Why no Kaibokans?

[Flaskegaard]

I just added the SH4 1.4 TMO 1.7.6 and found a KAIBOKAN ESCORT added to the Japanese ship roster. Even though it's just a re-worked American Evarts DE, I'm not going to complain. It's better than no kaibokan at all. The only problem I have with it, is it's not very good at detecting my sub. I played the BORNEO CONVOY single mission and noticed none of the Kaibokans I added to the scenario could find me. The Japanese Minekaze destroyer picked me up in normal time and started pinging me right after my torpedos hit, which was about normal when playing the same scenario in the stock setting. The two kaibokans just sailed around in circles, as if searching for me. I sank the Minekaze and even went to flank speed, but never got pinged by either Kaibokan. One even sailed right over the top of me while doing flank speed at 150 feet, and still nothing. Any ideas on how to make the Kaibokans a bit more accurate at detecting a sub? They acted like they had no sonar or hydrophones at all.

[Flaskegaard]

Ok, I am running SH4 1.4 with TMO 1.7.9, and I noticed the KAIBOKAN ESCORT(S) could not detect me. I was playing the BORNEO CONVOY mission with a Japanese Minekaze Destroyer in front of the convoy and two Kaibokan Escorts (Evarts DE) on the flanks. During my approach and attack, I was detected by the Minekaze, but not the Kaibokans. Even when the Minekaze depth charged where he thought I was, the Kaibokans didn't even come over to assist. They just sailed in circles. So, I replaced the Minekaze with another Kaibokan, then re-played the scenario. None of the three Kaibokans pinged me at all. While at periscope depth, one sailed down my port side at less than 50 feet and didn't detect or ping me. I then replaced the Kaibokans with all Minekazes and got detected and attacked by all three. I compared the COKaibokan.SNS file with the DDMinekaze.SNS file, and they were the same. I tried FUBUKI, SHIRATSUYU, and ASASHIO destroyers. I was detected and attacked by each type of destroyer and had to use evasion tactics to escape. With all Kaibokans, I stayed at periscope depth and have yet to be pinged, let alone depth charged. I am currently digging thru the game files to find anything that might fix the problem. It appears the .SNS files only work with generic Japanese ships. If anyone else finds an answer or fix, please post.

[Armistead]

It could be you're running 1.4 and an old version of TMO. I know they will hunt me using 1.5 and TMO 2.5. I think TMO 2.0 onward uses the Type C as the platform.

They're several other mods that make or include it, such as MadMax DD pack. You could simply pull the files from a later TMO or mentioned mod and replace your old ones or better make a small mod.

[Flaskegaard]

More experimenting with the Kaibokan Escorts (EvartsDE). I went into the files and tweeked the AI hydrophones and sonar to as sensitive as possible, then set the crew ratings to 4. Now when I play the scenario, they pick me up almost immediately and come charging over. But get this, I hear NO pinging of their sonar on my hull. They now find and depth charge me, but as they are closing, no sonar pinging. I put generic Japanese destroyers of all kinds in their place and they ping me almost all the way in. I have to adjust my crash dive times with the Japanese destroyers because they have 30+ speeds compared to the Kaibokan/Evarts DE speed of 19. The Minekaze destroyers with their 38 knot speeds are on me like a rat on a cheeto! I'm beginning to think there is something about the Kaibokan Escorts being reflagged American ships that is hardwired into the game. I've surfaced my submarine right in front of American and allied ships and destroyers, and they pay me no mind. Anyone know of a way to get the sonar pinging sound for the Kaibokan Escorts/Evarts DE to be heard? It probably has something to do with a game file that I haven't found yet. I think a Kaibokan has to be made from scratch, and not just a reflagged American ship that looks like one. For anyone who is better at that kinda stuff, here is a link to see what an actual Kaibokan looks like: www.sas1946.com/main/index.php/topic,25065.0.html Mabye someone who is good at creating ships for the game can create a generic Kaibokan from the drawings and models shown in this link. Good Luck!

[ColonelSandersLite]

This isn't what you think it is.

The destroyer ai can only use one sensor at a time. Either hydrophones or pinging, not both. Of course, the ai, bieng what it is, also appears to be able to instantly switch between the two but whatever.

The point is that the AI will never ping if you up the hydrophone values too much because it will determine that the hydrophones have the better fix under all circumstances.


Friendly DDS never ping either because they psychically know that you're a friendly. This reminds me of something that I personally haven't tried, but would be interested in any annectdotal results anyone has. If I recall correctly, if you sink a friendly ship, you get marked as rouge for something like 24 hours. I wonder if the friendly destroyers will magically know to start pinging you then?

[razark]

Originally Posted by ColonelSandersLite

If I recall correctly, if you sink a friendly ship, you get marked as rouge for something like 24 hours. I wonder if the friendly destroyers will magically know to start pinging you then?

I doubt it. I've sunk friendly ships many times in the training missions, and the PT boats never seem to care. They keep running around as if everything was perfectly normal.

[Flaskegaard]

Ok, I didn't know that. Good advise. I'll go back and "turn down" the hydrophones and "turn up" the active sonar, then test it with the Kaibokan Escorts and Japanese DD's. We'll see what happens. Stay tuned...