2011 SUBSIM Werewolf Game: Intro, Rules, FAQ, & Aftermath

[Bakkels]

Originally Posted by Neal Stevens

That is a great question.... what do you guys think?

Hm, I think he wouldn't be able to recognize the person. This would make him kind of like a seer wouldn't it? At least in the original game as I know it (but that's the 'real life' party game), the guardian assigns someone to protect, and then closes his eyes again before the werewolves wake up to make a kill.
And in that version, the wolves know who the other wolves are. They don't know that in our version, so they're already handicapped. Allowing a guardian to recognize the werewolf would make it even harder on them I think.