Tom Chick's Silent Hunter 4 review in Gamespy

[Onkel Neal]

If you've read the "Thanks!" section of the 2007 Submarine Almanac, you know I hold Tom in high regard. He gave SH3 a 5 out of 5 star review, (doesn't mean perfect, etc) which took some heat off yours truly for leading the glowing praise with a 100 rating (doesn't mean perfect, etc).

Note, Tom is a serious sim guy, he's not a PS2 clone who was assigned SH4, so I feel his criticisms are valid and should be taken seriously.

There's a reason there are more movies about submarines than there are about jets with hi-tech avionics. This is a visceral and straightforward type of warfare, with dramatic turns of fortune and an exciting hunter/hunted dynamic.

Tom Chick and the sub that won't go down

good hunting!
Neal