Which silent hunter series was released in baddest state?

[IanC]

Originally Posted by John Channing

I guess you do.

69.9% of 103 people (as of now) is not the same as unanimous.

When one game out of five, gets 70% of the vote. That's pretty darn unanimous to me, sorry.

[Nisgeis]

Originally Posted by IanC

When one game out of five, gets 70% of the vote. That's pretty darn unanimous to me, sorry.

Unanimous means that everyone chooses the same option. Un-amaorous yes, unanimous, no.

[IanC]

Originally Posted by Nisgeis

Unanimous means that everyone chooses the same option. Un-amaorous yes, unanimous, no.

You guys can post dictionary definitions and hair split all you want, doesn't change the fact that one game out of five got 70% of the votes all to itself. Unanimous? Heck yes.

[Nisgeis]

Originally Posted by IanC

Unanimous? Heck yes.

Yet still, in a much more real and correct sense, no.

I understand the point you are trying to make, but you communicated it poorly and it caused some confusion which needed clarification. What you meant is right, but what you said is not.

[Méo]

Anyway, all this is extremely subjective.

I did try the game and didn't vote cuz too bored with all those polls (I would have vote for SH4).

And how many members here have voted for a game which they didn't even give a try ? ...

[IanC]

Originally Posted by Nisgeis

Yet still, in a much more real and correct sense, no.

I understand the point you are trying to make, but you communicated it poorly and it caused some confusion which needed clarification. What you meant is right, but what you said is not.

... like I said, you can 'literal hair-split' all day long if you want.

[Nisgeis]

Originally Posted by IanC

... like I said, you can 'literal hair-split' all day long if you want.

Hey, I'm just trying to help you out, no need to get defensive.

[SurfnSea]

Originally Posted by mookiemookie

Eh...? A frame shot from the movie Das Boot?

[IanC]

Originally Posted by Nisgeis

Hey, I'm just trying to help you out, no need to get defensive.

I know an attempt at baiting when I see one... this is the end of our 'discussion'. I'll just let the votes speak for themselves.

[Nisgeis]

Originally Posted by IanC

I know an attempt at baiting when I see one...

If you're implying that my post was one, then no, you don't know one. . But you're right, let's agree to agree unanimously and leave it at that.

[desertstriker]

i would have to say SH4... buggy as heck and the controls where weird. i pity the guy that bought it off of ebay 1 week after i tried it.

[Jimbuna]

Another necro

[Sailor Steve]

[finchOU]

^^^^hahaha^^^^^ seriously!

I just now voted SH2.....it had the unfortunate privilege of being the first Uboat sim I picked up after not playing for about 8 years or so. The sim before it was AOTD. So yeah... I was very disappointed to say the least minus the bugs....but it took the cake for crap out of a computer game box. SH3 at leasssst had the campaign.... I was just amazed at the step backwards (minus graphics) the genre had taken from AOTD. Of course I feel the same way about Cliffs of Dover right now to....Why!!???!!? Just why!!???! haha

[GT182]

Originally Posted by Ducimus

This is just a guess:

Silent hunter 3
Silent hunter 3
Silent hunter 3
Silent hunter 3
Silent hunter 3

I agree on 3 but 5 is slowly catching up. If the SH3 grid map and campaign could be like SH3's is, 5 would be a handsdown winner in my book. Even more so it the Type II and IX Uboats could be added to 5.

But to be honest, SH3 wasn't too dam good out of the box either. Especially with StarForce in it. And just as much modding was done to it to make it what it is now. At least from what I've seen and read, SH3 was much simpler mod than 5 is.