SH4 vs SH5?

03-13-10, 08:55 PM

How does SH5 compare to SH4+U-Boat expansion?

jazman · 03-13-10, 10:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by demowhc

How does SH5 compare to SH4+U-Boat expansion?

SH4+UB+OpMonsun+OMEGU makes a decent game, although the OpMonsun aircraft are crazy deadly, even early war. Even so, it's better than SH5, but SH5 has some ways to catch up yet, time will tell.

Heck, you even get a Type IX, and can play Operation Monsun, or make a trip to the Caribbean, or sit off of Freetown. That's nice! Right now I'm patrolling off of Norfolk / Chesapeake Bay.

I am not all about eye-candy in my games, I consider gameplay to be more important. SH3+GWX is even better.

03-13-10, 11:05 PM

Yeh I currently have OpMonsun installed and was wondering how bad SH5 gameplay is in comparison, or if I should wait a couple months for patches and mods to fix it before purchasing...

And I know eye-candy isnt everything, but I'm a graphics whore and love nice graphics lol, this is the main reason I want SH5, but only if gameplay is up to par.

Chillaxed614 · 03-14-10, 12:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by demowhc

How does SH5 compare to SH4+U-Boat expansion?

If youre expecting a better version of SH3 or SH4 uboats I'd hold off for a minute. The graphics and some of the new concepts in it are great, unfortunately theyre making it feel like an unfinished console game, with a new interface completely unlike what all the diehard fans of the series have come to know and love. Fortunately theres already mods in the process to restore original SH3 and 4 elements and make it what it potentially can be. In a few months this game will rip tits.

wamphyri · 03-14-10, 12:49 AM

I agree with chill. There are many things in sh5 that I like over sh3/4 but it does not feel like a finished product yet.

alexradu89 · 03-14-10, 04:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jazman

SH4+UB+OpMonsun+OMEGU makes a decent game, although the OpMonsun aircraft are crazy deadly, even early war. Even so, it's better than SH5, but SH5 has some ways to catch up yet, time will tell.

Totally agree with you here, I am using exactly the same mods setup and I'm loving it, even though I would have preferred to play SH5 but right now it's just unplayable with it's bugs and everything.

ShadowWolf Kell · 03-14-10, 04:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by alexradu89

Totally agree with you here, I am using exactly the same mods setup and I'm loving it, even though I would have preferred to play SH5 but right now it's just unplayable with it's bugs and everything.

Loved those too, unfortunately I get a lot of CTDs with OM for some reason. Lorent is completely unaccessible to me. Any time I come remotely close to it, CTD.

Goes for a lot of cities. Had a patrol off Halifax at one point and couldn't enter the harbor. About the closest I could get before a CTD happened was 16km... well out of G7E range.

That said, despite the CTD issues I found it a very fun and rewarding experience. If SH5 didn't already have as many mods out for it that is does, I'd be back playing SH4 right now.

At some point I'll probably go back to it anyway. I never did get around to playing the latest TMO since I was having far too much fun in my VIIC.

03-13-10, 08:55 PM	#1
demowhc Stowaway Posts: n/a Downloads: Uploads:	SH4 vs SH5? How does SH5 compare to SH4+U-Boat expansion?

03-13-10, 11:05 PM	#3
demowhc Stowaway Posts: n/a Downloads: Uploads:	Yeh I currently have OpMonsun installed and was wondering how bad SH5 gameplay is in comparison, or if I should wait a couple months for patches and mods to fix it before purchasing... And I know eye-candy isnt everything, but I'm a graphics whore and love nice graphics lol, this is the main reason I want SH5, but only if gameplay is up to par.

03-14-10, 12:49 AM	#5
wamphyri Lieutenant Join Date: May 2004 Location: Lethbridge, Alberta Posts: 260 Downloads: 40 Uploads: 0	I agree with chill. There are many things in sh5 that I like over sh3/4 but it does not feel like a finished product yet.