2011 SUBSIM Werewolf Game: Intro, Rules, FAQ, & Aftermath

[The Enigma]

I would say, yes he can be lynched or eaten.

[The Enigma]

Hi folks,
I'm off to bed now. Will be back tomorrow.

[Rear]

Hi folks,
I'm off to bed now. Will be back tomorrow.

Ditto. Good night :salute:

[Onkel Neal]

Does the same work for lynching? If someone is in interrogation or escaped, they can still be lynched?


Yes, because the detainee in the dungeon is at hand, and the escapee must always be in camp during the day, and thus is also at hand.

[Tarrasque]

I'm off to bed too.

[Jimbuna]

Hi folks,
I'm off to bed now. Will be back tomorrow.

Ditto. Good night :salute:

I'm off to bed too.

Nighty nite peeps.

[Tinman764]

A chilling, ghostly voice is carried on the wind across the castle grounds - "doooon't fooorget abooout the bottle of schnaaaaps in the dock guard tooooower! oh... and aveeeeenge meeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!"
:up:

[mookiemookie]

A chilling, ghostly voice is carried on the wind across the castle grounds - "doooon't fooorget abooout the bottle of schnaaaaps in the dock guard tooooower! oh... and aveeeeenge meeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!"
:up:

:rotfl2:

[Task Force]

*this brings up a question. Did i see the werewolf kill bakkels?, did i see it happen, or was it "silent but deadly" to say?

[Onkel Neal]

Um, I think I'm seeing several POWs talking about doing recon tonight; check with Raptor, only one can go out per night, I think Jim is the choice tonight, but that's the Captain's call.

[Pioneer]

I got that covered up, was trying to interact when everyone had gone to sleep.

[Onkel Neal]

2 hours to the vote

August ------- Nisgeis
AVGWarhawk ------- August
Ducimuss -------
HunterIXC ------- MookieMookie
jimbuna ------- Nisgeis
Lord Justice ------- Nisgeis
mookiemookie ------- Nisgeis
Nisgeis -------
Pioneer ------- Nisgeis
Raptor1 ------- Nisgeis
Rear ------- August
Takeda Shingen ------- Nisgeis
Tarrasque ------- Abstain
Task Force ------- Nisgeis
The Enigma -------
--------------- --------------- ---------------
Dungeon (protected) No one?
Leave ---- Nisgies (To the nunnery)
Escaped -----Jimbuna


If your vote is not shown, be sure to let us know.

posted for Neal, by Wendy

[Task Force]

I voted Nisgeis neal, guess it was too far back and you didnt notice it.:up:

[The Enigma]

Sorry for the delay.

I realized this morning that I hadn't vote for the lynch party.
It's done now. :salute:

[Onkel Neal]

No problem, you were in with ten minutes to spare :)

[Rear]

Behind Bunkhouse A, Captain Raptor and SL Mookie addressed Jimbuna. "Be careful mate. See what you can see but don't put a foot down wrong, we don't want Jerry to get his mitts on you."
"Yes sir."
Raptor leaned forward, his taunt face rough with stubble in the moonlight. "And Jimbuna. If you find Nisgeis, put this between his ribs, aye?" Mookie handed a sharp wedge of wood, a hand-carved stilleto, to the sailor. A smile spread slowly across Jimbuna's face.
"With pleasure, sir."




Night begins
Does this mean Nisgeis was lynched? :stare:

Edit: Also I'm off to work for 6/7hrs

[Raptor1]

Dungeon (protected) No one?
Leave ---- Nisgies (To the nunnery)
Escaped -----Jimbuna


I thought Jimbuna was hauled off the the dungeon (http://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showpost.php?p=1691778&postcount=404) and therefore I had to send Mookie instead (http://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showpost.php?p=1691922&postcount=425).

[Ducimus]

Sorry folks, im usually pretty busy on the weekends. I'll try and catch up with the game thread today.

[Onkel Neal]

Does this mean Nisgeis was lynched? :stare:

Edit: Also I'm off to work for 6/7hrs

No, he was selected by popular vote, and Jimbuna was assigned to assassinate him (lynch) but as you know, Nisgeis was last seen heading for the nunnery.

I thought Jimbuna was hauled off the the dungeon (http://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showpost.php?p=1691778&postcount=404) and therefore I had to send Mookie instead (http://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showpost.php?p=1691922&postcount=425).

Ah, yes, I see. I guess Wendy missed that, sorry. Well, let's say that the Oberst was busy and never got around to having Jimuba sent for. Won't happen again :)

[Oberon]

No, he was selected by popular vote, and Jimbuna was assigned to assassinate him (lynch) but as you know, Nisgeis was last seen heading for the nunnery.


http://images4.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20070930152908/uncyclopedia/images/c/cb/Nun_Gun.jpg

And that was the last time Nisgeis was ever seen....

[AVGWarhawk]

:har:

[Onkel Neal]

This is the guy I need working with me on imagez!! :haha:

[HunterICX]

Ah crap out this soon, this stinks...
like a wet doggy that is :D:haha:

well played :yeah:

HunterICX

[Rear]

Seems too easy for the werewolves so far - none of the humans want to work together apparently :hmmm:

[Onkel Neal]

Well, seeing how the WW only managed to kill one in 2 of the 3 nights... :O:

[August]

Well, seeing how the WW only managed to kill one in 2 of the 3 nights... :O:

Kinda lopsided with 4 dead Germans vs 1 dead Englishman. I guess the Werewolves prefer blutwurst over spotted dick... :DL

[Tarrasque]

Or it's just easier for them to hunt the germans as the brits are all sleeping together.

EDIT: Purely in a location arrangement of course! Didn't mean to start the old one up about Navy men!

[Jimbuna]

Does Nisgeis return into the game now?

[The Enigma]

Perhaps the wolfs have had English breakfast once, since then they prefer continental food :D

[Raptor1]

Wait, so the fact that Nisgeis was in the nunnery saves him from murderous retribution? Or is he missing never to return?

[Tarrasque]

*arrives at post*

*disgruntled*

*cocks weapons. Checks the Howitzer and the hidden MP40. Also pulls Mauser HSC, Gewehr 98, MG 42, Karbiner 98K and a Panserfaust for good measure. Good for tanks and better for werewolves.


Good god! How many weapons do you need?

[Raptor1]

...and a Panserfaust for good measure. Good for tanks and better for werewolves.

I'm also glad the StG 44 wasn't the only weapon to arrive by time travel.

BTW, I think extensive OOC talk should be confined to this thread.

[Lord Justice]

BTW, I think extensive OOC talk should be confined to this thread.My sentiments exactly it ruining the game thread! :up:

[August]

That's fine by me.

To recap:

There are at least four werewolves.
Jimbuna is a human.
There is at least one Guardian (the one who protected Jim)
We have several players MIA.

[AVGWarhawk]

Good god! How many weapons do you need?


As many as this old boy can carry. :DL There is a beast or two running around.

[AVGWarhawk]

I'm also glad the StG 44 wasn't the only weapon to arrive by time travel.



There is more but I had to return to the armory to get them. I can only carry so much. :O:

[August]

As already posted. The wolves that attached the three germans were NOT the same as attacked Bakkels.

Saw this in the other thread. Thanks. i'd missed that little gem of information.

