[REL] SH5_MataHari's_More_Accuracy_for_TWoS_1.04_Mod

[vdr1981]

Originally Posted by Sjizzle

in your modlist is Large Optics for TDW UI 8 by 5 did u change the default resolution for TWoS ?

TWoS is optimized for 16:10 resolutions because my monitor has max resolution of 1680x1050 pixels...
Addons for different resolutions are within the modpack.

Anyway, maybe because of the lack of support for 16:10 displays or something else, but I'm experiencing significant inaccuracies when measuring distances using vertical angle measurement and RAOBF only...Can anyone confirm this?

[Sjizzle]

Originally Posted by vdr1981

TWoS is optimized for 16:10 resolutions because my monitor has max resolution of 1680x1050 pixels...
Addons for different resolutions are within the modpack.

Anyway, maybe because of the lack of support for 16:10 displays or something else, but I'm experiencing significant inaccuracies when measuring distances using vertical angle measurement and RAOBF only...Can anyone confirm this?

can u add also a 8:5 reso patch for large optics from |TWoS i have friend who has 8:5 resolution and need that thx

[vdr1981]

Originally Posted by Sjizzle

can u add also a 8:5 reso patch for large optics from |TWoS i have friend who has 8:5 resolution and need that thx

He doesn't need one because 8:5 is the same as 16:10 and this "patch" is by default in TWoS...

[MataHari]

Here's a list of the features modified:

1. OBS Periscope and ATK Periscope graticules redrawn for greater accuracy, while keeping the historical layout as much as possible.

2. The RAOBF middle grid matches the Periscope graticules.

3. The Field-of-view of the OBS Periscope is wider then the ATK's.

. . \data\Menu\Gui\Layout\RAOBF_Middle graphic files (700x700)

. . . . . . . . . TWoS mod . . . . . . . MataHari's mod
. . . . OBS : V=11 pixels/10mRad ____ V= 8.40 pixels/10mRad
. . . . . . . H=11 pixels/10mRad ____ H=14.67 pixels/degree
. . . . ATK : V=11 pixels/10mRad ____ V=15 pixels/10mRad
. . . . . . . H=11 pixels/10mRad ____ H=15 pixels/10mRad

. . \data\Menu\Skins\German\Gui\Layout\Periscope graphic files (1024x1024)

. . . . . . . . . TWoS mod . . . . . . . . MataHari's mod
. . . . OBS : V=13 pixels/10mRad _______ V=10.0 pixels/10mRad
. . . . . . . H=22 pixels/degree _______ H=17.5 pixels/degree
. . . . . . . (13 pixels/10mRad) / (5.7degree/100mRad) = 22.8
. . . . . . . (10 pixels/10mRad) / (5.7degree/100mRad) = 17.5
. . . . ATK : V=13 pixels/10mRad _______ V=17.85 pixels/10mRad
. . . . . . . H=13 pixels/10mRad _______ H=17.85 pixels/10mRad

. . . . Field-of-View = 725 pixels

. . TWoS mod:
. . . OBS : 725/(13/10)=557.7mRad x(5.7/100)=31.8 degrees.
. . . ATK : 725/(13/10)=557.7mRad x(5.7/100)=31.8 degrees.

. . MataHari's mod:
. . . OBS : 725/(10/10)=725mRad x(5.7/100)=41.3 degrees.
. . . ATK : 725/(17.85/10)=406.2mRad x(5.7/100)=23.2 degrees.

. . Notes : mRad = milli-Radian (or mill for short)
. . . . . . Optical Marks = 10 mRad
. . . . . . ArcTan(100 mRad) = 5.7 degrees (approximately).

4. The Cameras.cam file calibrated for the new graticules.

. . The C2-S-B1 Hull Large Merchant Ship is chosen as the reference ship:
. . Mast Height=30.0 m, Length=140.0 m, Width=19.2 m.

. . A Test SingleMission with the C2-S-B1 at 400m, 500m, and 800m is used
. . to calibrate the AngularAngle in the Cameres.cam file (Sub at -12 m).

