Too Many Planes

[Red Devil]

I have mentioned this before, and was suggested I use RSRD which is very good BUT, too few ships are to be found. Has anyone reduced the numbers of aircraft (the japs must have approx 10million flying planes) without having to install RSRD?

Another bug just discovered. Riding the surf en route to China Sea from Pearl, I was being attacked by an invisible jap ship, circa 1941 second patrol of my GATO, USS Drum. Nothing on the sea, in the air or on the map!!!

[ReallyDedPoet]

Originally Posted by Red Devil

I have mentioned this before, and was suggested I use RSRD which is very good BUT, too few ships are to be found. Has anyone reduced the numbers of aircraft (the japs must have approx 10million flying planes) without having to install RSRD?

Another bug just discovered. Riding the surf en route to China Sea from Pearl, I was being attacked by an invisible jap ship, circa 1941 second patrol of my GATO, USS Drum. Nothing on the sea, in the air or on the map!!!

See the second link in this post for your first question:
http://www.subsim.com/radioroom/show...33&postcount=1

Not sure on the second :hmm:


RDP

[Red Devil]

Excellent, my thanks

[ReallyDedPoet]

Originally Posted by Red Devil

Excellent, my thanks

Your welcome


RDP

[Red Devil]

Ah, one other thing

When a sub arrives home it auto fills with Mk14 torps. Would it not be better to have an empty sub so that, later on, I can load Mk23's without having to remove all the Mk14's first. Its a pain in the proverbials.

[ReallyDedPoet]

Not sure on that one, I just use whatever is there, call me lazy :p
Someone will help you with this though.


RDP

[Red Devil]

the poet is a helpful soul
who knows much more than many
he provides such help as can be told
and it does not cost a penny



Thanks again

[Red Devil]

back on track and topic: the planes download does not work. From Midway to a point about 400 miles west, I have encountered approx 65 Jap planes!!!! I feel like starting again! I loaded the file into data/cfg

[ReallyDedPoet]

Hey with that poetic effort ( just seeing it now ) I gotta help you out

I am wondering if you missed a step with the mod installation. Did you use JSGME
( Mod Enabler )? If not you should, it will make your life much easier. There is a link to it in the thread below my sig. It is from SH3 Forums but that does not matter, it works with SH3\4 and other games for that matter. There is also a nice guide on how to use it below my sig as well

Here is another mod regarding the planes:
http://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=131709
But that first one I sent should work if installed properly.


RDP

[Rockin Robbins]

You know, I'll bet the real skippers complained about too many planes too. But they didn't have the option of nerfing the enemy with a fortuitous mod to wussify their environment.

Yes, it's possible with RSRD to circumnavigate the Philippine Islands in late 1941, when they were under almost complete control of the Japanese without encountering a single airplane. Considering that on your way out to sea you just watched a movie about how the British moved their battleships out to interdict the Japanese invasion of Singapore and they were promptly sunk by swarming Japanese aircraft, how are you to defend such a thing? I doubt that a submarine could remain surfaced for more than an hour in that vicinity at that time. I've been on the surface continuously for four days except for sonar sweeps!

Fact: the air was FULL of unopposed Japanese aircraft.

Fact: they sank many valuable American and British naval ships, including some submarines. These included ships that could well defend themselves.

Fact: you complain that the game reflects that reality.

Have you considered that time compression makes the frequency of air attacks seem many times more frequent than they are? Have you actually logged times of air attacks in 12 hours in the game and compared them with WWII sub logs made at the same time in the war and in similar waters?

The issue isn't whether you can or can not choose to play the game any way you want. Of course you can. You can download my slightly subnuclear Mark 14 and incinerate any ship in the game with a hit to the rudder (it's a lot of fun!), but don't make claims of "too many airplanes" and "too few ships" without doing the extensive research on planes that the developers did or the incredible research on Japanese shipping that Lurker did. Go make the claim of not enough Japanese ships the RSRD thread and see how Lurker will drop reams of evidence on top of you. I dare you! As a matter of fact, it would be a fun discussion and I urge you to do exactly that. I'll bet you will learn a lot in a hurry. And so will a lot of other people who would never ask the question, so you would be helping lots of people.

Learning is one of the valuable things that happen when you choose play a simulation over an arcade game.

