Was the Mining Mod ever continued?

[LGN1]

Hi,

thanks for your replies!

I have some ideas I want to test to see whether I can include mine-laying missions in the SH3 campaign. I'm aware of all the limitations, but I think (like andqui) that it would still be great if you could get orders for laying mines during a career. Especially early in the war there were quite a few mine laying operations. These operations were very dangerous (i.e., thrilling in a simulation ) and in most cases did not lead to any recognizable success for the u-boats (what made these missions even more annoying).

One might argue that because the mines have no real effect in SH3, being able to lay mines in SH3 is not crucial for implementing mine-laying missions in SH3. That's true, however, I think it would add considerably to the immersion.

@Canovaro: All links I've found are dead Does anyone still have some files in his private archive?

Cheers, LGN1

Originally Posted by LGN1

Hi,

thanks for your replies!

I have some ideas I want to test to see whether I can include mine-laying missions in the SH3 campaign. I'm aware of all the limitations, but I think (like andqui) that it would still be great if you could get orders for laying mines during a career. Especially early in the war there were quite a few mine laying operations. These operations were very dangerous (i.e., thrilling in a simulation ) and in most cases did not lead to any recognizable success for the u-boats (what made these missions even more annoying).

One might argue that because the mines have no real effect in SH3, being able to lay mines in SH3 is not crucial for implementing mine-laying missions in SH3. That's true, however, I think it would add considerably to the immersion.

@Canovaro: All links I've found are dead Does anyone still have some files in his private archive?

Cheers, LGN1

Well good luck to you. If you get it figured out I would love to add it to my game.

If you can figure out how to change the career mission objective parameters, and say there completed when you lay mines in certain areas perhaps we can take it to another level. Like recon missions, or rescue missions, or enigma missions. Stuff like that. I'm not sure where to start on how to change mission objectives in the career game. I know Flotilla.cfg has the grids for the flotillas. But just changing those to whatever you want wont mean they'll get completed when you lay mines.

-pditty8811

[Hitman]

have some ideas I want to test to see whether I can include mine-laying missions in the SH3 campaign. I'm aware of all the limitations, but I think (like andqui) that it would still be great if you could get orders for laying mines during a career. Especially early in the war there were quite a few mine laying operations. These operations were very dangerous (i.e., thrilling in a simulation ) and in most cases did not lead to any recognizable success for the u-boats (what made these missions even more annoying).

One might argue that because the mines have no real effect in SH3, being able to lay mines in SH3 is not crucial for implementing mine-laying missions in SH3. That's true, however, I think it would add considerably to the immersion.

I agree with you, minelaying was an important, but also dangerous and much hated task for uboats in WW2. It should somehow make its way into the game, and because real commanders (And BdU) only rarely learned about ships sunk by their laid mines and got credit for them, leaving the area afterwards and having the mine dissapear is not a big issue.

That said, you can make the mines stay there for all the time you want it, even if they won't explode unless you are closeby (40km, the are where units are physically spawned and not just traced as abstract entities) and will not get any credit for anything they sink. How? Well, opening SH3 mission editor and adding a german minefield exactly where you accomplished your mission, with the number of mines and spacing you put them.

It can be done, it just will require some manual input from the player, though it could theoretically be automated by a Perl script that asks you for the parameters (Latitude/Longitude, number of mines, spacing) and then writes the minefield into the LND campaign layer for you.

In fact, what the script would ask you is what the real commander would fill in the report to BdU.

[SquareSteelBar]

Mine Layer

[Canovaro]

Originally Posted by SquareSteelBar

Mine Layer

That's the one.
Well I really would like it to work out, would be great.
Good luck!!

[LGN1]

Thanks for all your replies

Originally Posted by Hitman

That said, you can make the mines stay there for all the time you want it, even if they won't explode unless you are closeby (40km, the are where units are physically spawned and not just traced as abstract entities) and will not get any credit for anything they sink. How? Well, opening SH3 mission editor and adding a german minefield exactly where you accomplished your mission, with the number of mines and spacing you put them.

It can be done, it just will require some manual input from the player, though it could theoretically be automated by a Perl script that asks you for the parameters (Latitude/Longitude, number of mines, spacing) and then writes the minefield into the LND campaign layer for you.

I agree it would be easy. You could even mark the mines' positions on the map and later automatically extract these from a savegame and add the mines to the campaign layer. However, I don't think the effort is justified because you probably will never go back and see any effect.

