Alec Baldwin formally charged with Manslaughter in 'Rust’ shooting of Halyna Hutchins

[Jimbuna]

IMHO it was a tragic accident but if negligence is proven then the person at fault will obviously be answerable.

[MaDef]

Originally Posted by Jimbuna

IMHO it was a tragic accident but if negligence is proven then the person at fault will obviously be answerable.

I handle firearms on a daily basis, this was no accident, it was an incident, and it was negligent on the part of both the onsite armorer and Baldwin.

[Jimbuna]

Originally Posted by MaDef

I handle firearms on a daily basis, this was no accident, it was an incident, and it was negligent on the part of both the onsite armorer and Baldwin.

The courts will decide.

[les green01]

[mapuc]

My first experience with firearms was when I was around 8-10 years old and it was my uncle Who taught me important things like.

1. Always treat the gun/rifle as it was loaded.
2. Never point the gun/rifle at someone.
3. When checking for dirt in the (forgot the word) you look from behind-Where the thing use to sit(you have removed it to clean to see if this pipe is clean-By watching it from behind up against some light.

Markus

[les green01]

John Schneider explains everything in them videos hope you guys watches them.John Schneider been doing tv and movies since late 70's so he is a expert on sets and stuff but anyway you put it a bullet has no brains it is going hit where aim

[MaDef]

Originally Posted by Jimbuna

The courts will decide.

the law is pretty clear on what constitutes "involuntary Manslaughter" and the rules governing the safe handling of firearms is also quite clear.
New Mexico's statute regarding manslaughter:

B. Involuntary manslaughter consists of manslaughter committed in the commission of an unlawful act not amounting to felony, or in the commission of a lawful act which might produce death in an unlawful manner or without due caution and circumspection.

4 rules of firearm handling:

1. Always Keep Firearm Pointed in a Safe direction. Never point your gun at
anything you do not intend to shoot.
2. Treat All Guns as Though They are Loaded.
3. Keep Your Finger Off the Trigger until You are Ready to Shoot.
4. Always Be Sure of Your Target and What's Beyond It.

The FBI tested the firearm in question and found no mechanical or material defects, nor could they get the weapon to fire without pulling the trigger.

Baldwin broke rules 1 and 3, and a woman died as a result, He's guilty as charged.

[Buddahaid]

Originally Posted by MaDef

the law is pretty clear on what constitutes "involuntary Manslaughter" and the rules governing the safe handling of firearms is also quite clear.
New Mexico's statute regarding manslaughter:

B. Involuntary manslaughter consists of manslaughter committed in the commission of an unlawful act not amounting to felony, or in the commission of a lawful act which might produce death in an unlawful manner or without due caution and circumspection.

4 rules of firearm handling:

1. Always Keep Firearm Pointed in a Safe direction. Never point your gun at
anything you do not intend to shoot.
2. Treat All Guns as Though They are Loaded.
3. Keep Your Finger Off the Trigger until You are Ready to Shoot.
4. Always Be Sure of Your Target and What's Beyond It.

The FBI tested the firearm in question and found no mechanical or material defects, nor could they get the weapon to fire without pulling the trigger.

Baldwin broke rules 1 and 3, and a woman died as a result, He's guilty as charged.

That's the way I see it. Given the ridiculous expense of producing movies today, it's hard to justify using a functional firearm anymore.

Now for the edit.
Actors are just that, actors. It's not expected for them to be experienced firearm owners with well drilled safety habits. In Star Trek, it was common for the actors to be firing their phaser practicals accidently, and you can see it get past the cutting room into final product at times. The question I have is did Baldwin know the prop gun was a functional firearm? "Cold" gun, or not, did he know? Was he expected to know it was a functional firearm because he was informed it was?

[les green01]

Originally Posted by Buddahaid

That's the way I see it. Given the ridiculous expense of producing movies today, it's hard to justify using a functional firearm anymore.

Now for the edit.
Actors are just that, actors. It's not expected for them to be experienced firearm owners with well drilled safety habits. In Star Trek, it was common for the actors to be firing their phaser practicals accidently, and you can see it get past the cutting room into final product at times. The question I have is did Baldwin know the prop gun was a functional firearm? "Cold" gun, or not, did he know? Was he expected to know it was a functional firearm because he was informed it was?

since the movie in question is a western i'll answer with western all westerns start to end uses real firearms the so call prop guns are made out of plastic or rubber and are use for throwing a firearm stuff like where you wouldn't damage the real deal.so let talk Duke last movie the shootest after Ron Hower shoots the bartender and throws the firearm that was a prop gun as the real pair was a presentation that was giving too Duke,josie wales real although they did use a rubber walker in one part of the movie,some movies they do use nra trainers,the movie gettyburg most of the guys in it are reenactors so during the shoot little round top where the camera is infront of the The 20th Maine Volunteer Infantry Regiment reenactors and they are firing just blackpower into the camera the crew is behind a prixyglass,they shouldnt been a live round anywhere around the set of rusk so much safety was thrown out of the window i'm surspise didn't happen sooner

[Platapus]

I hope this will result in significant changes on movie sets.


1. There is no need to use real guns. Fake guns can be manufactured that are identical in appearance to real guns. Also gun flashes and gun noises are always fixed in post. The only thing the actor/gun has to do is simulate the recoil and honestly when was the last movie that had actual recoils in it? Actors are paid a lot of money to.. well.. act as in making believe they are doing something.



2. There should never, and I mean never, be live ammunition on a movie set with the exception of security forces.



3. If there is recreational shooting on an outdoor set (a really bad idea) , the shooting needs to be done off set in another area. The recreational shooting range should have no overlap with the film set. The set needs to be cleared of all weapons and ammunition before it is opened to the filming crew/cast. That means everything is inventoried and locked up before work starts.



This is day one stuff, film crews.

[Dowly]

BTW, here's a playlist of interrogations of various people (including Baldwin) involved in the accident:
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?lis...kox2rqd5li0HXV

[les green01]

John Schnider did some youtube stuff way they do it first several times each person check make sure it unloaded 1873 sa means spinning the clinder and poping it out alex and them didn't do it next they look at the rounds guess what they didnt do that 1873 sa you got to thumb the hammer back only two ways it will go off if the hammer is resting on a round and gets hit or a hair trigger fbi check the weapon out no faults of the weapon so he did it and he should stop telling bs lies

[Commander Wallace]

Originally Posted by les green01

John Schnider did some youtube stuff way they do it first several times each person check make sure it unloaded 1873 sa means spinning the clinder and poping it out alex and them didn't do it next they look at the rounds guess what they didnt do that 1873 sa you got to thumb the hammer back only two ways it will go off if the hammer is resting on a round and gets hit or a hair trigger fbi check the weapon out no faults of the weapon so he did it and he should stop telling bs lies

I saw this John Schneider Youtube video as well. I completely agreed with his assessment as well.