![]() |
SUBSIM: The Web's #1 resource for all submarine & naval simulations since 1997 |
![]() |
#46 |
Ocean Warrior
![]() Best of SUBSIM Chairman Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Milwaukee, WI
Posts: 3,207
Downloads: 59
Uploads: 0
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#47 | |
Navy Seal
![]() Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: New Mexico, USA
Posts: 9,023
Downloads: 8
Uploads: 2
|
![]() Quote:
I was, however, actually thinking more of LeMay's firebombing campaign, which killed more people than both atomic weapons combined. The 2d fire raid on Tokyo killed 102,000 alone, for example. Technically speaking—which is all that matters legally—all men 15-65, and all women 17-47 in Japan were soldiers by Imperial Edict. While that certainly leaves many kids and old people as non-combatants, they were if anything outnumbered by combatants. If you mix combatants and noncombatants intentionally, you cannot complain when the latter are killed. That's just a statement of reality. |
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#48 |
Navy Seal
![]() Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: New Mexico, USA
Posts: 9,023
Downloads: 8
Uploads: 2
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#49 |
Navy Seal
![]() |
![]()
As the joke goes, what do you call a soldier who cashes his paycheck? A mercenary.
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#50 |
Lucky Jack
![]() |
![]()
At 3:19 approx, you can see the two reporters with cameras on straps slung over their shoulders, without being told that they were reporters and those were cameras, one could make the mistake that those were possibly SMGs or RPGs in that shot.
At 3:39, the camera slews up and there are three gentlemen with what appear to be weapons of some sort, at least from the altitude and angle of the chopper. They radio in to check that there are no friendlies in the area, and receive the all clear. At 4:08, one of the camera crew appears to be picking up a long lens camera from the ground, unfortunately all that is visible on the tape is a long black object, which is something an RPG happens to be. Only at 4:13ish can one be sure that it's a camera, but if in advance you did not know that he was a camera man, would this still register so obviously? 4:21 he reports that there was 'a guy shooting', which obviously did not occur. This is the gunners error. You cannot excuse this statement save for words uttered in the grip of the moment which once uttered can never be returned to whence they came. 4:41 it sounds as though there is a US unit in a nearby street, talk of Humvees and Bradleys, and later in the video he talks in a unit. This would make any gunner just that little more jumpy knowing that his or hers countrymen are just a few streets away and the people you have in front of you could be mustering to attack them. 4:51 Yeah...by this point, now that you know who they are, it's obvious that they are a bit too relaxed to be planning an attack, but that's hindsight for you. Something that you only get after the event. 5:09 Primary engagement concluded. Civilians and combatants scatter alike, he who fights and runs away lives to kill you or a friend another day. 5:19 Two random shots at the fleeing reporter, gunner seems to lose track or something. Some humour. Not appropriate for the situation, but one way of relieving tension. 5:53 Ok, a bit overkill now, although probably aimed at the last survivor. Again, if a combatant survives, he can return to the battlefield. This gentleman was not a combatant, however the crew was firmly in the belief that he was and thus acted so. Asking for the guy to reach for a weapon is perhaps not appropriate, however in an age when SWAT teams cannot use force unless they've already been shot at (and possibly killed or injured) then he has to have what looks like a weapon in his hands before they can open fire. Let me bring forward another little story from another war. Malaya, 1950-52. 45 Commando of the Royal Marines, were deployed to Malaya during the crisis, it was in climate conditions probably quite similar to Vietnam, likewise in geography. Isolated villages surrounded by jungles, perfect ambush territory. As the Commandos patrolled, they would come across villages and the children of the village would run out to meet them, the Commandos would pick the children up, play games with them, share their rations with them, generally the things that you or I would do with children no matter if we were in a war or not. The enemy, Communist guerrillas, got word of this, probably through local sympathisers, and began to use the children as a weapon against the Commandos. The children were wired up with explosives, to them it was just a game, perhaps a new type of clothing, and when they ran out to greet the Commandos to play their games and get their sweets, the explosives were detonated and the children and Marines killed. After a time, quite a few Marines had succumbed to this new tactic, so an order was issued from command, any children who ran towards the Marines as they entered a village were to be shot on sight. Can you imagine that? To the children it was business as usual, some of them might have had a bomb vest, some of them might not have done...but if they ran towards the Marines to greet them...it was the last thing they did. Let me tell you something...it haunted those Marines to their final days, however what choice did they have? It was kill or be killed, for if one of those children with a bomb vest had met my grandfather in Malaya, I would not be typing these words right now. I'm just bloody grateful that I'm not in a position where my judgment is responsible for the life and death of those around me. |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#51 | ||
中国水兵
![]() Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Uppland, Sweden
Posts: 278
Downloads: 48
Uploads: 0
|
![]() Quote:
Quote:
"Imperial Edict", yeah right... That's one sorry excuse. ![]() |
||
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#52 |
Lucky Jack
![]() |
![]()
You do realise that most of the purple hearts issued today were quite likely from the five hundred thousand that were made in preparation for Operation Downfall? It's hard to tell whether or not the casualties of Operation Downfall would have exceeded that of the bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, but considering that at least seven nuclear weapons would have been used or available to be used during Operation Downfall, it could be argued that the civilian deaths alone would be three times higher. The devastation would not have been limited to two cities either it would have been distributed equally across the whole continent.
Very much a choice between the devil and the deep blue sea, but an invasion of Japan would have been monstrous for both sides. |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#53 |
Lucky Jack
![]() |
![]()
And let me just state for the record, before I retire to bed, that I am not American, I am British, and I am not some hard right wing conservative, in fact I consider myself quite liberal. I wasn't a particularly big fan of George Bush, and expected highly of Obama when he was first inaugurated.
