Which game should I buy? III vs IV vs V

Brett Sinclair · 04-14-17, 12:46 PM

Thank you very much for your replies!
There seems to be great love for SH3, and I can see why.
Currently I actually tend to buy SH4. With the "Operation Monsoon" mod I can apparently play all U Boote (U boats) on all seven seas. Something I cannot do with SH5 and only with worse graphics in SH3.
@Sailor Steve: Which "irreplaceable" SH3 mods do you use? And which mods fixed SH5?
One last question: Subsim's review of SH5 states "For the first time, the campaign is truly 'dynamic.'" What does it actually mean? Does SH3 and SH4 feel scripted after a while?

Best,
Brett

View Poll Results: Which game should I buy?
Silent Hunter III	22	75.86%
Silent Hunter IV	6	20.69%
Silent Hunter V	1	3.45%
Voters: 29. You may not vote on this poll

04-14-17, 12:46 PM	#5
Brett Sinclair Loader Join Date: Apr 2017 Location: Davy Jones’ Locker Posts: 89 Downloads: 46 Uploads: 0	Thank you very much for your replies! There seems to be great love for SH3, and I can see why. Currently I actually tend to buy SH4. With the "Operation Monsoon" mod I can apparently play all U Boote (U boats) on all seven seas. Something I cannot do with SH5 and only with worse graphics in SH3. @Sailor Steve: Which "irreplaceable" SH3 mods do you use? And which mods fixed SH5? One last question: Subsim's review of SH5 states "For the first time, the campaign is truly 'dynamic.'" What does it actually mean? Does SH3 and SH4 feel scripted after a while? Best, Brett