this is how they should do Silent Hunter

[JU_88]

Originally Posted by 4Para

Sir Skip, perhaps, but i trust some fine members (Moderators) within our community are already exercising or prepairing their skills to these matters (apparent wishes) already.

Yes the 'Modder' -that is the biggest ace up the PC gamers sleave that console gamers cant match

[Méo]

Originally Posted by JU_88

Yes the 'Modder' -that is the biggest ace up the PC gamers sleave that console gamers cant match

And now the question is:

What is the best way we (people who don't have sufficient skills, time, experience, etc.) could support the 'Modder'?

Any idea..

(of course make a donation to subsim is always good, but I thought maybe we could do something else)

[JU_88]

Originally Posted by Méo

And now the question is:

What is the best way we (people who don't have sufficient skills, time, experience, etc.) could support the 'Modder'?

Any idea..

(of course make a donation to subsim is always good, but I thought maybe we could do something else)

Yep
Make some time, learn the skills, gain experience, get stuck in and share the load!
Anyone can learn a little bit.
There is no other way - you cannot start paying a modder, (at least not in public ) it would be a disaster and probably result in bad feelings and a lawsuit or 10.
The Publisher would go nuts if you didnt get their permission, modifiying the contents of licensed software and distributing it for FREE is already treading on thin ice from a legal perspective.
But 'FREE' is the only reason they are cool with us doing it - generally speaking.

[Méo]

Originally Posted by JU_88

Yep
Make some time, learn the skills, gain experience, get stuck in and share the load! (Anyone can learn a little bit)

Alright, but I may ask some help/advice, maybe even ask silly questions..

Is there a ''Modding for dummies'' ..

Sh!t... it really exists!!! http://www.amazon.com/Modding-Dummie.../dp/0764575767

No.. not really about it..

[JU_88]

Originally Posted by Méo

Alright, but I may ask some help/advice, maybe even ask silly questions..

Well im not modding guru myself, So i would need to learn also, in GWX i was just a 3d & texture guy.
I dont think we will ever see a mass combined community effort with total co-operation accross the board because:

Constant communiaction is needed to avoid duplicating work and keeping consistancy
People will always disagree on what and how it should be done or driven
Some are unable to handle critism or take things personally.
Some will not want to share their successes or know-how with others.
Some will want to exploit others successes or know-how for ther own personal gain (rather than just learn from it).
Some will want to be 'in charge'.
Some will just want to compete.

Its all very sillly really -but hey ho thats just the way it goes from time to time... we're only human after all.
Dont get me wrong, we are lucky to have a great modding community for SH, but not everyone is sailing under the same flag

[SeaStorm]

Originally Posted by JU_88

People will always disagree on what and how it should be done or driven
Some are unable to handle critism or take things personally.
Some will not want to share their successes or know-how with others.
Some will want to exploit others successes or know-how for ther own personal gain (rather than just learn from it).
Some will want to be 'in charge'.
Some will just want to compete.

Its all very sillly really -but hey ho thats just the way it goes from time to time... we're only human after all.

Sad but true.

[skip]

I appologise I meant steel beasts pro not the original steel beasts, ( but i'm sure you probably knew which one I meant ) with regards to SH3 it sold very well, but its sequel ( SH4) did not, had UBI released constant upgrades including stuff such as graphics updates, new ships, better models, better stability, wolfpacks, proper weather, better simulation... ect. We could have had the sim or our dreams by now sure it might have cost us more but there's the rub. After all i forget what version of call of duty were on now isnt that really what their doing there.

Iam amazed at what the modding community have done with both silent hunter 3 & 4 but with no access to the SDK they are limited to what can be done.

I personaly would have rather paid for several really good upgrades to Silent Hunter 3 over the last 5 years ( other than buying SH4 or SH5 ) which would of improved the game in many aspects keeping it up to date and addressing many of the gameplay and simulation issues.

[Ducimus]

Originally Posted by JU_88

.. share the load!