[Jimbuna]

That's fine by me.

To recap:

There are at least four werewolves.
Jimbuna is a human.
There is at least one Guardian (the one who protected Jim)
We have several players MIA.

That werewolf I saw bore a striking resemblence to you :hmmm:

[Oberon]

Pfft, amateurs, I turned one of the guard towers into a veritable Fort Knox in the first Werewolf game, trip wires, searchlights, MG42s, the works.

Did bugger all to protect me though! :haha:

[August]

That werewolf I saw bore a striking resemblence to you :hmmm:

If you really think that Jim then you and who else reads this should vote accordingly. but if you're just kidding around then remember that each dead human puts your side closer to loosing the game. :shucks:

[Lord Justice]

when you Germans going to bury your dead it stinks around here now, :O: maybe you can fling your shovel into the compound when your done :up:

[Tarrasque]

when you Germans going to bury your dead it stinks around here now, :O: maybe you can fling your shovel into the compound when your done :up:

Perhaps because they're all werewolves and are leaving them round for a snack when they get peckish? :hmmm:

[Tinman764]

Team Human certainly seems to be getting its arse kicked at the moment! Time to stop thinking German v English and more Soft and Tasty v Hairy and dripping with blood IMO
:yeah:
(This announcement has been brought to you by Beyond the Grave! (tm))

[Lord Justice]

Perhaps because they're all werewolves and are leaving them round for a snack when they get peckish? :hmmm:Quite possibly :yeah: when they going to break the news about another death to the brits, is it not time they arm us?? :doh:

[Tarrasque]

Nah, they're going to keep us locked up. Haven't you realised yet, it's not a POW camp, it's a larder...

[AVGWarhawk]

Pfft, amateurs, I turned one of the guard towers into a veritable Fort Knox in the first Werewolf game, trip wires, searchlights, MG42s, the works.

Did bugger all to protect me though! :haha:

My goose is cooked then. :o

[August]

Quite possibly :yeah: when they going to break the news about another death to the brits, is it not time they arm us?? :doh:

Arm prisoners? Not a good idea even in the present circumstances.

[Tarrasque]

Arm prisoners? Not a good idea even in the present circumstances.

How well have the german guns worked so far?

[Pioneer]

Arm prisoners?

Hmmm, with the Germans losing so many, maybe the new CO can be swayed to the soft and tasty viewpoint.

[The Enigma]

The problem I have with this the 2 camps situation is:

I would like to put the German and English together, but since I'm low at rank, I can't walk into the pow camp and say "hey guys lets have a beer together and forget what has been said to each other in the past. Time to unite and fight the beast".

My superior would brick me for that, wouldn't he or am I playing my role way to 'officially'.

I'm new to the game and do my best, but taking the initiative isn't easy (also because of the language barrier).

Need to go back to school and have some English lessons:oops:

[August]

How well have the german guns worked so far?


They worked well enough against Vendor when we executed him and that's the point. There is a war on. Arming the enemy is treason.

Besides if we gave weapons to the prisoners what assurance would we have they wouldn't shoot us all down like the nazi dogs we are?

[Raptor1]

Arm prisoners? Not a good idea even in the present circumstances.

Perhaps you should start by telling us what is happening. The only time the Germans bothered to inform the British camp was an off-hand remark by Nisgeis that he 'told us' about the murders yesterday...

[August]

Perhaps you should start by telling us what is happening. The only time the Germans bothered to inform the British camp was an off-hand remark by Nisgeis that he 'told us' about the murders yesterday...

I'm just a Corporal dude. That would be the prerogative of the herr Hauptman.

[Tarrasque]

I would like to put the German and English together, but since I'm low at rank, I can't walk into the pow camp and say "hey guys lets have a beer together and forget what has been said to each other in the past. Time to unite and fight the beast".


Yeah, you'd need Rear or at the least Ducimus to do that.

[Raptor1]

I'm just a Corporal dude. That would be the prerogative of the herr Hauptman.

Well, yeah, I meant the Germans in general.

BTW...

::::Rises to the commotion and begins to wander about listening intently. The Germans have lost another, that makes the fourth in three nights plus we lost one of our own. The numbers are dwindling. The German can't afford to be guarding anywhere but the castle now, perhaps there may be a way out after all. The need to inspect the perimeter is rising. The stream, the woods, other side of the castle. The Germans are scared, now is the time to disrupt.:::

Pioneer walks toward the compound gate and notes there are still no guards around, and none that he can see. He begins feverishly using the wire form the fence to slot open the padlock on the gate. Within minutes the mechanism releases, and the padlock opens. He pockets the open padlock and closes it within the warmth of his pocket.

"No more tunneling under the wire, we'll just walk out now and wait to see where the challenge comes from."

Pioneer pushes the gate open and waits for the sound of gunfire or shouting. There is none, and he steps through. Nonchalantly he moves around the wire and heads for the stream, unchallenged by werewolf or German.

1. Where did you hear they lost another man? Nobody told us yet.

2. Are you even allowed to do that?

[The Enigma]

From the game thread:
OOC: Also:


Given last nights events Jimbuna has been shown to be a human.
You only have my word that Nisgeis accused me of being a werewolf.


I know, that's not a fact (yet) :smug:

[Task Force]

Ya know at the rate your pulling out weapons from that armory AVG warhawk, you will pull out a panzer 4 or something soon!

[Tarrasque]

At this rate he'll pull out some giant killer robot, let a lone a panzer 4

[Raptor1]

Of course he will, clearly the purpose of this remote outpost is to research time-traveling weaponry.

[The Enigma]

Wait, until he finds out those are all fake weapons :DL
The real armory has been replaced by me in during my nightshift :haha:

[mookiemookie]

What happened with yesterday's lynch vote? No action taken on it?

[The Enigma]

There's some confusion about it.

SS Nisgeis was chosen, but it seems he was in the nunnery.
(And perhaps killed by them??)

[Tarrasque]

Perhaps he died with a smile on his face?

Jim was supposed to kill him, but got scared off by the small hindrance of a werewolf trying to eat his face.

[AVGWarhawk]

Ya know at the rate your pulling out weapons from that armory AVG warhawk, you will pull out a panzer 4 or something soon!


Is there one in the garage? :hmmm:

[Task Force]

Is there one in the garage? :hmmm:

There might be!, or just a kubel... or some gardening equipment. (maybe a chainsaw)

[AVGWarhawk]

I did find this:

http://www.peachmountain.com/5star/images/AberdeenProvingGrounds/20060509_2099_NSengupta_AberdeenProvingGroundss.jp g

:D

[Tarrasque]

And I found this moored up at the dock....

http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_wjLSOEl0BZk/SV8yNeu98RI/AAAAAAAABWA/c128UHO4bKE/s400/bb56_med.jpg

[AVGWarhawk]

:D Can I use it? :har:

[Jimbuna]

What happened with yesterday's lynch vote? No action taken on it?

There's some confusion about it.

SS Nisgeis was chosen, but it seems he was in the nunnery.
(And perhaps killed by them??)

Yes, some detail on the subject or an answer even would be helpful.

[Onkel Neal]

Wendy, posting for Neal


Does Nisgeis return into the game now?



Who knows? :)

Wait, so the fact that Nisgeis was in the nunnery saves him from murderous retribution? Or is he missing never to return?