. . MastHeight(mRad) = [MastHeight(m) / Distance(m)] x 1000 [x4 if Hi]

. . Distance . Mast Height . . Optic . . . Pwr
. . . 400 m ____ 75 mRad _____ 7.5 Marks __ Lo
. . . 400 m ___ 300 mRad ____ 30.0 Marks __ Hi
. . . 500 m ____ 60 mRad _____ 6.0 Marks __ Lo
. . . 500 m ___ 240 mRad ____ 24.0 Marks __ Hi
. . . 800 m ___ 150 mRad ____ 15.0 Marks __ Hi

. . \data\Library\Cameras.cam file

. . TWoS mod: . . . . . . . . 16:10 . . . 16:9 . . . . 4:3
. . #77 : Periscope OBS ____ 69.4911 ___ 69.63075 ___ 64.76225
. . #85 : Periscope ATK ____ 69.4911 ___ 69.63075 ___ 64.76225

. . MataHari's mod: . . . . . 16:10 . . . 16:9 . . . . 4:3
. . #77 : Periscope OBS ____ ??????? ____ 91.27 ______ 75.00
. . #85 : Periscope ATK ____ ??????? ____ 59.75 ______ 46.50

. . ################### ATTENTION - GENERAL CALL #################
. . I would appreciate it very much if someone would be nice enough
. . to find the values for 16:10 monitor resolution.
. . ################################################## #############

5. All ships manually measured for Mast Height, Length, Width, and Draft, and values entered in the Identification Manual.

. . \data\Sea\[UnitClass]\[UnitClass].cfg text files.

6. Ship's Flag Height manually measured, and drawn in the Identification Manual.

. . \data\Sea\[UnitClass]\[UnitClass]_sil.dds graphic files.

7. Ships Search Criteria updated in the Identification Manual:
. . . . Category, Bow, Funnel, SuperStructure, Islands.

. . \data\Sea\[UnitClass]\[UnitClass].cfg text files.

8. Missing ClassNames=UnitNames added to the Identification Manual.

. . \data\Roster\Names.cfg text file

. . . . [SEA]
. . . . Tug_Z=Ported SV Tug Boat
. . . . PSTyohei_Z=Ported Uekel Small Passenger Type
. . . . NAMC_Z=Medium Freighter
. . . . JPFish01=Fishing boat 1
. . . . JPFish02=Fishing boat 2
. . . . OSHaruna_Z=Ported SteelViking Tanker

9. RAOBF Circular Slide Rule redrawn for more accuracy and visibility.

. . \data\Menu\Gui\Layout\RAOBFInner.dds graphic file.
. . \data\Menu\Gui\Layout\RAOBFOuter.dds graphic file.

. . Test 1:
. . . . Distance=400m (4hm)
. . . . Mast Height=30m
. . . . Optic (Hi)=30.0 Marks (300mRad)

. . . . With the mouse pointing at 30 (Mast Height in m) on the Middle ring, left-click and
. . . . rotate the Middle ring until it is next to 30 Optic Marks (or 300mRad) on the Outer ring.
. . . . Read off the bottom right red pointer at 4 on the Outer ring (for Hi Power),
. . . . the distance in hm on the Middle ring => 4 (or 400m).

. . Test 2:
. . . . Distance=400m (4hm)
. . . . Mast Height=30m
. . . . Optic (Lo)=7.5 Marks (75mRad)

. . . . With the mouse pointing at 30 (Mast Height in m) on the Middle ring, left-click and
. . . . rotate the Middle ring until it is next to 7.5 Optic Marks (or 75mRad) on the Outer ring.
. . . . Read off the top red pointer at 100 on the Outer ring (for Lo Power),
. . . . the distance in hm on the Middle ring => 4 (or 400m).

. . Test 3:
. . . . Rotate the Middle ring and allign 1 next to the top red pointer at 100 on the Outer ring.
. . . . This is the trinogometric Sin function:
. . . . . . The Inner ring is the angle in degrees.
. . . . . . The Middle (external) ring is the Sin value:
. . . . . . . . Sin(90)=1.0
. . . . . . . . Sin(30)=0.5

10. Nomograph redrawn for greater accuracy and readability.
. . The Nav Map Seal moved for the new nomograph.

. . \data\Menu\Gui\Layout\Nomograph.dds graphic file.
. . \data\Menu\Gui\Layout\NavMapSeal.dds graphic file.

[fitzcarraldo]

Download link broken in SUBSIM Bonus Mods.

