Better planes?

[Cybermat47]

Originally Posted by gap

Thank you Cybermat47 for report the umpteenth SH5 inaccuracy

I am afraid it is not a mistake anyway: there is already a Short Sunderland in game, and the Z501's cfg file is pointing to that model. In other words both of them share the same model, and it seems that devs did so on purpose...

now, can you imagine two aircraft diverging more than these two





Other than being both flying object capable to land on water, they don't have anything in common...

The really disturbing thing is that IL2 Sturmovik, a flight sim made in 2003-06, and regarded as the best flight sim ever until World of Planes/Birds of Steel was released,was published by ubisoft

[THE_MASK]

As i recall they couldny have the catalina because of copywrite issue and mony wanted for use or something like that .

[gap]

Originally Posted by sober

As i recall they couldny have the catalina because of copywrite issue and mony wanted for use or something like that .

Yes, I think so: it was a copyright issue.

Originally Posted by Cybermat47

The really disturbing thing is that IL2 Sturmovik, a flight sim made in 2003-06, and regarded as the best flight sim ever until World of Planes/Birds of Steel was released,was published by ubisoft

Silent Hunter 5 was developped by Ubisoft Romania whereas IL2 Sturmovik was produced by the independent software developping company 1C/Maddox Games, and only distributed by Ubisoft ouside Russia. Different software houses, different licenses, different games: you cannot compare them in any way, and their differences in therms of quality are under anyone's eye, indeed

Finally I have a proposal for you: what about preparing a complete list of aircraft related SH5 blunders, and releasing a patch for addressing at least the worst of them? We could do it compatible with OHII so to allow Trevally to incorporate the fix in the next version of OHII, if both he and you like the idea.

An example about the missing Z501: we could assign to it the AS_USFloatEarlyWar model, unused after the introduction of the correct Catalina model. We could give it the same specs as the historical Z501, but not its aspect of course. Anyway textures can be corrected to resamble a generic italian aircraft, and for love of histrorical correctness we can change its roster name from "Z.501 Patrol Plane" to just "Patrol Plane", or something like that.

[Cybermat47]

Wellington and British VLR bomber appear as Sunderland
Bristol beufighter appears as either mosquito or Beaufort
Ju87 is the tank busting variant

[gap]

Originally Posted by Cybermat47

Wellington and British VLR bomber appear as Sunderland

Yes, I can see it from their cfg files

Originally Posted by Cybermat47

Bristol beufighter appears as either mosquito or Beaufort

from what I can see there's a model used for Mosquito MkVI/MkXVIII and another one for Beaufort/Beaufighter

Originally Posted by Cybermat47

Ju87 is the tank busting variant