[Red Devil]

The only time skippers would have seen many planes would be when in empire waters, I would imagine. Further afield planes would sortie from island airstrips but doubt if they would have been as frequent as I have seen in SH4. They would not have had that many planes nor fuel. Also, planes heading outward on patrol at dusk would hardly be there, being unable to patrol at night as such.

NB: thanks again poet. Mod installed now to try it before I head out for night shift!

[ReallyDedPoet]

Originally Posted by Rockin Robbins

You know, I'll bet the real skippers complained about too many planes too. But they didn't have the option of nerfing the enemy with a fortuitous mod to wussify their environment.

Yes, it's possible with RSRD to circumnavigate the Philippine Islands in late 1941, when they were under almost complete control of the Japanese without encountering a single airplane. Considering that on your way out to sea you just watched a movie about how the British moved their battleships out to interdict the Japanese invasion of Singapore and they were promptly sunk by swarming Japanese aircraft, how are you to defend such a thing? I doubt that a submarine could remain surfaced for more than an hour in that vicinity at that time. I've been on the surface continuously for four days except for sonar sweeps!

Fact: the air was FULL of unopposed Japanese aircraft.

Fact: they sank many valuable American and British naval ships, including some submarines. These included ships that could well defend themselves.

Fact: you complain that the game reflects that reality.

Have you considered that time compression makes the frequency of air attacks seem many times more frequent than they are? Have you actually logged times of air attacks in 12 hours in the game and compared them with WWII sub logs made at the same time in the war and in similar waters?

The issue isn't whether you can or can not choose to play the game any way you want. Of course you can. You can download my slightly subnuclear Mark 14 and incinerate any ship in the game with a hit to the rudder (it's a lot of fun!), but don't make claims of "too many airplanes" and "too few ships" without doing the extensive research on planes that the developers did or the incredible research on Japanese shipping that Lurker did. Go make the claim of not enough Japanese ships the RSRD thread and see how Lurker will drop reams of evidence on top of you. I dare you! As a matter of fact, it would be a fun discussion and I urge you to do exactly that. I'll bet you will learn a lot in a hurry. And so will a lot of other people who would never ask the question, so you would be helping lots of people.

Learning is one of the valuable things that happen when you choose play a simulation over an arcade game.

Relax RR Nothing wrong with having options and playing the game how
you see fit

In fact it is one of the reasons why I have enjoyed SH3\4 so much and
have multiple installs depending on how I want to play at any
given time


RDP

[kylesplanet]

Originally Posted by Rockin Robbins

You know, I'll bet the real skippers complained about too many planes too. But they didn't have the option of nerfing the enemy with a fortuitous mod to wussify their environment.

Yes, it's possible with RSRD to circumnavigate the Philippine Islands in late 1941, when they were under almost complete control of the Japanese without encountering a single airplane. Considering that on your way out to sea you just watched a movie about how the British moved their battleships out to interdict the Japanese invasion of Singapore and they were promptly sunk by swarming Japanese aircraft, how are you to defend such a thing? I doubt that a submarine could remain surfaced for more than an hour in that vicinity at that time. I've been on the surface continuously for four days except for sonar sweeps!

Fact: the air was FULL of unopposed Japanese aircraft.

I love RSRD and consider it a must have but I do miss the lack of aircraft. The stock game probably over did it but like RR, I'm riding around Rabul in mid 42 on the surface and not a single aircraft. I have went four patrols before and not seen a single plane. Maybe in the future, we can get an RSRD patch to add some of the aircraft back.

[aanker]

I guess I'm one who doesn't mind the planes. Some days they are heavy other days there aren't any. For me they add to the fun & sometimes the frustration of my patrols which is as it should be.

BTW - most of the time the aircraft just west of Midway are 'our boys' ... so don't shoot... lol

Happy Hunting!

Art

[Rockin Robbins]

Originally Posted by reallydedpoet

Relax RR Nothing wrong with having options and playing the game how
you see fit

In fact it is one of the reasons why I have enjoyed SH3\4 so much and
have multiple installs depending on how I want to play at any
given time


RDP

Relax?
I AM relaxed!!!!! Can't you tell?

I could have sworn I said everyone has the right to play the game any way they please. Thought I mentioned something about a subnuclear torpedo.... Thought I was being tolerant, I did. Relaxed, I thought I was.

Actually I'm just a cute harmless little fuzzball who just happens to have 24 torpedoes at his immediate disposal.:rotfl: