Hello guys. How is sh5 doing these days?

[Bloomstomb]

Of course, I mean a fully modded up game.

Does it surpass SH4?

I have done some small mod work on sh3 in the past but when sh5 originally came out I was so disgusted that I shot the cd with a revolver. I didnt think anything could be done to rescue it. But then I felt terrible, knowing that this modding community is by far the best and the brightest of any gaming community. So... has it improved enough to buy it for 5 bucks?

[Deep Source]

No.

[Bloomstomb]

Hah.

Thanks m8

[89]

YEs.

Sh5 Magnetic torpedoes - check.

SH5 proper targeting system on level of Sh3-4 - check.

Sh5 wolfpacks -check.

Sh5 hydrophone fix - check.

Sh5 improved campaign (Open Horizons) -check.

SH5 ship sinking behaviour fix -check.

Sh5 still having the best graphics -check.

Is it worth $5?!!! Are you kidding me, its a fantastic game!

[TheDarkWraith]

Originally Posted by 89

Is it worth $5?!!! Are you kidding me, its a fantastic game!

I would have to agree. A little more work to do on it and no other subsim currently or in the past will even come close to it

You forgot:

CO2 bug fix - check
Sub hull taking damage from DCs - check

working on making the AI gunners much more accurate. Hopefully will have patch for that soon.

[col_Kurtz]

Originally Posted by Bloomstomb

Of course, I mean a fully modded up game.

Does it surpass SH4?

I have done some small mod work on sh3 in the past but when sh5 originally came out I was so disgusted that I shot the cd with a revolver. I didnt think anything could be done to rescue it. But then I felt terrible, knowing that this modding community is by far the best and the brightest of any gaming community. So... has it improved enough to buy it for 5 bucks?

I think - yes. With all mods I think this game is worth more than 5 bucks now. Definitely much more

[Akula4745]

Originally Posted by 89

Is it worth $5?!!! Are you kidding me, its a fantastic game!

So true... with all credit to all the wonderful modders, Silent Hunter 5 is now a great game to play. You can have total realism, or any variant of that you would like. The hard core guys might laugh... but with the proper adjustments to TDW's IRAI, I can have the "gaming" experience of WWII Uboat combat - just with a slightly increased probability of survival!

The answer to your question is a resounding "YES" - thanks to all the modders!

[Malhard]

Yes yes yes definitely yes.

[thebeasle]

Originally Posted by Bloomstomb

So... has it improved enough to buy it for 5 bucks?

No not at all. Despite the work of all the great modders here at subsim, SH5 is still not worth the price of a pack of cigarettes, a drink in a bar, or half a movie ticket.

What a joke. SH5 has been better than SH4 and SH3 (GWX) for a while now. TDW's UI upgrade and Trevally's Open Horizons campaign make the game the best in series IMHO.

[tonschk]

I agree

Originally Posted by thebeasle

TDW's UI upgrade and Trevally's Open Horizons campaign make the game the best in series IMHO.

[Charlie901]

Except for realistic reacting crew...

[radcapricorn]

Originally Posted by tmpat36

This has to the most frustrating mod to install. Waste of time. SH5 with this mod is still a TURD. after the tdw mod soup it's a painted TURD. You'd have to be an autistic obsessive to go through this insane install. Absolute abortion.

Originally Posted by tmpat36

TDW ,adds a layer of bugs on top of what is a disaster of a sim.

Are you having a bad day, sir?

[volodya61]

@radcapricorn

I think that it's useless to talk with terminally sick being..

[gap]

Originally Posted by volodya61

@radcapricorn

I think that it's useless to talk with terminally sick being..

Yep, someone here is looking to be banned

[Sailor Steve]

Originally Posted by volodya61

@radcapricorn

I think that it's useless to talk with terminally sick being..

We do not insult other members here at Subsim. Radcapricorn insulted the mod he didn't like. That is his privilege. Namecalling is not allowed here. This is an official warning.