Silent Hunter 3 vs. Silent Hunter 5 ... who's the best?

[Jimbuna]

Originally Posted by TheDarkWraith

I have to disagree. With mods SH5 wins hands down . I have since shelved SH3 as it's just a disappointment to play with it's poor graphics and not having the things SH5 has (real nav, ship's journal, better AI (from IRAI), OHII, dynamic environment, etc.). Plus the modding ability of SH5 far exceeds anything that SH3 can give (allbeit it takes a little more skill to mod SH5 than the other SH series).

How arrogant...nothing new there though.

Some in this modding community have a longer CV and committment yet don't resort to sniping when the opportunity arises