What do you think of the 100K Club ?

Shahed · 09-04-06, 09:19 AM

At UBI there is a club called the 100k club, there is also one for 200k and for 300k (IIRC) tonnage sunk in one patrol. Willhelm is in charge of running the roster.

I wonder of this will work here.

I wanted to get a view on what people here think of this.
Have a look here for reference:

http://forums.ubi.com/eve/forums/a/t...3/m/9191010914

My view is as follows. We need a higher standard for this kind of competitive club, if we want this kind of club.

100k does'nt mean anything at all unless it's exactly the same realism conditions and exactly the same game/mod for all involved.

As you can't police people's mods, you can never be sure of cheating or simple doctoring. Some of the logs I've seen at ubi, are quite dubious. It is probable that some of the logs at Ubi are fixed in one way or another. Even more so because most have not disclosed how they have achieved the results. this is not an accusation, but a broad statement. No offence is intended.

When I look at this forum it seems better off without the 100k club.
It seems more mature and has far lesser petty discussions/arguments than Ubi. This seems like the place for the hardcore, seperating the boys from the men (and the girls from the women as the casae may be). I also see a lot less conmen in this forum than at ubi, people claiming things that are'nt, claiming to be things that they are'nt.

I would suggest the following standard for the 100k club, if people want to have that:

GW or NYGM. How can we even consider that 100k in stock SH3 is an achievement ?
100% Realism. Even on 72% it's far too easy to make 100k. Or at least more than 70-80% realism.
Basic.cfg & sim.cfg files have to posted. Now here is the biggest work. You have to check the person's files to ensure that his are not different form the rest. This is a time consuming and IMO waste of time, but without this check the 100k really does'nt mean much becasue there is no certification to it's autheticity.

Having said all that I'll repost my logs if this is something that people want to do here as well.

Just to get the ball rolling in a democratic direction...

View Poll Results: Do you want a 100k club ?
Yes. Under any realism and mod standard.	4	10.53%
Yes. Only if the standard is the same for all.	17	44.74%
No. Not under any standard. Please state reason.	15	39.47%
Maybe if... please state comments in post.	2	5.26%
Voters: 38. You may not vote on this poll

09-04-06, 09:19 AM	#1
Shahed Planesman Join Date: Aug 2006 Posts: 189 Downloads: 2 Uploads: 0	What do you think of the 100K Club ? At UBI there is a club called the 100k club, there is also one for 200k and for 300k (IIRC) tonnage sunk in one patrol. Willhelm is in charge of running the roster. I wonder of this will work here. I wanted to get a view on what people here think of this. Have a look here for reference: http://forums.ubi.com/eve/forums/a/t...3/m/9191010914 My view is as follows. We need a higher standard for this kind of competitive club, if we want this kind of club. 100k does'nt mean anything at all unless it's exactly the same realism conditions and exactly the same game/mod for all involved. As you can't police people's mods, you can never be sure of cheating or simple doctoring. Some of the logs I've seen at ubi, are quite dubious. It is probable that some of the logs at Ubi are fixed in one way or another. Even more so because most have not disclosed how they have achieved the results. this is not an accusation, but a broad statement. No offence is intended. When I look at this forum it seems better off without the 100k club. It seems more mature and has far lesser petty discussions/arguments than Ubi. This seems like the place for the hardcore, seperating the boys from the men (and the girls from the women as the casae may be). I also see a lot less conmen in this forum than at ubi, people claiming things that are'nt, claiming to be things that they are'nt. I would suggest the following standard for the 100k club, if people want to have that: GW or NYGM. How can we even consider that 100k in stock SH3 is an achievement ? 100% Realism. Even on 72% it's far too easy to make 100k. Or at least more than 70-80% realism. Basic.cfg & sim.cfg files have to posted. Now here is the biggest work. You have to check the person's files to ensure that his are not different form the rest. This is a time consuming and IMO waste of time, but without this check the 100k really does'nt mean much becasue there is no certification to it's autheticity. Having said all that I'll repost my logs if this is something that people want to do here as well. Just to get the ball rolling in a democratic direction... __________________ IXC -U-126 DIE STEIGENDE SONNE, 26 PATROLS, ACTIVE. IXB -U-101 DER TEUFEL MITFAHRER, 1 PATROL, ACTIVE. Last edited by Shahed; 09-04-06 at 01:21 PM.