All in all, I tick most of the boxes to be what Americans would call a Democrat, and yet I do not think of things as left or right wing, conservative or liberal, because there is no such thing as black or white, in any situation and in my opinion, and my opinion alone, I think that it is incredibly naive to think that the world exists in Black and White. That's all I'll say on the subject for now, I'm going to bed before my rambling becomes uncontrollable. ![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#54 | |
Navy Seal
![]() Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Stavka
Posts: 8,211
Downloads: 13
Uploads: 0
|
![]() Quote:
Regardless, the bombing saved many more lives than they caused deaths. Estimated casualties for a successful execution of Olympic and Coronet went up to 1 million men for the Allies alone; the fact that the Japanese conscripted most of their population into the army without any proper armament or training and with suicidal orders to resist the invasion at all costs meant that Japanese casualties would far exceed that. All this is combined with the casualties that would've been caused by Operation Zipper in Malaya, Operation Tiderace in Signapore and, most importantly, the impending Soviet invasion of Hokkaido that was to follow the landing in the Kurils. Not to mention the fact that quite a few nuclear weapons were planned to have been used as tactical nukes to balance out the operational numerical equality that the Japanese have created with their conscription. EDIT: Bah, shouldn't be writing so late at night. EDIT 2: There, should be comprehensible now.
__________________
Current Eastern Front status: Probable Victory Last edited by Raptor1; 04-06-10 at 06:04 PM. |
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#55 |
Silent Hunter
![]() Join Date: Apr 2007
Posts: 4,405
Downloads: 31
Uploads: 0
|
Oberon has done an excellent job above with his timeline.
![]() I will also say this - to those of you who have never seen combat - never been shot at, and never had to pull a trigger - you have no understanding of the stresses involved. The comment of 5:53 - encouraging a person to reach for a weapon - is actually a comment that makes note of the ROE - if he DOES reach for a weapon, he confirms his own status as a combatant. Now - you just pulled a trigger - you now have an injured person in your sights - do you want to see him reach for a weapon - proving he is a "bad guy" - or do you want to see him hobble off, passing by a weapon and instead reaching for safety. If there is any doubt in your mind about him actually being a combatant - you know you have already injured him - if he is not a combatant - you have to face the fact that your actions marred for life an innocent person. It is part of the mental rationalization to want that person to reach for a weapon - which absolves you of the wounding and gives you the (somewhat shaky) ethical ground to put him out of his misery. Now - a comment about what is conspicuously absent in this discussion. You have a "reporter" - often local populace member - in an area of conflict - and around people with weapons. In addition, you have a unit of your own army nearby. The video shows the photographer was going to take a picture of SOMETHING - and being a "war correspondant" - you can bet a doughnut that he wasn't going to take a picture of a little girl playing with her doggy in the park. Something was going down - and the "reporter" knew it. Otherwise he wouldn't have been setting up to capture it. The fact there were armed elements in his immediate vicinity show that there was action about to occur (or in the case of the "sneaking" aroung the corner - already going on). Against whom - is unknown. It might have been the unit entering the area - it might have been another militia group, or any other possibilities. But the reality is $hit was about to get (or already was) hot, and the intervention by the soldiers involved obviously stopped things. Good or bad - we won't ever know. But to claim that the entire thing was just "indescriminant" killing by US forces is a total croc.
__________________
Good Hunting! Captain Haplo ![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#56 |
Silent Hunter
![]() Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Jakarta
Posts: 4,794
Downloads: 89
Uploads: 6
|
![]()
OMG a camera was thought of an RPG...
It must be a combination of poor tracking technology, poor judgment and an appetite for some action after some extended lull. Some more brain should be put into the brawn especially before engaging from high above.
__________________
Last edited by Castout; 04-06-10 at 06:19 PM. |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#57 |
Silent Hunter
![]() Join Date: Apr 2007
Posts: 4,405
Downloads: 31
Uploads: 0
|
Castout - US land forces are stretched thin, but the reality is that few countries are in a position to do much to the US. Could they use our current state to pursue regional goals? Possibly - but it would be a dangerous decision. Could a country invade the US? Only if its Canada or Mexico - and Mexico has been doing that for decades already. Anyone else has to deal with our navy, and no country on earth has the ability to take on our navy in the open ocean and win right now.
__________________
Good Hunting! Captain Haplo ![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#58 | ||
中国水兵
![]() Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Uppland, Sweden
Posts: 278
Downloads: 48
Uploads: 0
|
![]() Quote:
Quote:
I disagree over the necessarity of it all. Japan was already defeated. There wasn't much more for them to do. They didn't pose any direct threat to the US or any surrouning countries since almost the whole country was in ruins. It might had been hard to invade Japan at the time. But they had no fair option other than to surrender in the long run. I think lives could have been spared if they choosed to wait them out. Now, there is no news that USA makes their vengence and benefit priority number one. We've seen it time after time in history. No human life without a US citizenchip (or their allies) are worth ****. That's pretty much what this video shows. Have a nice day. |
||
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#59 |
Navy Seal
![]() |
![]()
I noticed these reporters don't ware the blue flack jackets and helmets with "PRESS" written on them.
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#60 | |
Navy Seal
![]() Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Stavka
Posts: 8,211
Downloads: 13
Uploads: 0
|
![]() Quote:
Waiting it out? You mean staving the Japanese home islands by blockade and continuing the conventional bombing which has killed far more people than the Atomic bombs? This would still have caused more casualties... Also, don't forget that the Soviets had plans of their own and, had the US not invaded or performed anything to end the war, you can be sure the Soviets would have, likely causing massive casualties as well...
__________________
Current Eastern Front status: Probable Victory |
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
|