Regards.

Fitzcarraldo

[Sailor Steve]

Hey, Canuckette! It's good to see you back again.

I don't play SH5, so there's not much else I can say.

[Sjizzle]

can u fix the download link or upload it somewhere else ?

[gap]

Originally Posted by MataHari

Here's a list of the features modified:

Thanks

I suggest you to link this list to your first post in this thread, for better visibility.

Originally Posted by MataHari

5. All ships manually measured for Mast Height, Length, Width, and Draft, and values entered in the Identification Manual.

What do you mean with "manually measured"? Stock manual ship measures were a mess, but all of the ships featured by TWoS, with the exception the units imported from SHIV, had their relevant dimensions corrected by toniloCoyote, who used an ingenious method for measuring them. As far as I can tell, though with some approximation, the figures provided by him are fairly accurate. Did you find significant discrepancies with your own measures?

To give you an idea of how approximate were ship specs stated in most cases in WWII recognition handbooks, I suggest you to have a look into one of the ONI manuals available at this link, and compare the specs stated there with information on the same ship classes available today.

Originally Posted by MataHari

8. Missing ClassNames=UnitNames added to the Identification Manual.

. . \data\Roster\Names.cfg text file

. . . . [SEA]
. . . . Tug_Z=Ported SV Tug Boat
. . . . PSTyohei_Z=Ported Uekel Small Passenger Type
. . . . NAMC_Z=Medium Freighter
. . . . JPFish01=Fishing boat 1
. . . . JPFish02=Fishing boat 2
. . . . OSHaruna_Z=Ported SteelViking Tanker

I think vdr1981 has finally replaced ship class names once derived from the forum name of the modder who had originally imported them, with more generic names or, wherever possible, with real class names which are now featured by TWoS. Not to look ungrateful, but I couldn't agree more with his decision. It looked odd reading those familiar names in game; it was something that, at least for me, broke the illusion of being thrown in the middle of WWII warfare, and reminded me of nodes, 3D meshes, unit controllers and long testing sessions. I am glad that someone dealt with them, but I would rather prefer reading their names in the credit notes.

[Onkel Neal]

Ok, I see the file, good job.

[MataHari]

**************************
* Download link restored *
**************************

Hello gap,

When I tested the Mast Height values with TWoS mod (16:9), I was getting erroneous results (ex. 11% error for the C2-S-B1 Merchant).

To get an accurate result, the graticule scale on the periscope must be calibrated with the Cameras.cam AngularAngle.
So I redrew the graticules for a more precise scale, and by try-and-error, found the AngularAngle.
I then manually measured each ship's Mast Height, Length, Width with the new graticule in Test SingleMissions.

I realized that different Classes of ship with the same 3D Model have the same dimention values, but the ID Manual says otherwise.

Ex 1:
DDType34 Class and DDType36N Class both have the same 3D Model: NDD_Type34A.
The Mast Height is listed at 26.6m and 26.8m respectively.
But both were manually measured at 25.8m in a Test SingleMission.

Ex 2:
BBNewYork Class and BBKongo/BBProvence Classes have the same 3D Model: NBB_New_York.
The Mast Height is listed at 48.6m for the first Class, and 39.2m for the other two classes.
They were all measured exactly at 48.6m.

Looks like what I'm measuring is the 3D Model which is identical in those classes,
even if in reality they were different and listed as such in the ID Manual.

Here are some statistics (138 Classes):
--- Mast Height OK = 66 Classes.
--- Mast Height error (average 1.7m) of a class with the same 3D Model as a Class with Mast Height OK = 11 Classes.
--- Mast Height error (average 1.3m) = 61 Classes (2/3 of those classes have an error less than 1m).

I also noticed that the measured Mast Height remains constant, no matter what type of cargo, what temperature or salinity of the water the ship is on.

[gezahu]

Is this mod compatible withtwos 2.0?

[fitzcarraldo]

Originally Posted by gezahu

Is this mod compatible withtwos 2.0?

No. It was left to be compatible from TWoS 1.05, I believe.

In fact, the recognition manual in TWoS 2 is very different to that in MataHari mod.
Regards.

Fitzcarraldo

[gezahu]

Thanks.

[U-190]

Good job! Thx!