[Poll] SH5 & you - One sub or more?

[Alex]

Originally Posted by danurve

I can't agree with that unless it's considered that the XXI helped to loose the Battle of the Atlantic. That's right, in the end all it did was consume resources to no avail. On the other hand if they scrapped the entire IX series for the XXI ..

I'm 200% (to say the least ) sure that you Sir know what I meant.
Unlike the type XVIII Walter that never got a chance to sail as these boats were cancelled in favour of the XXI in 1944, quite a few XXI got commissioned - though I agree with you, none of them sunk significant tonnage, as most if not all were used as training boats until the end of the war.

Originally Posted by danurve

another useless debate though.

@ Jim : Aw you're right, I forgot the type XXIII !