SHV may be a flop because no one cares anymore

[Steeltrap]

Originally Posted by Neal Stevens

I disagree with that too. The mods enhanced the game, but I thnk it's very safe to say 90% of the people who bought SH3, would have bought it if a single mod never existed.

There were no mods for Aces of the Deep and Silent Hunter 1 to speak of, and their strong sales were the commercial basis for SH2, SH3, and on.

It's probably more reasonable to say that the sorts of people who reside in subsim (i.e. the uber realism junkies) would never have seen a sim done to the level of detail they like were it not for the modders.

That might be something to consider with SH5. Developers have never built the sim to be a 'true' sim based on the wealth of historical reference materials available, so there's probably little point in hoping they will any time soon.

[Méo]

Originally Posted by Steeltrap

Developers have never built the sim to be a 'true' sim based on the wealth of historical reference materials available, so there's probably little point in hoping they will any time soon.

Nevertheless, I think that vanilla SH5 will be better than vanilla SH3.

Now everything is about how much SH5 will be unfinished at release, this will be critical, a lot more than DRM/OSP, IMHO.