What can we really expect from SHV?

[JScones]

I want to know when Neal will be sent a beta copy of SH5 to preview? I remember Neal was sent a beta copy of both SH2 and SH3 well before release, which he independently previewed, but it didn't happen with SH4 (all Neal got was a controlled demo of what Ubisoft wanted him to see)...and we all know the state SH4 was in upon release...which is why I ask my question, considering it's now a mere 8 weeks or so until release (and we should be well past beta stage now).

[TDK1044]

Originally Posted by JScones

I want to know when Neal will be sent a beta copy of SH5 to preview? I remember Neal was sent a beta copy of both SH2 and SH3 well before release, which he independently previewed, but it didn't happen with SH4 (all Neal got was a controlled demo of what Ubisoft wanted him to see)...and we all know the state SH4 was in upon release...which is why I ask my question, considering it's now a mere 8 weeks until release (and we should be well past beta stage now).

DEV Q&A

Q: Will Neal Stevens at subsim get access to a Beta version of the game for review?

A: Giving someone who could potentially increase sales of the product a Beta copy of the game for review is an interesting idea. For that reason, we won't do it.

[JScones]

So true, oh so true...

[sharkbit]

Originally Posted by Steeltrap

IF SH5 is SHIII in SH4+ engine without addressing all those points then .

That pretty sums it up for me.

[mookiemookie]

Originally Posted by TDK1044

DEV Q&A

Q: Will Neal Stevens at subsim get access to a Beta version of the game for review?

A: We maybe might possibly consider this as a topic of future discussions at a later future date.

[THE_MASK]

Originally Posted by mookiemookie

A: We maybe might possibly consider this as a topic of future discussions at a later future date.

We are working on this right now; we thought about it and discussed it since the game was started. but you get what you get .

[Jimbuna]

Originally Posted by tdk1044

dev q&a

q: Will neal stevens at subsim get access to a beta version of the game for review?

A: Giving someone who could potentially increase sales of the product a beta copy of the game for review is an interesting idea. For that reason, we won't do it.

classic!! :dl

[Adriatico]

Originally Posted by sharkbit

That pretty sums it up for me.

[Deep Dive]

I found in a monthly magazine an interview of Dan Dimitrescu about SH5

What i find very interesting is his answer about the new dynamic campaign

"A typical SH5 patrol may start with the player sent to inert an axis agent on the coast of North Africa.Succeeding in this task will increase the level of intelligence you get from the area, and this in turn makes it easier to intercept their shipping.A week later, you might get an update about a supply convoy leaving for Malta.If you choose to go ahead and intercept them, and sink the tankers in convoys such as this, you might bring the island fortress to its knees.Like in real history, this doesn't mean they'll surrender straight away, but the bombers based there will lose some of their effectiveness, and the allies will launch Operation Pedestal." Dan Dimitrescu

WOW

[robbythesub]

My opinion as someone who thinks SH3 modded is the best game ever, is that as long as SH5 keeps the basics of SH3, but improves some key areas, then it will be a great hit.
For me, the missing imperitives in SH3 that would really enhance SH5 are-

1. Wolf packs interactive, with realistic radio received orders that you need to act on, rather than the historic but meaningless ones we get in SH3.

2. More variations in the weather, ie proper showers, rainbows and cloud formations, maybe even snow in some areas at the right times of year.

3. Medics who actually do something to help injured crew.

4. Better sound effect, an area where I feel SH3 lacks considerably.

I realise that some of these features will require a very strong PC but this wont deter those of us who update regularly!

I for one am very much looking forward to this latest version in this series.

[Onkel Neal]

Originally Posted by JScones

I want to know when Neal will be sent a beta copy of SH5 to preview? I remember Neal was sent a beta copy of both SH2 and SH3 well before release, which he independently previewed, but it didn't happen with SH4 (all Neal got was a controlled demo of what Ubisoft wanted him to see)...and we all know the state SH4 was in upon release...which is why I ask my question, considering it's now a mere 8 weeks or so until release (and we should be well past beta stage now).

I would like to know that myself

[JScones]

T'is a shame that they extend the "blackout" to you too, Neal, a person I suspect holds great influence over not just the members here, but anyone who would find your independent preview, based on actually playing the game, on-line. I remember well yours and Drebbel's updates prior to SH3 release...and you'll notice I wasn't a member here then.

Oh well, hope things change.

[AAtaman]

Originally Posted by TDK1044

So once you strip away the usual rhetoric, what can we really expect from Silent Hunter V? We've now seen some 'in game' videos and screenshots. We've also seen an interview with Dan. I'm sure there's more to come.

I think a pattern is evolving that shows us that we can basically expect a graphically improved, bells and whistles version of Silent Hunter IV patched to 1.5, with the addition of the 'first person' to give a much better crew interraction.

Reading between the lines, I don't believe it will be a SIM, although I think that it will be very modable. I also don't believe it will be an Arcade Game. I believe it will be a video game that can be modded up by the usual suspects, or dumbed way down using the Options tab.

I think that Ubisoft are pinning their hopes on the casual gamers to increase sales with this version of the Silent Hunter series. That won't please many here, but if allowing the game to be dumbed down via 'Options' increases sales and guarantees the continuation of the franchise, then it's not an issue as long as the game is very modable for those of us seeking a more realistic experience.

Based on what I've seen, I like the look and feel of Silent Hunter V. I think the Devs have taken on board observations and some criticism from members here, and I think they have done their best to deliver the standard of game demanded here, while also giving their employer what it demands from the game.

My greatest wish is that it's finished when it's released. I was disappointed with both SHIII and SHIV in that regard. To have to patch a game within a month of its release in order to fix 'game critical' issues is laughable, and I really hope that Ubisoft doesn't take us down that road again.

So, as we all wait for March 2010, I have more hope for SHV than I ever did for SHIII or SHIV.

What do you guys think?

The things i expect are,

1)Extreme realism
2)Many ways of upgrading my U-Boat,something like SH3.
3)It must be harder than SH3 and SH4.No U-Boat captain in WW2 had a tonnage of 200000-250000 in one patrol.
4)Smarter enemy.
5)Better communication.I have 1 torpedo left,%70 hull damage and in the middle of atlantic and request permision for returning to base.Answer is "Be more agressive"...Ok darling
6)Good atmosfhere of horror.When depht charged
7)Wolfpacks must be historically used.

I have 1 torpedo left,%70 hull damage and in the middle of atlantic and request permision for returning to base.Answer is "Be more agressive"...Ok darling

Brilliant!

[Jimbuna]

Originally Posted by JScones

T'is a shame that they extend the "blackout" to you too, Neal, a person I suspect holds great influence over not just the members here, but anyone who would find your independent preview, based on actually playing the game, on-line. I remember well yours and Drebbel's updates prior to SH3 release...and you'll notice I wasn't a member here then.

Oh well, hope things change.

Agreed....blasphemy, stone those Ubi heretics in suits