Torpedoes in WOS

Mowgli · 07-10-19, 10:46 AM

I have had several dud torpedoes both electric and steam and have been increasing my torpedo man's skills to compensate.

My 1st question is, do they become more reliable as the war progresses?

In SH3 I liked to use torpedoes set to magnetic and set the depth just beneath the targets depth and so it made little difference to the angle of attack so long as the torpedo passed under the target and it was a very good tactic.

So my 2nd Question is this. Does this work in SH5 as I have tried several times and the torpedoes just pass under the vessel and carry on their merry way.

3rd and final question. Should I be using magnetic or impact setting?

Thanks in advance.

vdr1981 · 07-10-19, 11:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mowgli

I have had several dud torpedoes both electric and steam and have been increasing my torpedo man's skills to compensate.

That wont help much. The torpedoman's ability to effect "dud" percentage is quite unrealistic IMO and therefore it has been heavily reduced.

Quote:

My 1st question is, do they become more reliable as the war progresses?

Yes...

Quote:

In SH3 I liked to use torpedoes set to magnetic and set the depth just beneath the targets depth and so it made little difference to the angle of attack so long as the torpedo passed under the target and it was a very good tactic.

So my 2nd Question is this. Does this work in SH5 as I have tried several times and the torpedoes just pass under the vessel and carry on their merry way.

Yes, but try to use magnetic detonators only in calm seas because premature detonation chances will grow exponentially with wind speeds. Setting torpedo deeper and 24kn speed settings may help in this case.
Regarding torpedo depth settings... It's always better not to set torpedo depth more than ~0.5 m of designated ships draught because depths in TWoS are slightly randomized in order to simulate real life torpedo and ships behavior. Also, are you completely sure that those draught values from recognition manual are 100% correct?

Quote:

3rd and final question. Should I be using magnetic or impact setting?

Impact of course, at least in the early stages of war...It is very well known fact that magnetic detonators were really unreliable and TWoS simulates this very well, regardless of what people have learned and experienced in SH3...

Don't forget that impact detonators require sharp impact angle in both horizontal and vertical plane.

bstanko6 · 07-10-19, 11:13 AM

There are a few factors with torpedoes:

A) Weather. If the weather is bad, you must set torpedo depth correctly.

B) Torpedoman. Yes, to upgrade him helps, but only by small percentages.

C) Fact. Torpedoes were terrible in all theatres of the war. They did get better, but problems never went away. From 39’ to early 41’ don’t expect much.

Section A is usually the biggest issue for problem torps. Practice.

AP514 · 07-10-19, 04:14 PM

Weather and TP depth.
A few Videos out there about this...

In Simple Terms the higher the wind speed the more chance for DUDs.

here is a Thread I started not long ago about this same thing..
http://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=241132

Post 2..check out Video..TP DEPTH STTTINGS

Videos a Great source for learning

Fidgety · 07-14-19, 01:52 PM

I have a question relating to this subject.

It has been stated both on this forum and in tutorials that I have read in regards to torpedoes set on the impact trigger. That you should avoid letting the gyro angle go above 30 degrees. I am assuming technically that it is actually more the track angle that matters but gyro would be same when setting the tdc. I have had a couple of experiences where the torpedo has failed with the "the torpedo is a dud sir" getting announced. The reason I ask is I'm wondering if this is what gets said when the torpedo fails due to your track angle being too severe. Or does something else get said if that happens like maybe torpedo missed sir. Like the torpedo isnt a dud you just messed the track angle up. I've had it say dud when im pretty sure the track angle was close to 30 degrees.

XenonSurf · 07-17-19, 04:28 PM

Unaware if it's historically accurate or not, I have good experience with:

- If I cannot fire at 90° angle or very close, I chose magnetic
- In bad weather I never chose magnetic (premature explosions)
- in bad weather I set the depth of torpedos higher than usual.
- Longer than 2000m it's just gambling using Steam torpedos, they can be evaded easily.
- I avoid making my torpedo turn more than 10° when leaving tube.

In point 3: yes, higher and not lower! For some reasons I get a much better hit rate in SH5.

.
XS

Fidgety · 07-17-19, 06:11 PM

Yeah I do all that already, what I need to know is if the crew member says torpedo is a dud sir when it fails due to track angle or if they say something different like torpedo missed sir.

