Silent Hunter 4 or 5?

[KaleunMarco]

Originally Posted by JonasPersonal

Which is better

welcome to subsim.



SH4 and SH5 are completely different. 4 is pacific, 5 is atlantic...although SH4 has a megamod that allows you to play atlantic.
the other large difference is that SH4 is a followup app from SH3 which was wildly popular.

SH5 is point-and-click, move around the boat, you have to perform most tasks yourself. that sentence you have been all one word.
some players want to walk through the various hatches and ladders and see the boat.
others want to play a sub simulation where you command a crew and try to sink ships.

i prefer SH4. greatly.
but it is up to you.
good luck.