Things that bother me about "Iron Coffins"

[IanC]

Originally Posted by LukeFF

I think Subnuts makes his point quite clear: it's not that the book is not a good read; it's that Werner presented facts as truth when the patently are not.

Gosh, big deal. Still doesn't explain to me why Subnuts wants to see it, quote "raked over the coals".
The book as a whole, is so much bigger and more important, than the inaccuracies.

[robbo180265]

Originally Posted by IanC

Gosh, big deal. Still doesn't explain to me why Subnuts wants to see it, quote "raked over the coals".
The book as a whole, is so much bigger and more important, than the inaccuracies.

I think he said that he was asked to write a review of it and decided to share his feelings with us.

I've read the book and whilst I thought it a jolly good read , I took some of what was written with a pinch of salt - as it would appear a few others did too.

I think a discussion about how we feel about a particular book is hardly "raking it over the coals" - just that , a discussion.