Chess not haram

[Skybird]

The influential high-ranking Saudi Grand-Mufti Abdulaziz Al al-Sheikh released a Fatwa banning chess and declaring it as forbidden to play it, since it would distract players from their prayings, and would teach rivalry, competition, and builds hate and hostility.

The mad Grufti, I mean the Grand-Mufti, is a madman of the Sunni school of madness. It is one of the occasions when the Sunni madmen get accompanied by their Shia pendants as well, since the Shia Grand-Ajatollah Ali al-Sistani, also a man of great influence, has declared chess to be banned in a fatwah of his own, too.

I summarise it in plain English. Chess teaches discipline, patience, logic, precise thinking and exact calculation. Skills like this are the less wanted the more obscure and pedantic and fundamental a religious system is - since it cannot hold its ground together in the light of such intellectual qualities. THAT is the real reason behind this.

They are holding a chess tournament in Mekka, or planned to do so. Lets see if the Saudi religion-police brings it to a halt or not.

Back to prayer lessons.

[Jimbuna]

Is this how we ended up with one version being called Battle Chess?

[Platapus]

Similar to fundamentalists elsewhere who were trying to forbid dancing and intersex parties.

Fundies are funny... until they start getting political power.

[Skybird]

Originally Posted by Platapus

Fundies are funny... until they start getting political power.

Claimed spirituality left to private life and private cabin, is religion.

Claimed spirituality moved to the public space, is politics. That's tyranny.

Anyhow, they apparently will not win many science Nobel prizes any time soon.

[Aktungbby]

Perhaps if they rename bishops mullahs and knights jihadis and refer to the pawns as fellahin they'll allow the tournament;

The Arabs were the first people to study the game scientifically and it is to their early

writers that we owe the most numerous and earliest references to this ancient pastime. Chess researchers all agree that its history can only be reconstructed from these Arab sources.

For about 500 years, Muslims dominated the game and their players were the best in the world. In that period of history, it became a widely played popular form of entertainment. A good number of caliphs were capitivated by it and became expert players. In their book The Chess Scene, D. Levy and S. Reuben indicate that Harun al-Rashid of Arabian Nights’ fame was not only a player but also a patron of the game. When this famous Caliph was asked, "What is Chess?" he replied, "What is life?"

In that golden era of the Arabs, the game entered their legends and a vast literature relating to chess came into existence. H. Murray in A History of Chess quotes this verse by Ibn al-Mutazz, a chess playing Abbasid Caliph's son:

"0 thou whose cynic sneers express

The censure of our favourite chess,

Know that its skill is science' self,

Its play distraction from distress.

It soothes the anxious lover's care,

It weans the drunkard from excess;

It counsels warriors in their art,

When danger threat, and perils press;

And yields us when we need them most,

Companions in our loneliness."

The first documented history of the game is from the 9th century when al-Adl§ wrote what is considered to be the first book about this pastime entitled, The Book of Chess. He was followed by others - two of the most important being al-Razi and Aliqlidis.

However, the greatest chess players in early Islam were Al-Suli and his pupil al-Lajlaj who were renowned in the Abbasid Court of Baghdad. Al-Suli's superiority was recognized for centuries - until the European Renaissance. For many years people said of someone who showed remarkable skill in chess, "He plays like al-Suli."

After the Arabs had conquered the Iberian Peninsula, the game was introduced into that part of Europe. In the ensuing centuries, the flourishing and enlightened Caliphate of Cordova, which promoted culture, education and encouraged all sciences, became the pivot for the diffusion of chess to the remainder of Europe. To the caliphate's schools, students came from neighbouring countries to study and, in the process, became acculturated to the norms of Arab society. When they returned home, they took back with them the art of chess.

The game also became an essential part of the belongings carried by troubadours and travelling minstrels, thus helping in the spread of its popularity throughout Europe. Initially, its dispersal from the Iberian Peninsula was only a trickle but, in spite of the fact that it was forbidden by the clergy and monastic orders, likely due to it being the ‘infidel’s’ game, the trickle soon became a torrent.

The first evidence of chess in western Europe dates from 1010 A.D. when the Count of Urgel left his rock-crystal chessmen to the Convent of St. Giles at Nimes. A few years later, it is believed that the game was introduced into England with the Danish invasion. In subsequent years, it was favoured by the upper classes and became known as 'the pastime of the nobility'. When the Normans occupied the country, they named one of their departments of state Scaccarium (from the Arabic-Persian shah) after the chessboard, from which we get our modern word 'exchequer'. In Spain, after the Moors were expelled, they left behind a repository of knowledge relating to chess which was to establish the Spanish as the leading European proponents of the game for three centuries.

From its introduction into Christian Europe until 1200 A.D., chess was played according to the traditions and rules followed in the Muslim world. However, in the succeeding centuries, both the rules and names of the chess pieces changed. Improvements were made in the moves and rules and, as the years slipped by, the game lost its clear cut Arab framework.

Nevertheless, before others took over, the Arabs had contributed much to the development of chess which they called shatranj, an adaptation of the Persian word chaturanj, itself derived from the Sanskrit chaturanga. The Arabs had borrowed as loan words certain foreign words pertaining to chess and translated others that they found difficult to pronounce.