Who knows? ....


That's fine by me.

To recap:

There are at least four werewolves.
Jimbuna is a human.
There is at least one Guardian (the one who protected Jim)
We have several players MIA.

This is good game discussion, should be ingame.

Team Human certainly seems to be getting its arse kicked at the moment! Time to stop thinking German v English and more Soft and Tasty v Hairy and dripping with blood IMO
:yeah:
(This announcement has been brought to you by Beyond the Grave! (tm))

:)

[Rear]

Yes, some detail on the subject or an answer even would be helpful.

Yea I asked about that on page 14 of this thread :o I guess since noone discovered a corpse, the narrator didn't announce it?

Anyway I'm off to bed nn.

[Pioneer]

I hate being the only soul in my timezone...and a RL fire doesn't help either.

I utilized the overheard conversations to wander out. I was trying to head towards the castle to open up "the other side" by describing the terrain, with a view of "we must escape or we will die here".

[The Enigma]

That s*cks, Pioneer.
Is all ok?

[AVGWarhawk]

I hate being the only soul in my timezone...and a RL fire doesn't help either.

I utilized the overheard conversations to wander out. I was trying to head towards the castle to open up "the other side" by describing the terrain, with a view of "we must escape or we will die here".

Yeah, that sucks. I hope the fire did not ruin a lot.

[Onkel Neal]

The lynch vote coming up will be important for the humans. They have dodged several bullets, but now the odds are getting stacked against them. Choose wisely and get a werewolf this time.

[Pioneer]

Workplace fire, all is good.
Just buying into my werewolf time.

Q for the narrator: if we voted to lynch someone and the werewolf has decided to attack, who gets seniority? And how will be know?

And as a side issue, my avatar has changed twice since the hunt begun.

[Onkel Neal]

Q for the narrator: if we voted to lynch someone and the werewolf has decided to attack, who gets seniority? And how will be know?




When the lynch vote is counted at the end of Day, the person who wins, gets lynched right away. Except in the case of Nisgeis, who legitimately went off the grid. The nunnery was part of the game design, so he cannopt be lynched. When he returns, if he returns (mystery time-whooooo) then he is open to be lynched, like all the other players.

I see Enigma has invited the Brits into the castle for snaps, someone makes Jim doesn't miss out. He was cruelly disappointed the night before :)

[Tarrasque]

I've just remembered...I've got a bottle of rum stashed.

We can all get drunk and won't care we're being eaten by werewolves. :D

[The Enigma]

I'm off to bed now. Will pop in tomorrow morning (5/6 hours from now).

Have fun and cheers to that rum.

[Raptor1]

Do I still have to assign someone to leave the camp? That would be rather moot considering that it's wide open.

[Jimbuna]

Do I still have to assign someone to leave the camp? That would be rather moot considering that it's wide open.

Well there are areas inside the castle still to be explored....the same areas the Germans won't allow us to see.

[Pioneer]

By chance, if a werewolf kills a werewolf in the night, what form is found in the morning?

[mookiemookie]

By chance, if a werewolf kills a werewolf in the night, what form is found in the morning?

If it's anything like the last game, it's found as a werewolf.

[Tarrasque]

Think Neal's already explained this one.

If werewolf A attacks werewolf B then A finds out B is a werewolf. B is oblivious.

EDIT: Post #5 in this thread.

[AVGWarhawk]

Well there are areas inside the castle still to be explored....the same areas the Germans won't allow us to see.

OMG...the chamber of horrors!!! Oh the humanity! :o

[Onkel Neal]

Do I still have to assign someone to leave the camp? That would be rather moot considering that it's wide open.


You do, if you wanrt to. You think anyone is going out there at night unless they have orders?:cool: Now it's pure recon, no escape, and they can go anywhere on the map they choose...and feel safe.

Only one Brit can recon at a time.
One one Jerry can take leave at a time.

[Jimbuna]

Too late I should imagine...our fine leader appears to have abstained :DL

[Pioneer]

Think Neal's already explained this one.

If werewolf A attacks werewolf B then A finds out B is a werewolf. B is oblivious.

EDIT: Post #5 in this thread.

Post 5 deals with werewolf on werewolf attack.

If werewolf A kills werewolf B, I'll assume that Human C in the morning sees the werewolf.

Right?

[Onkel Neal]

2 hours to the vote

August ------- Rear
AVGWarhawk -------
Ducimuss -------
jimbuna ------- Lord Justice
Lord Justice ------- August
mookiemookie ------- Lord Justice
Nisgeis -------
Pioneer ------- Nisgeis
Raptor1 ------- Abstain
Rear ------- August
Takeda Shingen ------- Lord Justice
Tarrasque ------- Lord Justice
Task Force -------
The Enigma ------- Lord Justice

--------------- --------------- ---------------
Dungeon (protected) No one?
Leave ---- Nisgies (Still at the nunnery?)
Escaped -----Mookie

Did we miss anyone??

Posted by Wendy, check my count when you get home Neal

[The Enigma]

So that's one less of them creatures :rock:

[Nisgeis]

Let's not let role play get in the way of game play. We all know what has been said in the game thread and can discuss it, you don't have to have been in the room - you could have 'overheard it' or whatever. Otherwise you'd have to go round and tell everyone specifically and that would get tedious and spammy. The original werewolf games are played in an open room and everyone witnesses what happens. This is a more elaborate form, but we all still know what's happened.

There's no sense in not letting your character know something that has happened just because they weren't there, unless you have a reason to play it that way Mr. Werewolf :03:. If something happened in one of Neal's posts, we all know it and we all know it's absolutely true.

We all know the rules too, otherwise we don't know anything and can't even begin to analyse the evidence - e.g. if a guardian is attacked, they don't die in the first attack. If Neal says someone is a guardian, it would be a bit silly to lynch them, just because your character thinks it's a ruse, unless of course that is a ruse in itself Mr. Werewolf ;).

By the way... is the seer dead, or just asleep at the wheel?

One werewolf down. THREE (that we know of) to go.

[Nisgeis]

Do we have to get permission for leave in the day cycle and go off during the day?

[Rear]

2 hours to the vote

August ------- Nisgeis
AVGWarhawk ------- August
Ducimuss -------
HunterIXC ------- MookieMookie
jimbuna ------- Nisgeis
Lord Justice ------- Nisgeis
mookiemookie ------- Nisgeis
Nisgeis -------
Pioneer ------- Nisgeis
Raptor1 ------- Nisgeis
Rear ------- August
Takeda Shingen ------- Nisgeis
Tarrasque ------- Abstain
Task Force ------- Nisgeis
The Enigma -------
--------------- --------------- ---------------
Dungeon (protected) No one?
Leave ---- Nisgies (To the nunnery)
Escaped -----Jimbuna


If your vote is not shown, be sure to let us know.

posted for Neal, by Wendy

What? I thought Nisgeis died and now he comes back from the nunnery?? :dead:

[Lord Justice]

Because there was a bend in the rules, a good tactic all the same to be admired! but rules are rules ;). good luck gents, Very enjoyable, @ Pioneer, like your RP thanks for the salute.

