Should I get SH4?

[Renesco]

Originally Posted by Rockin Robbins

American subs were capable of winning. German subs were not. Which were the better subs? Just playing the games SH3 and SH4 leaves no doubt that the American subs were superior war machines by a large margin over the WWI designs of German U-Boats used in WWII. And the games give only an incomplete picture of how bad the comparison really was.

German subs had less striking power as the yank ones have mostly 6 forward 4 aft and superior radar, but German subs had a much deeper diving depth and snorkels, and were fighting an uphill battle versus airpower and a large enemy surface navy yet still nearly strangled England, also the XXI was the pioneer of most cold war subs. The Americans had it easy by comparison, with air power and surface naval power on their side.

Just because the soviet union won the war for you does not mean your subs were better than the German ones, correlation is not causation in this instance.