[WIP] S.S. America \ USS West Point

[Ruzbasan]

Von Dos,

Absolutely incredible !!! She looks like the most realistic troop ship in the game!

I will see my Dad this weekend after the winter storm we are expecting in the Northeast. (He lives two hours away). He is not computer literate, so I show him your progress when he visits. I will bring the screen shots with me on my laptop for him to look over. He will be greatly excited to see this!

I will post his feed back here for you this weekend.

The only change I can see right now is fewer life rafts. Looking at the photo of the West Point, the model has 6 rafts too many in the mid section area. In the photo the rafts are in groups of 5 in the mid section of the ship, not all connected. Maybe remove 6-8 rafts in the mid section to seperate the rafts into smaller groups of 4-5 rafts each across the mid section.

Otherwise- just perfect !!!

A little story for you from my Dad- When he was crossing the Atlantic from the U.S. to Italy on the West Point in 1944, the ship was NOT escorted. She travelled alone because of her high speed. My father remembered that the whole ship would vibrate from the propellors when the stern came out of the water during heavy seas. There were other terrors. My father was assigned sleeping quarters below decks in the bow of the ship during the crossing. One night, my father was awakened when he was thrown from his hammock by a violent turn and lurching of the ship. Terrified, he asked a passing crew member what had happened. The sailor calmly said-"Nothing much, we just turned to avoid a torpedo." After that, my father rarely got a full nights sleep on board. (Oh, and my Dad said no one told the 7000 troops on board what to do or where to go if they were torpedoed- no life boat drills and no mae west vests).

[Jimbuna]

Looking really cool VD

[Anvart]

Sorry ...
I have other opinion ...
And adjust a smoke ...

[VonDos]

Every opinion is welcome (also negative ^_^)
Please, Anvart, explain you, so you can help me to improve my work..

about funnels, i will move smoke's coordinates back

[Anvart]

Originally Posted by VonDos

Every opinion is welcome (also negative ^_^)
Please, Anvart, explain you, so you can help me to improve my work..

about funnels, i will move smoke's coordinates back

Sorry, VonDos.
My opinion is not the negative ...
Simply it's not finished work (wip) ...
And to speak about success still early, though last sample is better previous ...
I would like, that the ship has been more detailed (especially decks), to have the best scale parity of all ship parts (mesh and texture), more the best texturing (UV mapping) ...
And i believe, that you can do it ...
...
To help you ... ???
My firm belief - only your own work (errors and success) and self-training will help you to become high-modder ...

Good luck.

[VonDos]

Thanks for clarification mate, and for your words also! :hmm:

[iambecomelife]

Originally Posted by Ruzbasan

Von Dos,

Absolutely incredible !!! She looks like the most realistic troop ship in the game!

I will see my Dad this weekend after the winter storm we are expecting in the Northeast. (He lives two hours away). He is not computer literate, so I show him your progress when he visits. I will bring the screen shots with me on my laptop for him to look over. He will be greatly excited to see this!

I will post his feed back here for you this weekend.

The only change I can see right now is fewer life rafts. Looking at the photo of the West Point, the model has 6 rafts too many in the mid section area. In the photo the rafts are in groups of 5 in the mid section of the ship, not all connected. Maybe remove 6-8 rafts in the mid section to seperate the rafts into smaller groups of 4-5 rafts each across the mid section.

Otherwise- just perfect !!!

A little story for you from my Dad- When he was crossing the Atlantic from the U.S. to Italy on the West Point in 1944, the ship was NOT escorted. She travelled alone because of her high speed. My father remembered that the whole ship would vibrate from the propellors when the stern came out of the water during heavy seas. There were other terrors. My father was assigned sleeping quarters below decks in the bow of the ship during the crossing. One night, my father was awakened when he was thrown from his hammock by a violent turn and lurching of the ship. Terrified, he asked a passing crew member what had happened. The sailor calmly said-"Nothing much, we just turned to avoid a torpedo." After that, my father rarely got a full nights sleep on board. (Oh, and my Dad said no one told the 7000 troops on board what to do or where to go if they were torpedoed- no life boat drills and no mae west vests).

Thanks for the story. It's amazing how reckless the Allied navies were when it came to protecting some of their major ships. I read that even big warships like the "Rodney" would often travel solo early in the war. The "Indianapolis" & "Glorious" incidents showed what could happen if a valuable ship traveled in hostile areas without enough protection.

And good work, VonDos.

[bigboywooly]

Originally Posted by iambecomelife

Thanks for the story. It's amazing how reckless the Allied navies were when it came to protecting some of their major ships. I read that even big warships like the "Rodney" would often travel solo early in the war. The "Indianapolis" & "Glorious" incidents showed what could happen if a valuable ship traveled in hostile areas without enough protection.

And good work, VonDos.

I think the reasoning was high speed meant less of a chance of being hit plus less screw noise of only one ship as opposed to a group
Impossible for a sub to catch up with them submerged and a struggle surfaced
Didnt always work though as once in a while a uboat was in the perfect position or took a chance at a shot

Nice unit Von D as usual

[VonDos]

Thanks ^^


\\ "Nothing much, we just turned to avoid a torpedo."

and after this, try to sleep again

Thanks for this witness. This experience could be terrorific for everyone!


For casistic of big liners escorts, i remember RMS Queen Mary and her escort, cruiser HMS Curacao.
The liner was at speed, and in a zig zag route, she split in half the cruiser. And QM captain order to not stop for help survivors of the smaller ship, for U-Boat danger °_° Hard decision here, btw; Queen Mary was full of soldier, the risk was really elevated.

[Jimbuna]

Originally Posted by VonDos

Thanks ^^


\\ "Nothing much, we just turned to avoid a torpedo."

and after this, try to sleep again

Thanks for this witness. This experience could be terrorific for everyone!


For casistic of big liners escorts, i remember RMS Queen Mary and her escort, cruiser HMS Curacao.
The liner was at speed, and in a zig zag route, she split in half the cruiser. And QM captain order to not stop for help survivors of the smaller ship, for U-Boat danger °_° Hard decision here, btw; Queen Mary was full of soldier, the risk was really elevated.

That's right mate....and further weight to the 'no escort' rationale