[Jimbuna]

What? I thought Nisgeis died and now he comes back from the nunnery?? :dead:

I thought Neal had already answered that question? :hmmm:

[August]

I thought Neal had already answered that question? :hmmm:

The way I look at it, gone or not, he was voted by the players to be lynched. Now just because he's late to his hanging party that don't mean he should get a pardon out of it.

[AVGWarhawk]

The way I look at it, gone or not, he was voted by the players to be lynched. Now just because he's late to his hanging party that don't mean he should get a pardon out of it.


:hmmm:

[Onkel Neal]

No, no bend in the rules, that nunnery element was in from the get go. Nisgeis was the first to try it. There are quite a few other elements to be exploied, naturally I cannot provide a list of the surprise and secret portions of the game but they're there. You just have to find them.

[Onkel Neal]

Oh boy, it doesn't get any better than this. :smug: All night actions are in, I will be ending night shortly.

[Onkel Neal]

Ok, now that the players are down to 11, I will throw the exploration limit away. If you want to explore, the boundaries and risks still apply, but is no longer limited to a single player on each side.

As long as no one says "unfair", we can go with that from this point on, ok?

Remember, if you are unsure about something, you can PM me. If you are exploring something, post the description of your actions, then wait for me to update you with an Official Discovery. If you don't hear from me or my assistant Wendy in 4 hours or so, nothing was discovered.

Yes, the minefield extends to the forest. As was outlined in the initial Game PM, the waters are too dangerous. The woods are simply dangerous. And there's no Google Maps in 1942 to help you, so god have mercy on your souls.

[Rear]

I reckon there were 4 or 5 werewolves in the game from the start: Lord Justice, Takeda, August and Ducimus (possibly one or two more) :yep:

[Jimbuna]

Well it's certainly beginning to look like I've got the strongest heart :DL

[mookiemookie]

Yes, the minefield extends to the forest.

Into the forest? If so, I was unaware of this.

[Jimbuna]

Into the forest? If so, I was unaware of this.

Don't you go playing hop scotch in the minefield Mark :DL

[mookiemookie]

Don't you go playing hop scotch in the minefield Mark :DL

Looks like it may be too late. :dead:

[Jimbuna]

Looks like it may be too late. :dead:

Neals not around atm....want me to delete the post? :DL

[mookiemookie]

Neals not around atm....want me to delete the post? :DL

Yes, if it's within the rules.

[Onkel Neal]

Into the forest? If so, I was unaware of this.


To the forest.

[AVGWarhawk]

Yes, if it's within the rules.

Gonna cost ya! :O:

[Nisgeis]

Well it's certainly beginning to look like I've got the strongest heart :DL

How did you survive two attacks in a row? :hmmm:

[Onkel Neal]

I'm off to work now, Wendy will be watching the game, I will be back soon.

Great going, guys:rock:

[Nisgeis]

The way I look at it, gone or not, he was voted by the players to be lynched. Now just because he's late to his hanging party that don't mean he should get a pardon out of it.

You've got to be quicker than that!

[Nisgeis]

After leaving for work just after the cycle change, I was delayed at work and didn't make it back in time to read through all the posts and post before the deadine. Therefore I was unable to deliver the results of the examination of the bodies. Apparently they think subsim is not a work related site :stare:.

[Rear]

*Enigma enters the 'verbotene wald'*

That's handy, a nice path is inviting me to use it.
So be brave Enigma and take the easy way. Last days have been hard enough.

*The trees have grown up to the sky, keeping away the poorly shining sun.
It's becoming darker while Enigma enters the wood further.*

Darn, there must be some water in the neighborhood.
I can hear it's sound and it's getting a bit foggy again.

*There he discovers a small wooden bridge*

I need to roleplay a troll under the bridge :doh:

[August]

You've got to be quicker than that!

Quiet dead man! :DL

[The Enigma]

I need to roleplay a troll under the bridge :doh:

That dog Harris (I believe) is more then enough :03:

[Raptor1]

Ah, I knew I'd get killed. Rather surprised it didn't happen sooner...

[The Enigma]

At the very end we all will :03:

Nice role playing Raptor1 :salute:

[Task Force]

Sorry i couldn't vote yesterday, ISP went down for awhile.

[August]

I wish somebody would kill me off because I have totally lost the plot here.

It's way late in the game and the only persons who I don't think could be werewolves are:

A. Enigma, mainly because we were in the same room all night and I'm not ripped to shreds.

and

B. Jimbuna. Neal correct me if i'm wrong but once night falls all werewolves still make the change into wolves regardless of whether they decide to attack someone or not? Well if so then since Jim was still in human form both times he came face to face with a werewolf and he also didn't change into a wolf the first night Oberon and myself guarded him ergo he must be a human.

and of course

C. Me. :D So far I have shared a guard post with two other players, both of who survived the night and neither of who changed into wolves.

Now everyone else seems to deliberately separate themselves from everyone else when night falls. If you're going to keep people from identifying you as a wolf i'd think getting away from prying eyes so you can make your change in private is vital.

So My Lynching pick for tonight is Rear but AVG is a close second... :salute:

[Jimbuna]

How did you survive two attacks in a row? :hmmm:

jimbuna is Neals alias account :DL

[Jimbuna]

I wish somebody would kill me off because I have totally lost the plot here.

It's way late in the game and the only persons who I don't think could be werewolves are:

A. Enigma, mainly because we were in the same room all night and I'm not ripped to shreds.

and

B. Jimbuna. Neal correct me if i'm wrong but once night falls all werewolves still make the change into wolves regardless of whether they decide to attack someone or not? Well if so then since Jim was still in human form both times he came face to face with a werewolf and he also didn't change into a wolf the first night Oberon and myself guarded him ergo he must be a human.

and of course

C. Me. :D So far I have shared a guard post with two other players, both of who survived the night and neither of who changed into wolves.

Now everyone else seems to deliberately separate themselves from everyone else when night falls. If you're going to keep people from identifying you as a wolf i'd think getting away from prying eyes so you can make your change in private is vital.

So My Lynching pick for tonight is Rear but AVG is a close second... :salute:

I hope you've posted your vote in the 'official' game thread.

[AVGWarhawk]

AVG is a close second


I'm on the beach heavily armed....Come at me bro.... :stare:

http://chloeandeddie.com/wp-content/plugins/wp-o-matic/cache/3c6f5_demotivational-posters-come-at-me-bro.jpg

[Rear]

I'm disappointed that anyone thinks I'm a werewolf but now I'm off to bed so I got my lynch vote in a while ago, and hopefully there'll be one less werewolf around with Takeda in chains :up:

[The Enigma]

I wish somebody would kill me off because I have totally lost the plot here.


Maybe that's because you aren't in the game thread, like Jimbuna already mentioned.

[AVGWarhawk]

I'm disappointed that anyone thinks I'm a werewolf but now I'm off to bed so I got my lynch vote in a while ago, and hopefully there'll be one less werewolf around with Takeda in chains :up:

Oh sure..throw that in there....:O:

[August]

Maybe that's because you aren't in the game thread, like Jimbuna already mentioned.

I already voted in the game thread. My post above was not in character so I thought it best to post my thoughts here. Is that not correct?

[Takeda Shingen]

I'm disappointed that anyone thinks I'm a werewolf but now I'm off to bed so I got my lynch vote in a while ago, and hopefully there'll be one less werewolf around with Takeda in chains :up:

That's exactly what a werewolf would say.