With one exception, the Persian nomenclature of the chess-pieces was adopted into Arabic almost unchanged. Baizag (pawn), f§ l (bishop), firzan (queen) and rukhkh (rook) are the Arabized forms of the Persian payadah, phil, firzin and rukh. Shah (king) remained the same. Only asp, Persian for horse, was given an Arab translated name, faras (knight) and firzan was later changed to vizir.

Due to the prohibition of human-likeness in Islam, the abstract Arab chess-pieces bore little resemblance to images. The Muslims created new forms to reinterpret the realistic-naturalistic Persian-Indian models. After the game entered Europe, the non-representational Arab chessmen were transformed into human likenesses. In the beginning, ignorance of their original significance caused certain pieces to be given a great variety of names. But over the years these names became standardized in the form we know them today.

The Arab ancestry of European chess can be easily established by the `Arabicisms' in the nomenclature of the European game. In medieval chess ferez was the Arabic ( firzan), alfil

(al- f§ l ), roc (rukhkh), check (shah) and mat or mate (mat). The Spanish name for chess, ajedrez and the Portuguese, xadrez are derived from the Arabic shatranj. On the other hand, the English name chess, French échec, and Italian scacchi are variations of shah.

The Arabs were also responsible for dividing the game into the three parts we know today: opening, middle and end games. According to C. Alexander in his A Book of Chess the Arabs not only invented the World Chess Championship but also the Grandmasters. He states that in 820 A.D. there were four aliyat or 'players of the highest class'; and in 847 the Persian al-Razi defeated al-­ Adli in the presence of the Caliph al-Mutawakkil - an international contest that seems to carry a hint of the classic Fisher/Spassky clashes.

There is no better description of the Arabic influences in the game than that written by Michael Gartner in Newsday, an American publication:

"The shah of Iran is no more, but you remember him. He was the guy with lots of money and lots of troubles. He was called the shah because shah is the Persian word for king.

The word moved through Arabic into Old French as exchac, which eventually became the English check. By then, though, the word didn't refer to any old king. Rather it referred to the king in the game of chess, and that's why when your king is in danger, your chess opponent says 'check.' That means, 'Be careful. Your king is in big trouble.'

If you aren't careful, after the next move he'll say 'checkmate.' That comes from the Arabic al-sh~h m~t, which means 'the king is dead.' In chess it means your king is captured, and you lose the game. That led to the use of the word check to indicate hindrances of various kinds. Hockey players are checked', military plans are checked, political manouvers are checked. A square on a chessboard was originally called a checker or, in Middle English, escheker. Since chess was a royal game, involving kings and queens and knights, the royals of old took the name exchequer to describe the royal treasury. And it is from that word that the British get their cheques and we get our checks."

More than any other pastime, chess has for hundreds of years symbolized circumstances encountered in daily living. This is put into prospective by these words of Omar Khayyam:

"We are but chessmen, who to move are fain.

Just as the great Chessplayer doth ordain;

He moves us on life's chessboard to and fro,

And then in Death's box shuts us up again."

Today, chess is played in all countries of the globe, but its true home has become the western world. It is as it has been from the very beginning, a contest between two players each directing an equal size army in an imaginary war. Victory always falls to the one whose strategical imagination is greater.

Finally, it is said that chess has triumphed over shatranj. A. Saidy and N. Lessing state that the "Irony of ironies! Easterners now have to learn the fine points of chess and the latest innovations from the once - despised Westerners." Yet, the enormous Arab contributions to this king of indoor sports has endured. As H. Golombek writes in Chess - A History:

"Just as the Arabs were the great popularisers of scientific mathematical knowledge, so were they also the innovators of scientific study in what we now call chess and they termed shatranj. One cannot but marvel at the intellectual energy of a people who flourished more than a thousand years ago and yet set the style for theoretical analysis which, with the natural differences that occurred as the game developed and changed, has endured all that time."

Even the Chinese are presently buiding islands in the sea "to honor their ancestors" seems the Arabs cannot do the same Methinks the Grand-Mufti is a very petit-mufti! This'd piss em off!

[Betonov]

Originally Posted by Skybird

Claimed spirituality left to private life and private cabin, is religion.

Claimed spirituality moved to the public space, is politics. That's tyranny.

Anyhow, they apparently will not win many science Nobel prizes any time soon.

Well said

[Oberon]

We'll have to replace them with mechanical Turks

Originally Posted by Skybird

...since it would distract players from their prayings, and would teach rivalry, competition, and builds hate and hostility.

Religion of Peace (™).

[Oberon]

[August]

Here and I thought they banned the game because the Queen is more powerful than the King.

[vienna]

It should be noted that at one time in history, the Muslim world was at the forefront of science, mathematics, astronomy, and other subjects of learning. They were far more advanced than their European contemporaries during that period. What happened? A learned, progressive society was overtaken with the extreme, fundamentalist religious prattling of those who imposed their will at a political level and plunged their society into darkness and hatred. This should be a case lesson to those who dismiss the efforts of religious fundamentalists of all stripes who attempt to inject their particular brand of "morality" into secular government...

Regarding chess, has anyone else here ever tried the Japanese version of chess called Shogi? It is truly diabolical with all manner of piece promotions and with an added factor: a piece, when captured, can be used by the captor and placed back on the board to be used by the captor as one of his own pieces. It has often been noted there are an infinite number of game combinations in Western chess, but Shogi truly takes the whole game "to infinity and beyond"...


<O>