SH 3, 4 or 5?

[xXNightEagleXx]

Originally Posted by BL!TZKR!EG

I say that overall SH3 has the best gameplay BY FAR

Well it would be more helpful if you could elaborate and define what do you mean by best gameplay. I'm not arguing your opinion but gameplay itself is too vague.
Are you talking about campaign? submarine behavior? ai behavior? ecc.....
I don't agree that the link you provided is fair enough to give a good idea about 3 vs 5 because as you said they are mostly comparing 3 to 4 which are really different and the 5 itself is really different from 3 and 4.

For example, in sh5 under some circumstance when you proceed with an attack, sooner or later reinforcements will arrive (which is great). You have real navigation (which might be great for some). IMO in sh5 the campaign is a big event fest and that kills the "replayability" (although you can ignore them, but them you might feel like you are just doing whatever you want instead of being part of a bigger plan with a common objective).

These are just my own opinion that might divert a little bit also because it is more than 6 month that i touch any sh.

NE