[Jimbuna]

I already voted in the game thread. My post above was not in character so I thought it best to post my thoughts here. Is that not correct?

That is correct Sir.

[Jimbuna]

I'm on the beach heavily armed....Come at me bro.... :stare:



Oh...don't tempt me :DL

[Rear]

I'm on the beach heavily armed....Come at me bro.... :stare:



Oh...don't tempt me :DL

Yea especially considering his high survival rate :)

[AVGWarhawk]

Oh...don't tempt me :DL

:O: I'm the one with the bucket and shovel..




Yea especially considering his high survival rate


:up:

[Jimbuna]

Yea especially considering his high survival rate :)

http://www.findlove-keeplove.com/images/green-eyed-monster.jpg

[AVGWarhawk]

I will have to say that I'm have a really good time with this and those involved. Good fun.

[Takeda Shingen]

I will have to say that I'm have a really good time with this and those involved. Good fun.

Me too. This has been a blast! :up:

[Bakkels]

Yeah, it was a blast... :shifty:

I enjoy following the story though :03:

[Jimbuna]

I will have to say that I'm have a really good time with this and those involved. Good fun.

Me too. This has been a blast! :up:

SINK EM ALL!!

[August]

SINK EM ALL!!

This has been a lot more fun than I thought it would be when Neal put the arm on me to play. :DL

Neal :salute:

[Onkel Neal]

2 hours to the vote

August ------- Rear
AVGWarhawk -------
Ducimuss -------
jimbuna ------- Rear
mookiemookie ------- Rear
Pioneer ------- Rear
Rear ------- ?
Takeda Shingen ------- Rear
Tarrasque ------- Takeda
Task Force ------- Rear
The Enigma ------- AVGWarhawk (PM)
--------------- --------------- ---------------
Dungeon - Takeda
Leave ---- every man for himself
Escaped -----same


Did we miss anyone?? You guys better vote, you could be killed as a nonessential NCP :O:

Posted by Wendy, check my count when you get home Neal

[AVGWarhawk]

I had voted rear. :DL

[Pioneer]

I voted Rear only to get the extra vote.

[mookiemookie]

Rear's got my vote as well. (http://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showpost.php?p=1693684&postcount=650)

[Nisgeis]

Poor Rear. Obviously only a werewolf could... use the PA system..?! You guys don't work for FIFA do you? :DL

Three Werewolves left versus seven humans left. You need three more day cycles in order to kill all the werewolves, but will you all survive the three night cycles that requires?

EDIT: Three werewolves that we know of... *twilight zone music*.

[Onkel Neal]

Yep, it's looking bad for the humans, but who knows!

[Tinman764]

lol and Rear was the only guy that I would have said with any certainty was a werewolf... :hmmm:

[Rear]

Yep, it's looking bad for the humans, but who knows!

Well at least there is (hopefully) one werewolf in the dungeon still :up: At least until he is let out by Ducimus/August... personally I think the werewolves started voting me out as soon as they knew their game was up.

Anyway it's probably a good thing that I died since I was finding it hard to RP with work + sleep :)


EDIT: Also with the amount of starting players it would make sense to have 2 german wws and 2 english/us wws (imo August, Ducimus, LJ and Takeda)

[Jimbuna]

Hmm...an interesting list of names you have there...you could be half correct :hmmm:

[Takeda Shingen]

Well at least there is (hopefully) one werewolf in the dungeon still :up: At least until he is let out by Ducimus/August... personally I think the werewolves started voting me out as soon as they knew their game was up.

Anyway it's probably a good thing that I died since I was finding it hard to RP with work + sleep :)


EDIT: Also with the amount of starting players it would make sense to have 2 german wws and 2 english/us wws (imo August, Ducimus, LJ and Takeda)

Shoddy detective work is shoddy.

[Tarrasque]

What the?

Where did that one come from?

[Takeda Shingen]

:rotfl2::rotfl2::rotfl2:

I figured that Steve would make an appearance eventually. It wouldn't be a SubSim game without him.

Great twist. :up:

[Sailor Steve]

Blame Neal. :D

He encouraged me to embellish a little, but of course the story is all his. :sunny:

[AVGWarhawk]

ZZ Top is on the island! :o

[AVGWarhawk]

Good stuff! :up::up:

[Onkel Neal]

Every great play has to have a cameo ;)

And no, the tower will not protect anyone but Tiresias, so I don't wanna see all the players packed into the top, hanging out of windows :D

[Sailor Steve]

Every great play has to have a cameo ;)

And no, the tower will not protect anyone but Tiresias, so I don't wanna see all the players packed into the top, hanging out of windows :D
It's okay, Will warned 'em, didn't he? They'd get pretty hungry after a couple of days. :sunny:

[AVGWarhawk]

I feel a disturbance in the Force. :hmmm:

[Rear]

So only one death while Takeda is in the dungeon? Maybe I was right, or maybe the werewolves cut down their attacks to make people suspect Takeda? :yeah:

[mookiemookie]

So only one death while Takeda is in the dungeon? Maybe I was right, or maybe the werewolves cut down their attacks to make people suspect Takeda? :yeah:

Or a werewolf tried to attack another werewolf, or someone protected by a guardian.

[Nisgeis]

EDIT: Also with the amount of starting players it would make sense to have 2 german wws and 2 english/us wws (imo August, Ducimus, LJ and Takeda)

Except, it's all completely random. First game there were three werewolves in the sub - and that was with three groups (sub, camp, and village). I think you're right about Ducimus and August.

Or a werewolf tried to attack another werewolf, or someone protected by a guardian.

This will get more and more likely until you can be sure they will all know.

Three werewolves versus six humans.

EDIT:
One in three chance of lynching a werewolf at random
NONE in three chance of lynching a werewolf with current voting reasons. :-)

[Task Force]

Wow, i actually made it this far before dieing! Amazing!

[Onkel Neal]

Official Discovery

The bearer of the talisman is protected from Werewolf attack.

The talisman only protects one person, the bearer.

It can be given away, but no one can steal it.


That is all I can say.

[Nisgeis]

Official Discovery

The bearer of the talisman is protected from Werewolf attack.

The talisman only protects one person, the bearer.

It can be given away, but no one can steal it.


That is all I can say.

Same rules? E.G. One attack and you lose the power (of the amulet for any that wear it)?

[AVGWarhawk]

Official Discovery

The bearer of the talisman is protected from Werewolf attack.

The talisman only protects one person, the bearer.

It can be given away, but no one can steal it.


That is all I can say.

Can I buy it? :DL

[mookiemookie]

Can I buy it? :DL

Only if you're offering enough to buy my way off this crazy island. :|\\

[AVGWarhawk]

Only if you're offering enough to buy my way off this crazy island. :|\\


If I could afford that we would not need the talisman. :DL

[Tinman764]

The way the game is going for the humans, I wouldn't bet against a werewolf taking control of the talisman :up:

[Pioneer]

Can we "acquire" the talisman after lynching the holder?

[mookiemookie]

Can we "acquire" the talisman after lynching the holder?

http://fc09.deviantart.net/fs71/f/2011/145/9/1/rage_faces_by_shishywonka-d3h8gca.png

[Nisgeis]

Can we "acquire" the talisman after lynching the holder?