It doesnt matter, I will figure it out myself as I accumulate more failures over time. Only reason I asked is because I dont get much failures so its going to take some time unless I load up a historical mission and repeatedly test which I dont have time for. My limited game time in a week I can actually play SH I want to play campaign. Lol most of the time I write on this forum I should be working

Thanks anyway

07-10-19, 10:46 AM	#1
Mowgli Sparks Join Date: Dec 2001 Location: South Wales Posts: 248 Downloads: 158 Uploads: 0	Torpedoes in WOS I have had several dud torpedoes both electric and steam and have been increasing my torpedo man's skills to compensate. My 1st question is, do they become more reliable as the war progresses? In SH3 I liked to use torpedoes set to magnetic and set the depth just beneath the targets depth and so it made little difference to the angle of attack so long as the torpedo passed under the target and it was a very good tactic. So my 2nd Question is this. Does this work in SH5 as I have tried several times and the torpedoes just pass under the vessel and carry on their merry way. 3rd and final question. Should I be using magnetic or impact setting? Thanks in advance. __________________ Now this is the Law of the Jungle -- as old and as true as the sky; And the Wolf that shall keep it may prosper, but the Wolf that shall break it must die. As the creeper that girdles the tree-trunk the Law runneth forward and back -- For the strength of the Pack is the Wolf, and the strength of the Wolf is the Pack.

07-10-19, 11:13 AM	#3
bstanko6 Admiral Join Date: Feb 2015 Location: Murwik Naval Academy Posts: 2,130 Downloads: 390 Uploads: 13	There are a few factors with torpedoes: A) Weather. If the weather is bad, you must set torpedo depth correctly. B) Torpedoman. Yes, to upgrade him helps, but only by small percentages. C) Fact. Torpedoes were terrible in all theatres of the war. They did get better, but problems never went away. From 39’ to early 41’ don’t expect much. Section A is usually the biggest issue for problem torps. Practice. __________________ [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC] BSTANKO6'S SH5 NAVAL ACADEMY http://www.youtube.com/channel/UCPbe...W2NArCA/videos DISCORD https://discord.gg/6tFeTSUmVc

07-17-19, 04:28 PM	#6
XenonSurf Sea Lord Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: Germany, Italy Posts: 1,721 Downloads: 107 Uploads: 4	Unaware if it's historically accurate or not, I have good experience with: - If I cannot fire at 90° angle or very close, I chose magnetic - In bad weather I never chose magnetic (premature explosions) - in bad weather I set the depth of torpedos higher than usual. - Longer than 2000m it's just gambling using Steam torpedos, they can be evaded easily. - I avoid making my torpedo turn more than 10° when leaving tube. In point 3: yes, higher and not lower! For some reasons I get a much better hit rate in SH5. . XS Last edited by XenonSurf; 07-17-19 at 04:37 PM.

07-10-19, 04:14 PM	#4
AP514 Gunner Join Date: Feb 2019 Posts: 95 Downloads: 6 Uploads: 0	Weather and TP depth. A few Videos out there about this... In Simple Terms the higher the wind speed the more chance for DUDs. here is a Thread I started not long ago about this same thing.. http://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=241132 Post 2..check out Video..TP DEPTH STTTINGS Videos a Great source for learning

07-14-19, 01:52 PM	#5
Fidgety Mate Join Date: Apr 2016 Location: AN72 Posts: 55 Downloads: 33 Uploads: 0	I have a question relating to this subject. It has been stated both on this forum and in tutorials that I have read in regards to torpedoes set on the impact trigger. That you should avoid letting the gyro angle go above 30 degrees. I am assuming technically that it is actually more the track angle that matters but gyro would be same when setting the tdc. I have had a couple of experiences where the torpedo has failed with the "the torpedo is a dud sir" getting announced. The reason I ask is I'm wondering if this is what gets said when the torpedo fails due to your track angle being too severe. Or does something else get said if that happens like maybe torpedo missed sir. Like the torpedo isnt a dud you just messed the track angle up. I've had it say dud when im pretty sure the track angle was close to 30 degrees.

07-17-19, 06:11 PM	#7
Fidgety Mate Join Date: Apr 2016 Location: AN72 Posts: 55 Downloads: 33 Uploads: 0	Yeah I do all that already, what I need to know is if the crew member says torpedo is a dud sir when it fails due to track angle or if they say something different like torpedo missed sir. It doesnt matter, I will figure it out myself as I accumulate more failures over time. Only reason I asked is because I dont get much failures so its going to take some time unless I load up a historical mission and repeatedly test which I dont have time for. My limited game time in a week I can actually play SH I want to play campaign. Lol most of the time I write on this forum I should be working Thanks anyway