Hitler would've won the war if. . .

micky1up · 03-24-06, 05:31 PM

STeed old friend you dont seem to get the point your too ridged in the idea that whatever could have happened germany couldn't have beaten russia , in fact you made my point in the napoleon part what if grouchy had joined napoleon insted of aimlessly following the prussians ? all im saying that there are to many variable's in how an battle is won to say in different circumstances that germany could never have won , you seems to reject any speculation out of hand that things could have turned out differently . napoleon was beaten fair and square by a much inferior force , all that i really am saying that sometimes no matter how much of an advantage u have in suplies and men logistics and weaponry you will at some stage get a spanking history is repleat with stories of stronger bigger more advanced armys losing because u can for definte caculate who is going to win or lose on the strength of logistics numbers and indeed as shown weather

p.s indeed to reinforce my point every book and documentery ive seen and read written and presented by proven experts in military history have all said that the russian campaign was a close run thing in 1941 ,42 and indeed the the point when germany really lost it was kursk up til that point much of the campaign had went germanys way

03-24-06, 05:31 PM	#11
micky1up Captain Join Date: Nov 2002 Location: helensburgh Posts: 525 Downloads: 2 Uploads: 0	STeed old friend you dont seem to get the point your too ridged in the idea that whatever could have happened germany couldn't have beaten russia , in fact you made my point in the napoleon part what if grouchy had joined napoleon insted of aimlessly following the prussians ? all im saying that there are to many variable's in how an battle is won to say in different circumstances that germany could never have won , you seems to reject any speculation out of hand that things could have turned out differently . napoleon was beaten fair and square by a much inferior force , all that i really am saying that sometimes no matter how much of an advantage u have in suplies and men logistics and weaponry you will at some stage get a spanking history is repleat with stories of stronger bigger more advanced armys losing because u can for definte caculate who is going to win or lose on the strength of logistics numbers and indeed as shown weather p.s indeed to reinforce my point every book and documentery ive seen and read written and presented by proven experts in military history have all said that the russian campaign was a close run thing in 1941 ,42 and indeed the the point when germany really lost it was kursk up til that point much of the campaign had went germanys way