2009 SUBSIM Werewolf Hunt - Signup and Q&A Thread

[Oberon]

Originally Posted by Weiß Pinguin

Indeed. I imagine that anyone attacked for real would have mentioned it somewhere by now.

They wouldn't have known because they had a guardian protecting them. So whoever was attacked was whoever the guardians were protecting last night.

[Onkel Neal]

Originally Posted by Oberon

Great pic of the Uboat dock and fuel tanks and die Kamp by the way Neal. Nicely composed

Thanks

[Nisgeis]

Haha! My 750th post and I became a grey wolf!

[Task Force]

Maby the wolf attacked a guardian last night.

[Oberon]

Originally Posted by Task Force

Maby the wolf attacked a guardian last night.

I'm not 100% sure of the rules, Neal will probably give a better overview, but I think that if a wolf attacks a guardian, the guardian will die, but if the wolf attacks someone protected by a guardian it will be beaten off. Quite possibly why AVSM and Mookie survived after the attack on Chad.
Therefore, perhaps the question should be asked, who did AVSM and Mookie protect last night, for it was one of the accused, then the other is the wolf.
Of course, if they protected each other, or my assumption that a guardian will die if attacked directly by a wolf is wrong then the entire process is torpedoed out of the water.

[Oberon]

Oi! Task Force, stop haunting the villagers and the Ubootwaffles, or I'll give these guys a ring:

[Task Force]

Originally Posted by Oberon

I'm not 100% sure of the rules, Neal will probably give a better overview, but I think that if a wolf attacks a guardian, the guardian will die, but if the wolf attacks someone protected by a guardian it will be beaten off. Quite possibly why AVSM and Mookie survived after the attack on Chad.
Therefore, perhaps the question should be asked, who did AVSM and Mookie protect last night, for it was one of the accused, then the other is the wolf.
Of course, if they protected each other, or my assumption that a guardian will die if attacked directly by a wolf is wrong then the entire process is torpedoed out of the water.

But if a regular werewolf attacks a guardian. The werewolf dosent kill anyone. Only a hellhound can.

[Oberon]

That must mean that there's a third guardian, because AVSM and Mookie were both exposed as guardians after Chads death, so no werewolf would target them. Unless they were guarding someone in which case the wolf would be beaten off, which boils back down to who were they guarding?

[Onkel Neal]

Jimbuna, have you voted yet??

[Onkel Neal]

Originally Posted by Oberon

I'm not 100% sure of the rules, Neal will probably give a better overview, but I think that if a wolf attacks a guardian, the guardian will die, but if the wolf attacks someone protected by a guardian it will be beaten off. Quite possibly why AVSM and Mookie survived after the attack on Chad.
Therefore, perhaps the question should be asked, who did AVSM and Mookie protect last night, for it was one of the accused, then the other is the wolf.
Of course, if they protected each other, or my assumption that a guardian will die if attacked directly by a wolf is wrong then the entire process is torpedoed out of the water.

The rules do not appear to specifically say this, but I think it is implied: if a werewolf attackes a guardian, the attack is beaten off. I didn't make up those rules myself, I copied those rules from another game, so they appear to be a little less than totally complete, as StdDev has pointed out. But, the important thing: I have applied the rules consistently. In the next game, we can add the additional provisions, such as when two werewolves attack each other in the same night (both die)

or if a Hell Hound attacks a human who is guarded by a guardian, who is in turn guarded by another guardian (the first victim, the human, dies)

or if a two werewolves attack the same human who is protected by a guardian (I dunno... whatever will keep the game balanced works for me).

[Penelope_Grey]

What happens in the even of a tie?

[Onkel Neal]

I guess I should add, if we have a tie, no one gets shot.

[Penelope_Grey]

Oh.. thank god.

And I make it midnight GMT now... ballots are closed.

[Onkel Neal]

Originally Posted by Penelope_Grey

What happens in the even of a tie?

Yep, no one gets shot, there probably won't an even number tomorrow.

Why is it Jimbuna posts all day and then doesn't vote? I thought U-boot commanders were decisive

[Penelope_Grey]

This game is spinning my head... I need rest and sleep....

lol I've been so tempted to take up smoking again in real life too over the course of this game LOL