Published on 2 August 2024

[s0cks]

Originally Posted by RAM

I have to insist that no, it's not fair. This is like comparing two products, one just bought off-the-self, the other customized with a gazillion aftermarket add-ons and custom made modifications. You should compare them off-the-self, not one like that and the other with the gazillion aftermarket mods fit in.

But, ok, let's agree to disagree. At least we can agree on the second part of that quote, that it really wouldn't be far to say that Uboat will never be as good .

But why would I compare to vanilla SH3 if I'm not going to play vanilla SH3? It would be weird to say "I'm not going to play modded SH3 because vanilla SH3 is worse than UBOAT".


But I do get where you're coming from. I'm comparing a game that has not realised it's full potential to one that has. That's something that's definitely worth pointing out, but I'm not sure it makes it unfair.


Happy to agree to disagree. I think we're all having fun in either game regardless. I'm also excited to see where UBOAT will go!