Some clarification on magnetic exploders and the commands

Bubblehead1980 · 07-06-21, 10:26 PM

SUBPAC submarines were ordered to deactivate magnetic features of torpedoes on 24 June 1943. Stubbornly, COMSUBSOWESPAC boats in Fremantle were ordered to keep using them, which they did until 20 January 1944(!) , of course some skippers disobeyed orders and had them disabled while at sea, if had torpedoes aboard they would reactivate them, from what I read. No small chore, not like in the sim when we just flip a switch (kind of annoys me). Of course this revealed the mostly masked fault of the firign pins and resulted in many duds, which was resolved (mostly) in late September early October 1943.

Anyways , search for clarification on subs out of Brisbane. Brisbane boats were under Task Force 72 commanded by Admiral Fife, and Fife was a big part of exposing the torpedo problems from what I understand. Did he order the exploders deactivated as well or no? Ask as have read things including patrol reports indicating premature torpedo explosions in Brisbane based boats in Brisbane operating areas in November 1943 (Drum) .

Confused, wonder if someone can enlighten me.

mikesn9 · 07-09-21, 08:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bubblehead1980

SUBPAC submarines were ordered to deactivate magnetic features of torpedoes on 24 June 1943. Stubbornly, COMSUBSOWESPAC boats in Fremantle were ordered to keep using them, which they did until 20 January 1944(!) , of course some skippers disobeyed orders and had them disabled while at sea, if had torpedoes aboard they would reactivate them, from what I read. No small chore, not like in the sim when we just flip a switch (kind of annoys me). Of course this revealed the mostly masked fault of the firign pins and resulted in many duds, which was resolved (mostly) in late September early October 1943.

Anyways , search for clarification on subs out of Brisbane. Brisbane boats were under Task Force 72 commanded by Admiral Fife, and Fife was a big part of exposing the torpedo problems from what I understand. Did he order the exploders deactivated as well or no? Ask as have read things including patrol reports indicating premature torpedo explosions in Brisbane based boats in Brisbane operating areas in November 1943 (Drum) .

Confused, wonder if someone can enlighten me.

ALL kinds of info on this in "Silent Victory" book by Clay Blair Jr. Yes, Brisbane was way behind in de-activating any thing. Also, all the desk jockeys were NOT about to admit there was a problem with the torpedoes, It had to be the people firing them.

Bubblehead1980 · 07-09-21, 11:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mikesn9

ALL kinds of info on this in "Silent Victory" book by Clay Blair Jr. Yes, Brisbane was way behind in de-activating any thing. Also, all the desk jockeys were NOT about to admit there was a problem with the torpedoes, It had to be the people firing them.

Well, it has been a long time since read Silent Victor and no longer have my copy, went missing during a move or something. Definitely will order one.

07-10-21, 04:19 AM

If you allow me a completely different topic: I understand that you are in the process of expanding TMO 2.5. When do you publish that extension?

Bubblehead1980 · 07-10-21, 05:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by easy

If you allow me a completely different topic: I understand that you are in the process of expanding TMO 2.5. When do you publish that extension?

I planned to release end of June but still refining a few things, checking for bugs, and packaging together. I leave for two weeks of vacation on July 29th so plan is to release around 27th or 28th .

07-06-21, 10:26 PM	#1
Bubblehead1980 Navy Seal Join Date: Apr 2009 Location: Florida USA Posts: 7,104 Downloads: 605 Uploads: 44	Some clarification on magnetic exploders and the commands SUBPAC submarines were ordered to deactivate magnetic features of torpedoes on 24 June 1943. Stubbornly, COMSUBSOWESPAC boats in Fremantle were ordered to keep using them, which they did until 20 January 1944(!) , of course some skippers disobeyed orders and had them disabled while at sea, if had torpedoes aboard they would reactivate them, from what I read. No small chore, not like in the sim when we just flip a switch (kind of annoys me). Of course this revealed the mostly masked fault of the firign pins and resulted in many duds, which was resolved (mostly) in late September early October 1943. Anyways , search for clarification on subs out of Brisbane. Brisbane boats were under Task Force 72 commanded by Admiral Fife, and Fife was a big part of exposing the torpedo problems from what I understand. Did he order the exploders deactivated as well or no? Ask as have read things including patrol reports indicating premature torpedo explosions in Brisbane based boats in Brisbane operating areas in November 1943 (Drum) . Confused, wonder if someone can enlighten me.

07-10-21, 04:19 AM	#4
easy Stowaway Posts: n/a Downloads: Uploads:	@ Boubblehead1980: If you allow me a completely different topic: I understand that you are in the process of expanding TMO 2.5. When do you publish that extension?