What's so great?

[Immelman]

Originally Posted by ERPP8

I don't see why people love SHIII soooooo much.
The bad graphics and simplicity make it seem pretty boring.

What realism level are you playing with?? You obviously haven't experienced 100% realism or some mods such as GWX or NYGM. Give that a try and then come and tell me all about the simplicity.

Graphics I will not argue with you because honestly I don't give a crap about them to me its about realism, strategy and re-playability and that SH3 has got in spades. If these factors are not part of what you are looking for then you are playing the wrong game friend. This is after all a U-Boat SIMULATION game.