You'd be killed in the rush... but could a werewolf even hold it?

[Jimbuna]

You'd be killed in the rush... but could a werewolf even hold it?

Best answer possible :DL

[Nisgeis]

Since Rear was lynched, that leaves Ducimus in charge. That means no one in the interrogation cell, which means all potential werewolves loose and none are restrained.

Looks like Ducimus will be lynched, so that's OK as the next in line is... August! :timeout:

I can't seem to find the rules about overthrowing the camp authority... anyone got a link?

By the way AVG and Takeda - nice investigation banter... but Ducimus has been absent since the game began, poor, poor,Vendor will get a complex.

[Jimbuna]

For a minute you've got me confused...are you out of the game or running another one in parallel? :DL

[Rear]

Yes Ducimus has been inactive for a while afaik and there seem to be less ww attacks so I assumed he was a ww :ping:

[Nisgeis]

For a minute you've got me confused...are you out of the game or running another one in parallel? :DL

Commenting on this one, which I still have an interest in, after all if my side wins, so do I! The first game everyone was discussing events, much to the secret annoyance of a certain werewolf (me!) and we can even reveal our classes... after who knows if he is telling the truth, other than the fabulously slim and handsome Narrator? The only thing we can't do is reveal * official * spoilers.

This game has the same features as last time that make it tough... werewolves have the players discussing the game and pointing out logic flaws and rules and the werewolves have the problem that guardians have been publicly named, which makes it jolly tricky to get them lynched! This time though it's slightly different as the guardians aren't immortal.

EDIT: For example, I can't reveal what happened up at the nunnery. What happens at the nunnery, stays at the nunnery.

[Tinman764]

I'm really enjoying keeping up with the goings on.... I have absolutely no clue who is human and who isn't! :hmmm:
Have to say I'm looking forward to the next hunt, would liked to survive longer than I managed in this one lol

[Sailor Steve]

What happens at the nunnery, stays at the nunnery.

Nun's the word. :D

[Onkel Neal]

Yes, please be sure in commenting that you or anyone as an ex-player does not give away anything to the poor players still trying to cope.

The Talisman may be given to another player, the original holder must PM me well before night and cc the receipient. After it changes hands, the new owner may elect to keep it or give it away.

In case of death by the owner of the talisman, there is a custordy chain but I ain't telling what it is.

[andy_311]

To AVGWARHAWK just how did you mange to get of the beach and back to the castle which you thought that would be your doom(killingfields) am looseing track of this game (and im not even in it) somebody please explain please.

[Takeda Shingen]

By the way AVG and Takeda - nice investigation banter... but Ducimus has been absent since the game began, poor, poor,Vendor will get a complex.

Thank you! AVG is a very good person to RP with.

[AVGWarhawk]

To AVGWARHAWK just how did you mange to get of the beach and back to the castle which you thought that would be your doom(killingfields) am looseing track of this game (and im not even in it) somebody please explain please.


I returned yesterday evening to see Rear buy the farm. After all, I did suggest his lynching! This was not acted out in game. Some things are naturally assumed after the narrator steps in with new facts and storyline.

Some ad libbing goes on as well because of how Neal makes the game progress. Time differences in response. His interjected storyline. Things of that nature will skew what has transpired.

[AVGWarhawk]

Thank you! AVG is a very good person to RP with.


Yes sir! A lot of fun with Tak and RP! Much fun this game is.

[Ducimus]

I haven't been active because i can't keep up with the thread. Lynch me, please. You'd be doing me a favor. This last weekend just blew me out of the water. 5 or 6 pages to 23 or more pages. I got stuff to do, i can't keep up with that. So ever since then, my attention span has been VERY low.

[AVGWarhawk]

I haven't been active because i can't keep up with the thread. Lynch me, please. You'd be doing me a favor. This last weekend just blew me out of the water. 5 or 6 pages to 23 or more pages. I got stuff to do, i can't keep up with that. So ever since then, my attention span has been VERY low.

Off with his head! :O:

[Jimbuna]

I haven't been active because i can't keep up with the thread. Lynch me, please. You'd be doing me a favor. This last weekend just blew me out of the water. 5 or 6 pages to 23 or more pages. I got stuff to do, i can't keep up with that. So ever since then, my attention span has been VERY low.

Of that you can be assured :DL

[Jimbuna]

Nun's the word. :D

ROFLMAO :har:

[Tarrasque]

Mookie continues to caress the talisman

"You may be of use elsewhere...."


((I MAY be giving this to another player. I have PMed the Narrator about it))


*Sticks hand up.*

Pick me, Pick me! :haha:

[August]

I returned yesterday evening to see Rear buy the farm. After all, I did suggest his lynching! This was not acted out in game. Some things are naturally assumed after the narrator steps in with new facts and storyline.

Some ad libbing goes on as well because of how Neal makes the game progress. Time differences in response. His interjected storyline. Things of that nature will skew what has transpired.

There is something I think I should point out. I recently discovered that our ad libbing does not necessarily affect the storyline.

You can arm yourself with anything you want. You can put yourself in the most secure location imaginable. You can even drape yourself in garlic and load your gun with silver bullets. It will still not prevent a werewolf from killing you if he chooses you. The only exceptions to that are specifically designated game items/characters.

Also, spending the night with someone does not indicate their status. If they are a wolf they will be able to leave the human they are with, go off and murder someone else, then return without that human (or anyone else) realizing that it happened. That goes for two werewolves as well. Unless they choose each other as victims they will not know that their companion of the night did anything but sit there and wait for dawn.

[Tarrasque]

I think that has to be so due to how the game works. If a werewolf couldn't act whilst with others, everyone would just get into one room and stare at each other all night causing a stalemate - hence the slight discrepancy between the RP part and the actual game part.

[Jimbuna]

I think that has to be so due to how the game works. If a werewolf couldn't act whilst with others, everyone would just get into one room and stare at each other all night causing a stalemate - hence the slight discrepancy between the RP part and the actual game part.

^ :yep:

[AVGWarhawk]

I think that has to be so due to how the game works. If a werewolf couldn't act whilst with others, everyone would just get into one room and stare at each other all night causing a stalemate - hence the slight discrepancy between the RP part and the actual game part.

Yes, some leeway is provided on night action. Who has done what and when. No matter, we are just puppets on Neal's island attempting to survive the pull of our strings. It's more about convincing and manipulating the others to gain your goal. And I'm having a hell of a lot of fun being a part. :)

[mookiemookie]

*Sticks hand up.*

Pick me, Pick me! :haha:

I may pick myself. It depends on who I can trust. I think I'm keeping it. I asked Neal because I just wanted to know what my options were.

But then again, I may be a wolf and I enjoy keeping it out of your puny human hands. :03:

[AVGWarhawk]

http://quizilla.teennick.com/user_images/H/HE/HEA/heather679/1192898882_1behemoth1.jpg

[August]

He don't look so tough... :roll:

[Onkel Neal]

All I can say is, this is going to be a crucial night, for either side. Very interesting.... :hmmm:

[AVGWarhawk]

He don't look so tough... :roll:

The guy with the entrails hanging out? :hmmm:

[Onkel Neal]

2 hours to the vote

August ------- Ducimus
AVGWarhawk ------- Ducimus
Ducimuss -------
jimbuna ------- Ducimus
mookiemookie ------- Ducimus
Pioneer -------
Takeda Shingen ------- Ducimus
Tarrasque ------- Ducimus
The Enigma ------- AVGWarhawk
--------------- --------------- ---------------
Dungeon - busted lock
Leave ---- every man for himself
Escaped -----same


Did we miss anyone??
Posted by Wendy

[August]

The guy with the entrails hanging out? :hmmm:

Naw that overgrown poodle of course! :DL

[The Enigma]

Did we miss anyone??

