Hello + the fateful question: which one is the most realistic?

04-15-22, 02:16 PM

Thank you all, and thank you Bilge Rat for the comprehensive assessment.

I didn't mention SH4 because I'm a lot less fascinated by US WW2 subs and the Pacific Theatre.

Anyway, at the moment I'm dabbling with Aces Of The Deep, reading its manual, etc. I like the atmosphere it creates. I'm not bothered by the old visuals, nor the lack of external views.

I want to find out if I really like sub sims when playing them seriously, before possibly investing more time in them.

If that'll be the case, I could try SH4 (for a change from U-Boots) and then Wolfpack, which seems a very interesting product.

View Poll Results: Most "realistic" subsim?
Aces Of The Deep	1	8.33%
Silent Hunter III + mods	5	41.67%
Silent Hunter V + mods	4	33.33%
UBOAT + mods	1	8.33%
Wolfpack	3	25.00%
Multiple Choice Poll. Voters: 12. You may not vote on this poll

04-15-22, 02:16 PM	#5
Murmur79 Stowaway Posts: n/a Downloads: Uploads:	Thank you all, and thank you Bilge Rat for the comprehensive assessment. I didn't mention SH4 because I'm a lot less fascinated by US WW2 subs and the Pacific Theatre. Anyway, at the moment I'm dabbling with Aces Of The Deep, reading its manual, etc. I like the atmosphere it creates. I'm not bothered by the old visuals, nor the lack of external views. I want to find out if I really like sub sims when playing them seriously, before possibly investing more time in them. If that'll be the case, I could try SH4 (for a change from U-Boots) and then Wolfpack, which seems a very interesting product.