Silent Hunter, The Perfect Sim?

[goose814]

Is it just me or has anyone else had the same thought, that the more I keep reading about what's wrong with SH4 or what needs to be added or changed, or this doesn't work and that doesn't work, or if it only did this or do that, etc., etc., etc., the more I keep thinking that the original Silent Hunter seems to have been close to perfect. I mean many features that people are looking for in SH4 were already in SH, and they worked. It seems that if you take SH and add SH4's eye candy (graphics), change or add a few gameplay issues, then you would have the perfect sim. I don't know, maybe it's just me.

Gus