Originally Posted by SquareSteelBar

Mine Layer

Great Thanks a lot. It's not the first time that your archive saves me, SSB! BTW, do you also have this old mod:

http://www.subsim.com/radioroom//sho...d.php?t=147445

Originally Posted by pditty8811

Do you have knowledge of Perl script editing? If so that would be awesome.

I was thinking something that would require a script also. But I have never done stuff like that before though I manually mod all the time. Here is a thread I started concerning an idea I had.

http://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=185828

If you have knowledge of script editing or could point me in the right direction I could do it myself.

-pditty8811

Hi pditty8811,

what exactly do you want the perl script to do? Remove a certain type, class, name,...? From what I understand at the moment it seems to me that the whole programming effort is not justified (in many years playing SH3 I've seen only one carrier and maybe five battleships in career mode)

Cheers, LGN1

Originally Posted by LGN1

Thanks for all your replies



I agree it would be easy. You could even mark the mines' positions on the map and later automatically extract these from a savegame and add the mines to the campaign layer. However, I don't think the effort is justified because you probably will never go back and see any effect.



Great Thanks a lot. It's not the first time that your archive saves me, SSB! BTW, do you also have this old mod:

http://www.subsim.com/radioroom//sho...d.php?t=147445



Hi pditty8811,

what exactly do you want the perl script to do? Remove a certain type, class, name,...? From what I understand at the moment it seems to me that the whole programming effort is not justified (in many years playing SH3 I've seen only one carrier and maybe five battleships in career mode)

Cheers, LGN1

Hi,

Perhaps you should beef up your SCR layer a bit and add some models to your Sea folder, never hurts to add ships. I have many ships and I know mods like GWX took the time to add particular ships to the SCR layer for historical accuracy. I like to add historical routes to these new ship models too.

Basically I would like to have a button in SH3 Commander, or not even, just a script to be triggered when a patrol is finished or before a patrol starts. This script would search the patrol log or captian's log for the class of ships that were sunk. This script would then use this information to tell the Campaign Editor program to delete these ships. Only classes like the Warspite or Elizabeth or something like that.


So, essentially this script would be the communication or link from the Captian's log, or patrol log, to the Campaign Editor. The editor would do the rest of the work.

-pditty8811

Originally Posted by Hitman

I agree with you, minelaying was an important, but also dangerous and much hated task for uboats in WW2. It should somehow make its way into the game, and because real commanders (And BdU) only rarely learned about ships sunk by their laid mines and got credit for them, leaving the area afterwards and having the mine dissapear is not a big issue.

That said, you can make the mines stay there for all the time you want it, even if they won't explode unless you are closeby (40km, the are where units are physically spawned and not just traced as abstract entities) and will not get any credit for anything they sink. How? Well, opening SH3 mission editor and adding a german minefield exactly where you accomplished your mission, with the number of mines and spacing you put them.

It can be done, it just will require some manual input from the player, though it could theoretically be automated by a Perl script that asks you for the parameters (Latitude/Longitude, number of mines, spacing) and then writes the minefield into the LND campaign layer for you.

In fact, what the script would ask you is what the real commander would fill in the report to BdU.

Do you have knowledge of Perl script editing? If so that would be awesome.

I was thinking something that would require a script also. But I have never done stuff like that before though I manually mod all the time. Here is a thread I started concerning an idea I had.

http://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=185828

If you have knowledge of script editing or could point me in the right direction I could do it myself.

-pditty8811

Hitman has a good idea.

Any scripting program would work.
Python, Perl, Lua, etc.

With Python you can create a stand alone exe that does not require a full install of Python also.
It's free, and easy to set up the whole thing.
I wrote a Python exe that converts specific 3D models to the Collada format in about a day when I first started with Python.

Originally Posted by privateer

Hitman has a good idea.

Any scripting program would work.
Python, Perl, Lua, etc.

With Python you can create a stand alone exe that does not require a full install of Python also.
It's free, and easy to set up the whole thing.
I wrote a Python exe that converts specific 3D models to the Collada format in about a day when I first started with Python.

Thanks I'll take a note of this program. I am currently busy at the momment but I will try to implement it with my dynamic campaign idea.

[bjorn]

In Battle for the Baltic (SH4) there is a playable minelayer vessel...

But also many minefields....eventualy stopped playing BFB because of the large amount of time u hav to put in avoiding these killing fields....

[Sepp von Ch.]

Originally Posted by LGN1

Hi,


- Does anyone ever released a mod for mine laying for SH3?

Hello, yes, Dietrich´s Uboat Armaments mod and Tomi_099’s VIID minelayer mod.