WW II Magazine review of SH5

Zedi · 06-02-10, 10:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Faamecanic

Seems like you disagree with anyone that doesnt give SH5 a 8 out of 10 star review.

Keep in mind MOST people are playing an unmodded game where you pretty much DO have to run around the boat to give orders. And if you dont then where in the manual does it say how to NOT run around the boat to give orders.... oh thats right...the manual is a joke and woefully incomplete.

Maybe they added the function to NOT have to run around the ship in the 1.2 patch... but maybe the reviewer played the game Pre-patch (which even PC gamer reviews games ONLY pre-patch, and rarely revists them post patch).

Bottom line is this game was worth about 10 hours of my time.... before I moved on and now await the final patch and mods. I refuse to waste my time with a sim that is so incomplete. I have other games that were actually, GASP, released 90% complete or more, that deserve my time more than SH5 does now.

I play without mods, as I wrote few post ago. Old people tend to have some serious issues with orientation in 3D spaces, I remember many complained that they cant exit the sub as they don't know how to use the ladder

I mean, c'mon .. that's the only problem with SH5? Orientation, difficulties in moving around the sub and talk with the crew? I saw nothing mentioned about the God damn retard (pre-patch) AI, the boring campaign and the stupid missions.. you know, the real problems. Those guys should quit playing video games, or at least write reviews about.

Anyway, I doubt Ubi give a frak about that review, the biggest hits in the stomach was from the Eurogamer and Subsim review, those hurts really hard and is really bad for business. So if any1 want a good and comprehensive review, read those 2 mentioned... this one is a joke.

robbo180265 · 06-02-10, 11:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Magnum

I play without mods, as I wrote few post ago. Old people tend to have some serious issues with orientation in 3D spaces, I remember many complained that they cant exit the sub as they don't know how to use the ladder

I mean, c'mon .. that's the only problem with SH5? Orientation, difficulties in moving around the sub and talk with the crew? I saw nothing mentioned about the God damn retard (pre-patch) AI, the boring campaign and the stupid missions.. you know, the real problems. Those guys should quit playing video games, or at least write reviews about.

Anyway, I doubt Ubi give a frak about that review, the biggest hits in the stomach was from the Eurogamer and Subsim review, those hurts really hard and is really bad for business. So if any1 want a good and comprehensive review, read those 2 mentioned... this one is a joke.

My thoughts exactly

M4XDmG · 06-02-10, 11:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Magnum

I play without mods, as I wrote few post ago. Old people tend to have some serious issues with orientation in 3D spaces, I remember many complained that they cant exit the sub as they don't know how to use the ladder I mean, c'mon .. that's the only problem with SH5? Orientation, difficulties in moving around the sub and talk with the crew? I saw nothing mentioned about the God damn retard (pre-patch) AI, the boring campaign and the stupid missions.. you know, the real problems. Those guys should quit playing video games, or at least write reviews about.

Anyway, I doubt Ubi give a frak about that review, the biggest hits in the stomach was from the Eurogamer and Subsim review, those hurts really hard and is really bad for business. So if any1 want a good and comprehensive review, read those 2 mentioned... this one is a joke.

Everybody has a right to have an opinion, but it is sad that you think old people should stop playing videogames.

I really HAD problems with ladders at first. It was a big problem and annoyed me much. Now I don't know why it was so hard, but it was. And I don't have orientation problems in 3d spaces. Hmm... oh well, I'm not old either, unless one thinks that someone in mid twenties is old.

But I agree about that review. You should not write reviews unless you know what you're talking about.

Nisgeis · 06-02-10, 01:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by M4XDmG

I really HAD problems with ladders at first. It was a big problem and annoyed me much. Now I don't know why it was so hard, but it was.

The game workls differently that a lot of 3D environments, in that if you look up at the hatch you want to go to, then you can't 'engage' on the ladder. Now you know where the hatch is, you just go for the ladder instead of looking up. It caused a few people problems, due to the design choice they made.

Buddahaid · 06-02-10, 07:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Magnum

I play without mods, as I wrote few post ago. Old people tend to have some serious issues with orientation in 3D spaces, I remember many complained that they cant exit the sub as they don't know how to use the ladder

I mean, c'mon .. that's the only problem with SH5? Orientation, difficulties in moving around the sub and talk with the crew? I saw nothing mentioned about the God damn retard (pre-patch) AI, the boring campaign and the stupid missions.. you know, the real problems. Those guys should quit playing video games, or at least write reviews about.

Anyway, I doubt Ubi give a frak about that review, the biggest hits in the stomach was from the Eurogamer and Subsim review, those hurts really hard and is really bad for business. So if any1 want a good and comprehensive review, read those 2 mentioned... this one is a joke.

And just what do you consider old? I've been playing PC games since they were invented, so does that make me old?

How about young people have problems with patience and bed wetting, or did I go too young?