Default Situation: should I disobey BdU orders?

DirtyACE · 02-11-10, 05:04 PM

I'm currently on my first patrol in the Atlantic, about 200km north-west of Ireland. There's a convoy going to England, of which I sent a contact report to the BdU. They in return gave me an objective of targeting tankers within it. There are a few tankers, however, they're flying flags of nations (Greece and Panama) who are not yet in war with Germany. Should I go ahead and sink them anyway or disobey my superiors' orders?

One other question. I also noticed that the some of the Greek merchant ships have guns on them and they do try to shoot at me, even though they're supposed to neutral at this time. Can I sink these ships as well in that case, since they are being hostile to me?
Last edited by DirtyACE; 02-11-2010 at 01:37 PM.

Sailor Steve · 02-11-10, 07:26 PM

Op Monsun? I don't think Lurker has the neutrals showing up as such, though I could be wrong. I think you get full credit for sinking them, even neutrals.

If they are neutral they shouldn't shoot at you unless you shoot them first. If my above summation is correct, avoid them at all costs.

DirtyACE · 02-11-10, 08:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sailor Steve

Op Monsun? I don't think Lurker has the neutrals showing up as such, though I could be wrong. I think you get full credit for sinking them, even neutrals.

If they are neutral they shouldn't shoot at you unless you shoot them first. If my above summation is correct, avoid them at all costs.

Yes I'm playing Op Monsoon.

So you're saying that all ships are fair game? There's no penalty or anything for sinking neutrals?

Yeah it's weird that they shoot at me because I was doing my best not to shoot at them. I only targeted ships flying the British flag.

Galanti · 02-15-10, 02:54 PM

There's a bug in SH4 which means nuetrals aren't really so neutral....so to avoid general awkwardness, I believe all ships are designated as enemy or allied, regardless of whichever flag they fly. In other words, there are no penalties for sinking ships that you think may be nuetral.

I would roleplay it. I leave singletons alone if they are flying the flag of a neutral country during the timeframe I'm in; however, if they are in convoy they are fair game, which I believe was BdU policy.

02-11-10, 05:04 PM	#1
DirtyACE Engineer Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: Portland, OR Posts: 213 Downloads: 28 Uploads: 0	Default Situation: should I disobey BdU orders? I'm currently on my first patrol in the Atlantic, about 200km north-west of Ireland. There's a convoy going to England, of which I sent a contact report to the BdU. They in return gave me an objective of targeting tankers within it. There are a few tankers, however, they're flying flags of nations (Greece and Panama) who are not yet in war with Germany. Should I go ahead and sink them anyway or disobey my superiors' orders? One other question. I also noticed that the some of the Greek merchant ships have guns on them and they do try to shoot at me, even though they're supposed to neutral at this time. Can I sink these ships as well in that case, since they are being hostile to me? Last edited by DirtyACE; 02-11-2010 at 01:37 PM.

02-11-10, 07:26 PM	#2
Sailor Steve Eternal Patrol Join Date: Nov 2002 Location: High in the mountains of Utah Posts: 50,369 Downloads: 745 Uploads: 249	Op Monsun? I don't think Lurker has the neutrals showing up as such, though I could be wrong. I think you get full credit for sinking them, even neutrals. If they are neutral they shouldn't shoot at you unless you shoot them first. If my above summation is correct, avoid them at all costs. __________________ “Never do anything you can't take back.” —Rocky Russo

02-15-10, 02:54 PM	#4
Galanti Captain Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Ottawa Posts: 536 Downloads: 106 Uploads: 0	There's a bug in SH4 which means nuetrals aren't really so neutral....so to avoid general awkwardness, I believe all ships are designated as enemy or allied, regardless of whichever flag they fly. In other words, there are no penalties for sinking ships that you think may be nuetral. I would roleplay it. I leave singletons alone if they are flying the flag of a neutral country during the timeframe I'm in; however, if they are in convoy they are fair game, which I believe was BdU policy.