![]() |
SUBSIM: The Web's #1 resource for all submarine & naval simulations since 1997 |
|
![]() |
#1 |
Commodore
![]() Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Augsburg / Germany
Posts: 631
Downloads: 203
Uploads: 0
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#2 | |
Ace of the Deep
![]() Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 1,288
Downloads: 85
Uploads: 0
|
![]()
It's a conspiracy theory based on a conspiracy theory. I did some research on that so let me summarize what I know.
1. It is known for sure that Germany did explore parts of Antarctic now know as Queen Maud Land, and named these Neuschwabenland (New Swabia). Their 1938 expetition is well established: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Swa...281938-1939.29 However, no facilities there were established officially. 2. There are some facts suggesting that Germans did in fact establish an U-boot base in the region. The evidence is that (1) crew members of the first expedition themselves saying that they made repeated trips to Antarctic transporting heavy equipment and (2) German U-boots were still operating in South Atlantic after the capitulation of Berlin, which implies existence of German supply base in the region, and (3) Admiral Dönitz is on record saying in 1943 that Quote:
3. A historical fact is that the US did a military expedition in the region in 1946-7, known as Operation Highjump (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Highjump), under the command of Admiral Richard E. Byrd. The expedition encountered losses and returned home early. Official statements say that the losses were due to accidents. That much is proven historical record. Now, we go to "fringie" land. A. A primary conspiracy theory is that the purported German submarine facility (see 2) did in fact exist, and U.S. losses during Operation Highjump were caused by fighting with the German forces. A variant of that theory is that upon encountering the Germans Americans were routed / turned back, and Operation Highjump in 1955 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Deep_Freeze) was in fact a (successful) military operation against remaining German forces. There are even claims that nuclear weapons were used. A major weakness in this theory is: why wouldn't the Germans simply surrender to the Americans? An operational submarine base could be easily traded for immunity. B. Coming back to US after premature termination of Operation Highjump, Byrd was interviewed by a newspaper in Argentina. From Wikipedia: In the interview Byrd warned of an imminent attack on the United States and the necessity to "remain in a state of alert and watchfulness" and take defensive precautions against "the possibility of an invasion of the country by hostile aircraft proceeding from the polar regions". Byrd said, "I do not want to scare anybody but the bitter reality is that in the event of a new war the United States will be attacked by aircraft flying in from over one or both poles." This, combined with the theory of German research into UFOs/antigravity, is taken as a confirmation of an existence of a German UFO base in the Antarctic region. However, a much simpler explanation exists: the shortest route from US to Soviet Union is over the North Pole, so, Soviet bombers attacking U.S. targets would be "proceeding from the polar regions". This also explains U.S. military expeditions to the polar regions after WWII: they were required to train for future US/USSR combat operations in the North Polar region. C. An extreme version of the German UFO theory is a text known as "Byrd's secret diary". It's a purported account of Byrd doing flying over Queen Maud Land, encountering UFOs, being forced to land in an oasis around a hot spring and finally interviewed by an alien speaking in German. This text was demonstrated to be a fake. The evidence of a fake is that at the beginning of the report Byrd notes engine problems, and the engine malfunction is identical to one he actually encountered several years prior. But having an identical mechanical problem, in the same phase of the mission, in two different aircraft several years apart is improbable. So the author of the fake probably took Byrd's actual flight report from 1930s, and added the part about UFOs. There. I hope it clears up the issue. But I doubt it. ![]() |
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
|