Yes, my vote. I voted AVGWarhawk

[The Enigma]

Is there a reason why the game thread is still locked?

[Onkel Neal]

Waiting for the poor Narratr to get home from work.

Will be open in 15

[The Enigma]

Real Life has of course higher priority. :yep:

[Jimbuna]

Neal....I believe I voted Ducimus before the deadline.

[Tarrasque]

Neal....I believe I voted Ducimus before the deadline.

As had I.

*Discusses with AVGWarhawk the likely candidates left to be a flesh-eating hairy blood-thirsty monster.*

"I guess I'm going to have to agree with you on this one. Ducimus must go. That's if he's not already slain in some alcove somewhere."

[Jimbuna]

Yep..voted for Ducimus @12:07 (2 1/2 hours prior to your post).

http://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showpost.php?p=1694322&postcount=684

No worries mate the outcome wasn't affected.

[Onkel Neal]

Ok, thanks, I don't see how I missed that, but yes, no change in outcome.


Mookie sits in the courtyard grumbling at the situation...

***8220;I was woken around 3 a.m. by something outside. I thought it might have been someone trying to break in. It was a chicken. At two in the morning! What is a chicken doing awake at this hour?***8221;


Buh-BUK!

[Pioneer]

Buh-BUK!

Oh cr@p.

[Takeda Shingen]

"He is assembling coffee, tea and donuts for the meeting. I hear there will be free hand outs."

:DL

(OOC: :haha:)

[AVGWarhawk]

At two in the morning! What is a chicken doing awake at this hour?***8221;

It's either being choked or it is a were-chicken.

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_Dlum8FS-7kw/S0Icny9ZCsI/AAAAAAAAAHE/EpslV6Jn7og/s320/chiustream_werechicken.jpg

[Onkel Neal]

Where once there were 20, now only 6 remain.

Roster

Castle Collinswood
Oberst HunterIXC (Colonel) [DEAD, killed by werewolf]
Hauptmann Rear (Captain) [DEAD, killed by firing squad]
Oberfeldwebel Ducimus (Sergeant Major) [DEAD, killed by firing squad]
Gefreiter Tinman764 (Corporal) [DEAD, killed by werewolf]
Gefreiter August (Corporal) [DEAD, killed by werewolf]
Schuetze The Enigma (Private)
Schuetze Oberon (Private) [DEAD, killed by werewolf]
Schuetze the_tyrant (Private) [DEAD, killed by werewolf]
Schuetze AVGWarhawk (Private)
SS Nisgeis [DEAD, killed by werewolf]



HMS Terrific
Captain Raptor1 [DEAD, killed by werewolf]
Sub-lieutenant mookiemookie
Chief Tarrasque
Petty Officer jimbuna
Petty Officer Lord Justice [DEAD, killed by firing squad]
Sailor Task Force [DEAD, killed by werewolf]
Sailor Pioneer [DEAD, killed by werewolf]
Sailor Vendor [DEAD, killed by firing squad]
American News Takeda Shingen
Cook Bakkels [DEAD, killed by werewolf]

[Tarrasque]

At this rate, there's going to be more werewolves than humans left.

[Onkel Neal]

"Men, seize Mr. AVGWarhawk, and Mr. Tarrasque as well if he refuses to relinquish his weapon."


:haha: in this case, "men" refers to Jim


Reminder: please, remember no one can shoot anyone else :) Let's play this all the way out, no cheap suicides either :) thanks!

[Takeda Shingen]

At this rate, there's going to be more werewolves than humans left.

No, there are only two wolves left. AVG is one. The identity of the other will be clear soon enough.

[Bakkels]

Haha game thread is going into high gear, and even seeps into this thread :03:. Keep it up guys, very interesting!

[Tarrasque]

Oh yeah! :D

I'm even starting to get an adrenaline rush! :haha:

[Onkel Neal]

In case of a tie, no lynching.

[Tarrasque]

I've got to head out.

I'll try to keep track and post on my phone but may not be able to dependent on signal.

[Jimbuna]

:haha: in this case, "men" refers to Jim


Reminder: please, remember no one can shoot anyone else :) Let's play this all the way out, no cheap suicides either :) thanks!

LOL :DL

[Ducimus]

All im going to say is how many of ya i attacked is for me to know and you to guess on. :D

I couldn't follow the thread conversation, it was just too much for me to follow. Luckily all i needed was an active roster list when i PMed Neal my actions. :O:

[Bakkels]

All im going to say is how many of ya i attacked is for me to know and you to guess on. :D

I couldn't follow the thread conversation, it was just too much for me to follow. Luckily all i needed was an active roster list when i PMed Neal my actions. :O:

And all I'm going to say is I'd be really pissed off if I was killed by an animated black sheep :O: :haha:

[Ducimus]

And all I'm going to say is I'd be really pissed off if I was killed by an animated black sheep :O: :haha:

Picture with Language not safe for people with virgin ears: (http://www.ducimus.net/sh415/blacksheep.jpg)

:O:

[Bakkels]

:yeah::rotfl2:

[The Enigma]

Hey AVGWarHawk, I hope you don't take it personally.
I'm just accusing The Schutze. :03:

[AVGWarhawk]

Hey AVGWarHawk, I hope you don't take it personally.
I'm just accusing The Schutze. :03:

It's part of the game. :up:

[The Enigma]

:salute:

[Rear]

One thing I'll never get is why August and Nisgeis accused each other of being werewolves :damn:

[Ducimus]

You should have seen the PM Nisgesis sent me. Talk about trying to be sneaky! lol

[Pioneer]

Neal, when all is said and done can you supply a night by night account of what actions took place? Who killed who?

[Nisgeis]

One thing I'll never get is why August and Nisgeis accused each other of being werewolves :damn:

Can you find in the game thread where I accused August? August was the one that said I had accused him...

Ducimus was right... I was being sneaky, but in such a way that it should have been obvious. Ducimus' reaction was sort of right - say nothing, disagree with me would have been better. August apparently didn't 'get it'. His reaction was odd, given everyone knew the rules! Will elaborate after game end.

[Raptor1]

I wonder how AVG can cite all those events that he never knew even happened as evidence... :hmmm:

[Nisgeis]

I wonder how AVG can cite all those events that he never knew even happened as evidence... :hmmm:

Oh come on... if in the game thread Andy and Bob were comparing claw size and saying 'No, no, I insist you kill Charlie and I take Dave'... would you seriously not vote for Andy or Bob for werewolves?

Anything in the game thread is public. Private is what PMs are for. Don't get hung up on the Role play, as excellent as it is, as it will kill the gameplay, which is based on official events and the rules.

