First convoy SH3/GWX attack - report from AOD player

[MarkShot]

I just the following email off to a friend describing my first convoy attack attempt with SH3/GWX. Below if anyone is interested in some comparisons:

Well, I managed to come to PD in the middle of the convoy without detection. However, my attack scope was spotted immediately and it immediately drew a lot of gun fire.

Despite the potential for a shot as merchants were all around (especially in this game; setting up for a shot is going to take 2-4 minutes), I ordered a crash dive. Survival of the boat is always the first priority.

After 1 hours and 6-8 DC attacks, contact was broken. It seemed that we were able to be moderately tracked running silent at 2KTS. However, at 150M, they were unable to get our depth and all DCs were too shallow. Dropping to 1KTS silent, we were able to slip away.

Well, one thing SH3 does better than any sub game (with the possible exception of Sub Command) is the sound modeling. Listening to all the unique sounds on the hydrophone of merchants, warships, DCs, and explosions was truly impressive. The modeling is such that with careful study information can be gathered. However, the game gives it to you in alternative forms.

Regarding the attack compared to AOD. Certainly, it was tough day for a daytime attack from within the convoy, since the sea was very calm; easy to spot the scope. However, in AOD, the attack probably would have succeeded. Why? In AOD, the screen actively searches for subs and maintains a greater range from the convoy in daylight and fair weather conditions. Thus, slipping in under the screen guarantees sufficient time for a shot; even if detected prior to launching. However, in SH3/GWX, much to my suprise, the escorts appeared to mixed into the convoy closely with the merchants. Thus, I was immediately in close proximity to the escorts as I initiated my attack. Thus, I was foiled.

PS: My wife said of my flying days "everything happens so fast ... what fun is that?". Of my sub days she says "everything happens so slowly and is so gloomy ... what fun is that?"