Having a huge workload will wear any modder out fast. I think very few people have any idea how much work goes into some of the mods, let alone a supermod. I know i won't ever attempt what i did in SH4 ever again, it's just too much work. Nobody here will probably believe it, but for awhile, between my normal RL job, and modding at night, i was having 18 to 20 hour days for a week or two at a time.

edit:

Originally Posted by JU_88

People will always disagree on what and how it should be done or driven

One reason why i never tried to form an official team with TMO.

[Méo]

Originally Posted by Ducimus

Nobody here will probably believe it, but for awhile, between my normal RL job, and modding at night, i was having 18 to 20 hour days for a week or two at a time.

I do believe it, that's why I wrote post #6.

It would be so great if you guys could work on it as a full time job.

But that's probably just impossible, seems like there's way too much dissent and/or legal issues.

[Ducimus]

Originally Posted by Méo

It would be so great if you guys could work on it as a full time job.

I wish. I'm probably more skilled at tweaking SH 3/4 then i am at my RL job by now. Not saying i know everything, (far from it) but after awhile, i felt like i was working on a 2nd unpaid job. It's like i've acquired this useless job skill that has no value anywhere in the real world.

But that's probably just impossible, seems like there's way too much dissent.

Depends on the people involved. JU_88 might be referring to all the people of the "old guard" in modding. Those are personalities that have been around awhile and have formed longstanding opinions about each other and their work. So lots of sillyness there. I saw more cooperation with SH4 modders. Lots of cross pollination of ideas and mods, admitidly, regardless of forum, there's always mod politiics involved to some degree. I've always had to think about what im saying to others so as to not step on their toes and cause friction. Not saying their touchy, i just think that's just the nature of a modding community in general.

[Méo]

@Ducimus

I have no idea what would be the solution, but...

If I can do anything to support the genre, I will.

No matter ATO or PTO (even if I have a preference for ATO, and hopefully with wolfpacks).

And who knows, maybe someday I'll be tired of ATO and will discover new aspects of PTO..

[THE_MASK]

Originally Posted by Ducimus

I wish. I'm probably more skilled at tweaking SH 3/4 then i am at my RL job by now. Not saying i know everything, (far from it) but after awhile, i felt like i was working on a 2nd unpaid job. It's like i've acquired this useless job skill that has no value anywhere in the real world.



Depends on the people involved. JU_88 might be referring to all the people of the "old guard" in modding. Those are personalities that have been around awhile and have formed longstanding opinions about each other and their work. So lots of sillyness there. I saw more cooperation with SH4 modders. Lots of cross pollination of ideas and mods, admitidly, regardless of forum, there's always mod politiics involved to some degree. I've always had to think about what im saying to others so as to not step on their toes and cause friction. Not saying their touchy, i just think that's just the nature of a modding community in general.

But you see , your work is appreciated by tens of thousands of people in the real world .

[bigboywooly]

Originally Posted by Ducimus

between my normal RL job, and modding at night, i was having 18 to 20 hour days for a week or two at a time.

I hear that
And after keeping that up for months I couldnt even stand to play the game

[Ducimus]

Originally Posted by bigboywooly

I hear that
And after keeping that up for months I couldnt even stand to play the game

Too true. I haven't actually played Sh4 in what feels like years. Tested/modded yeah, played, no. It just isn't fun when you know the game inside and out.

Originally Posted by Jan Kyster

Wonder if Neal has some extra space in the basement? Perhaps next to the - apparently enormeous - brig?

Then I would say, lock them up and keep them hungry!

That brig is my home a away from home.... when im not riding along the ships keel.

[Jan Kyster]

Originally Posted by Méo

And now the question is:

What is the best way we (people who don't have sufficient skills, time, experience, etc.) could 'support' the Modder?

Any idea..

Wonder if Neal has some extra space in the basement? Perhaps next to the - apparently enormeous - brig?

Then I would say, lock them up and keep them hungry!