[TEC]GR2 files and Granny Viewer

The .FBX format seems to be a viable export option for cross compatability.

The SDK is free also.

The .obj format is probably manditory for most people though.

So proposed formats could be:
.obj
.3DS
.FBX
.X
.dae

Multiple export options is a must as I see it.

After testing each format I believe the .3ds format would loose the least
amount of information on export from a GR2 file.

So that narrows it down to 2 formats I'd like to see.
.3DS
.OBJ

[Yosarian]

I would stop any attempt to decode the GR2 format, as with other games in the past RAD Game Tools the owner of Granny starts legal action against modders

[UberTorpedo]

privateer knows his way around the block. Just sit back and watch a genius at work.

[skwasjer]

Originally Posted by privateer

After testing each format I believe the .3ds format would loose the least
amount of information on export from a GR2 file.

So that narrows it down to 2 formats I'd like to see.
.3DS
.OBJ

Are you sure?

3DS is limited in that it's strings can only hold up 16 characters iirc (object names, material/texture names, etc) unless you use an extension, which makes it non-compatible to alot of 3D-programs/converters, something you'd want to prevent. It's why I dropped it for S3D.

OBJ is a big no as far as I am concerned because you have the same problems again with multiple uvw channels. What I built into S3D clearly is a hackjob and not a supported method of import by ANY 3D program. So you end up doing alot of handywork again to merge all channels.

Clearly, the only viable formats are those that support multiple uvw channels, and skeletal, mesh, matrix and texture animations (or at least a couple of these) and (VERY important!) meta data (stuff like visibility flag., matrix transforms, controller data or custom data)
The ones that come to mind are already mentioned:
- X (although I think it is officially dropped in favor for FBX)
- FBX
- Collada

[edit] But yea, in the end, you will hit a (legal) wall with regards to GR2. Unless we get an official 'endorsed' importer/exporter, best to forget about it, and hope full (legacy) DAT-support will be enabled in a future patch.

[Pintea]

Originally Posted by skwasjer

3DS is limited in that it's strings can only hold up 16 characters iirc (object names, material/texture names, etc) unless you use an extension, which makes it non-compatible to alot of 3D-programs/converters, something you'd want to prevent. It's why I dropped it for S3D.

Even more, it can't store objects with a higher vertex/poly count than 65536.

[skwasjer]

Originally Posted by Pintea

Even more, it can't store objects with a higher vertex/poly count than 65536.

Well true I forgot about that, but this wasn't a requirement for SH3/4 as DAT had same limit

Originally Posted by privateer

If someone is working on a Tool,
they have not stated so in this thread.

Not me

Originally Posted by privateer

If attempts were stopped in the past?
Most seem to have been stopped by the Game Developers
that use RAD Games Tools.

Perhaps you're right. S3D could have been stopped by Ubisoft too, for legal reasons. Still, the choice of GR2 is a wise choice from a developers perspective, but the fact that it's not an open format/SDK makes it very problematic to support by a community. DAT still isn't fully known after 5 years (although nearly there, just only that one byte in model chunk, and skeletal anim related stuff). And here we are now, we need to start over completely from scratch. It's not just how to decode it, the problem is games/3D are increasingly complex and thus more data needs to be figured out... That's a major step back without developer support.

You know, if only just they'd provide us with the header files and export some entrypoints, they don't even need to add support to Goblin...
[edit] I know about the granny DLL, but I rather not use that.

[urfisch]

to get the gr2 tools better known...i might can provide the dev-tools from rad to the ones, who need it in the hope to learn about/from it. just drop a pm. i got them from a friend of mine, but can not use them. they are only code files which need to be linked/added with the software you are working with. never understood how to do this. but i am no coder guy...maybe one of you is.

...Anvart
Personally i would like to have plug-ins for direct import of *.GR2 files into 3ds Max and corresponding export.

and...by the way:

http://gr2decode.altervista.org/docs.html

[thfeu58]

Originally Posted by skwasjer

[edit] But yea, in the end, you will hit a (legal) wall with regards to GR2. Unless we get an official 'endorsed' importer/exporter, best to forget about it, and hope full (legacy) DAT-support will be enabled in a future patch.

This will not happen. With which a big part of SH5 will not remain modifiable.

If someone is working on a Tool,
they have not stated so in this thread.

Most of the discussion here is hypothetical at this point.
It's a way to pass information about a POSSIBLE tool,
Without all the whineing and crabbing at the Devs
found in so many other threads.

I've stated many times my concern about Legal issues.
I've also visited every site I can find that concerns GR2 file structure.
I've found no concrete evidence that RAD Games is concerned
much about past attempts.
There's alot of code out there that could be removed at thier demand
but is not.

If attempts were stopped in the past?
Most seem to have been stopped by the Game Developers
that use RAD Games Tools.

@skwasjer,

Thanks for the information.
I was not aware of the limitations in the different formats.
It's a learning process for me at this point.

[coronas]

I don't sure if it's usefull or legal but...

http://aoe3.heavengames.com/cgi-bin/...f=14,36458,,10

[mookiemookie]

Originally Posted by privateer

I've stated many times my concern about Legal issues.
I've also visited every site I can find that concerns GR2 file structure.
I've found no concrete evidence that RAD Games is concerned
much about past attempts.
There's alot of code out there that could be removed at thier demand
but is not.

If attempts were stopped in the past?
Most seem to have been stopped by the Game Developers
that use RAD Games Tools.

I sincerely hope that this is true and all is okay with your work on the legal front. I'm having a bit of fun playing the arcadey goals of SH5 until someone gets a real campaign worked up, but I'm quickly losing interest due to the lack of ships out there. I'm getting tired of sinking the same 4 ships over and over.

[kylania]

Originally Posted by skwasjer

[edit] But yea, in the end, you will hit a (legal) wall with regards to GR2. Unless we get an official 'endorsed' importer/exporter, best to forget about it, and hope full (legacy) DAT-support will be enabled in a future patch.

Over on the Ubisoft forums they asked for questions to ask the devs. My question was if such tools as you're talking about will be released to players. Lets hope they answer it!