Iron Coffins

[Kpt. Lehmann]

Originally Posted by LukeFF

Not hardly. He is a respected historian and took the time to do the research on the so-called "facts" presented in IC. Have you taken any time to conduct any research on the matter, or are you simply parroting the praise others here have for the book?

Originally Posted by LukeFF

Take it up with Dr. Rohwer if you don't like what I've written. Or did you not read my quoted comment up above about how, if all the errors in IC were underlined in red ink, the book would look like a bloodbath?

EVERY personal account of submarine warfare is written with the author'(s) spin on any given situation... REGARDLESS of nationality.

NO INDIVIDUAL ACCOUNT of submarine warfare should be viewed as a cross-section of typical life within any given branch.

Iron coffins is a great read whatever you BELIEVE or however you may FEEL about it or its surrounding subject matter.

What IS obvious is that you are unable to make your case with any class.

Take your attitude problem elsewhere.