Last game we had someone who invented a 'werefish test' which people were lynched because of... almost screwed the game completely because one of the werefish drank the bug juice and hardly anyone would believe the test wasn't genuine. Of course it was a pure fabrication, it took some persuading that it wasn't real (official). Anything anyone says in the threads is public knowledge (you can listen at keyholes, or overhear or whatever for role play) - I think this is the reason that Rear started using the PA system - because people complained that they hadn't been told stuff. His reward for trying to make the game thread accessible to everyone? A bullet to the face.

[The Enigma]

That's what I understood a bit too late.
All content of posted msg's are known stuff to everybody.

[Onkel Neal]

Neal, when all is said and done can you supply a night by night account of what actions took place? Who killed who?


Yes, we can, and all players, in and out of the game should wait until the game is over before discussing the tactics and maneuvers they used and saw from other players. Just one more day, I bet.

[Raptor1]

Oh come on... if in the game thread Andy and Bob were comparing claw size and saying 'No, no, I insist you kill Charlie and I take Dave'... would you seriously not vote for Andy or Bob for werewolves?

Anything in the game thread is public. Private is what PMs are for. Don't get hung up on the Role play, as excellent as it is, as it will kill the gameplay, which is based on official events and the rules.

Last game we had someone who invented a 'werefish test' which people were lynched because of... almost screwed the game completely because one of the werefish drank the bug juice and hardly anyone would believe the test wasn't genuine. Of course it was a pure fabrication, it took some persuading that it wasn't real (official). Anything anyone says in the threads is public knowledge (you can listen at keyholes, or overhear or whatever for role play) - I think this is the reason that Rear started using the PA system - because people complained that they hadn't been told stuff. His reward for trying to make the game thread accessible to everyone? A bullet to the face.

Nobody is realistically going to openly admit he is a werewolf on the game thread, therefore that is moot. If someone did that, I would vote for them, but only out of character. Similarly, if you're going to present a theory based off of knowledge your character can't possibly have, you can always do so out of character...

Well, it could be just me, since the hunt itself doesn't interest me that much and so I mostly play the game for the role-playing (Which I do enjoy a lot).

BTW, did anyone take the bug juice test seriously last game (Out of character, I mean)? I most certainly did not.

[Nisgeis]

Yes they did take it seriously. Massively so. I had to go through the entire thread to find an instance where Silverraptor had drunk bug juice until Tarjak would believe it wasn't a true test.

But, others also like an excuse to lynch. So, when Vendor is declared a non-combatant and out of the game, the reaction was to vote to lynch him. This is a 'nice' thing to do, as it doesn't 'spoil' the game for any player still active, but on the other hand you've been told that Vendor won't be playing and even if he is a werewolf cannot attack you, so the choice comes down to someone who cannot attack you and anyone else who possibly could be a werewolf and definately will attack you.

People chose the person who definately would not attack them, versus the person who possibly could.

[AVGWarhawk]

I'm too young to die!!! I'm just the damn gardener!

[Tinman764]

What Nisgeis said about the sympathy vote against Vendor is totally true in my case - but I have the excuse of never having done one of these games before so had no idea what to expect.
I think tactics definatly need to come before (but not at the expense of) roleplay. the_enigma's knowledge that he uses in his tirade at AVG could have come from many different sources - incidental "Oh by the way..." comments from people around him... these shouldn't need to be RP'd to advance the story...

Plus, it makes some damn good reading! :yeah:

[Nisgeis]

You're right Tinman. I wish we could have worked together :DL. At the end of the best game almost everyone (if not a sole survivor) is dead. :rock: Bring on the body count!

[Tarrasque]

Well this one has almost gone to the limit.

[Nisgeis]

It will be very tricky for the werewolves to get Jimbuna and Mookie lynched :DL.

[Raptor1]

I agree that not every piece of information has to be RPed to be learned by a character, unless they want it to be so. My problem is with information that they could never have come by. For example, in the beginning of the game, if the Germans held up in their castle and never told the British about a murder, the British could not possibly know about it, but if a German strolled by and told it to one of the Brits, then the knowledge would spread easily enough to the rest of the British players. If you somehow get to know in-character something like a character's thoughts at some point, or some random minor background event that happened when you weren't present and nobody would otherwise note, then that's somewhat more problematic.

EDIT: Problematic for me, of course. Don't mind my ranting. :O:

[Tinman764]

What's the normal rule as far as PMing someone in a game? Do people normally RP a whisper, or a secret note or are PM's totally secret?

I saw in the 1st hunt a lot of RP'd PM's, but not seen anything in this one though there must be a fair amount going on :)

[Bakkels]

I thought I've seen some hints to pm-ing going on in the game thread, but indeed, not as much as in the first hunt. Neal didn't mention restrictions about that, if you want (or wanted;)) to PM someone, you were free to do so and not mention it in the game thread.

[Tarrasque]

Some of mine have been RPed. The latter ones where the werewolves are about to win and lynch the innocent people have been a bit more urgent and nor RPed

[August]

Now that i'm out of it I can say that I didn't really follow the game last time so the idea that nothing anyone posted actually affected the game play came as a surprise to me.

It's kind of embarrassing to admit this but for most of the game I really had believed that if I could verify someones location and status all night, pulling a guard shift with someone for example, and they didn't turn into a werewolf in front of my eyes (as it were) then for sure they weren't one.

The change between human and wolf form as well as the historically typical werewolf behavior (ripping the lungs out of anyone and everyone they can get their claws on) would be an impossible event to miss (or survive), at least it would be in any book or movie werewolf representation that I'd ever heard of. Same thing with the game werewolves ability to get past any defenses no matter how impervious. Heck, even Lon Chaney Jr. could be stopped by a stout door and a good lock!

So I played the game based on that idea, thereby casting undue suspicion against those who would deliberately separate themselves from the rest of the group. (Sorry Rear. :oops:), as well as undue trust in those who would seek to band together with others. Now I know that such devices are useless if I ever participate in this game again, i'll do so without saying or reading anything outside of official storyline posts from Neal.

This has been a lot more fun than I originally thought it would be when Neal invited me to play but without player interaction meaning something there are (to the plain human player at least) an insufficient number of reliable clues with which to accurately base decisions about anyone's guilt or innocence.

[Bakkels]

Well you were called in at the last minute, so it's nothing to be embarrassed about. I thought it was weird too at first, and I had to read back the first werewolf hunt to really understand how it is played. I guess you weren't given the time to do that.

[Tarrasque]

I think that's the whole point. It's all about the trust and the paranoia. Everyone could be a werewolf.

For example, in the last one, there was a fairly stable alliance of humans formed. Except by the end of it, they trusted me as an outsider more than they trusted each other.

The only people that can be certain as to what someone is are the seers and like Cassandra from greek mythology, they are rarely believed until it's too late.

[mookiemookie]

It will be very tricky for the werewolves to get Jimbuna and Mookie lynched :DL.

http://cdn0.knowyourmeme.com/i/000/106/887/original/backpain-1292835351.jpg?1300412448

[Tarrasque]

Well jimbuna is impossible to be lynched, because we know he's a human.

[mookiemookie]

Well jimbuna is impossible to be lynched, because we know he's a human.

Humans can be lynched just as anyone else can. Look what happened to poor Rear.

[Tarrasque]

Yeah. But no human is going to knowingly lynch another human. We know for definite Jim is human courtesy of the two cases where he was protected from attack.