GWX manual and buoys?

[prowler3]

The GWX manual states that if red buoys are on the right (starboard) and green buoys are on the left (port), then that indicates you are leaving port. This goes completely against what I was taught..."Red right, return".

In other words, red on the right, you are returning to port or harbor?

Which is correct?

[Gargamel]

Red right return, IIRC, that they red buoys are on the right when you are heading back into port (or upstream when on river/waterway?). So leaving port they will be on the left.

You are both correct, but I think you have just misinterpreted the saying.

Much like the often misused saying of "red at night....."

[prowler3]

???? We can't both be correct. it's either I'm returning or I'm leaving?

[Sailor Steve]

When returning to port in Europe the green bouys should be to starboard. "Red right" is a Western Hemisphere thing.
http://www.sailingusa.info/basic_navigation.htm

[Gargamel]

Originally Posted by prowler3

???? We can't both be correct. it's either I'm returning or I'm leaving?

Holy crap your right, I totally misread your post.

[Jimbuna]

Originally Posted by prowler3

The GWX manual states that if red buoys are on the right (starboard) and green buoys are on the left (port), then that indicates you are leaving port. This goes completely against what I was taught..."Red right, return".

In other words, red on the right, you are returning to port or harbor?

Which is correct?

What page number in the manual?

[Herr-Berbunch]

Page 144.

Navigation channels in and out of ports are generally marked with red and green buoys, with the red buoys on the port side when entering a harbor (although in some countries it means you are leaving the harbor).

And in specific regard to GWX -

If you see red buoys to port and green buoys to starboard it means you are entering a port; if you see red buoys on starboard side and green on the port side it means you are leaving port.

So not 'red right, return' - more like 'red to red return' (Your red next to the buoys red = return)

[Jimbuna]

Originally Posted by Herr-Berbunch

Page 144.

Ah, good....nothing I've written then

In addition to what Steve has posted:

http://www.sailingissues.com/navcourse9.html

Region A - IALA A covers all of Europe and most of the rest of the world, whereas region B - IALA B covers only the Americas, Japan, the Philippines and Korea.

[Pablo]

Hi!

More to the point, from the GWX Manual (V3 Gold):

"Buoys in GWX mark navigation channels in and out of Axis-controlled harbors in accordance with the European standards of the World War II era. If you see red buoys to port and green buoys to starboard it means you are entering a port; if you see red buoys on starboard side and green on the port side it means you are leaving port. A yellow buoy warns of a hazard to navigation. These buoys may be equipped with bells or other noise-making devices to help ensure you pay attention to them."

When in doubt, RTFM!

Pablo

[Didd]

From what I have learnt, strictly speaking it's red to port and green to starboard in the direction of the flood tide, which usually (always?) is when entering a harbour. I do know however that in the menai straights, the buoys swap sides half way as the flood tide comes from both directions...mmmm.

Didd