Stadimeter accuracy

Dignan · 04-30-11, 04:46 PM

How accurate is the stadimeter? I know it's more accurate the closer you are but I still seem to get an error of about 200 - 300 meters from ranges above 5,000m and about 50 - 100 meter sized errors when I'm closer than 5,000m to the target. I'm assuming this is normal right?

I'm using TDWs NewUI and the manos scopes mod 8x5 version. The only problem is that these slightly incorrect range readings will then throw off your AOB and speed calculations too. Since I switched to "map contacts off" i've had a much higher rate of misses. Is this normal with the stadimeter?

Trevally. · 04-30-11, 04:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dignan

How accurate is the stadimeter? I know it's more accurate the closer you are but I still seem to get an error of about 200 - 300 meters from ranges above 5,000m and about 50 - 100 meter sized errors when I'm closer than 5,000m to the target. I'm assuming this is normal right?

I'm using TDWs NewUI and the manos scopes mod 8x5 version. The only problem is that these slightly incorrect range readings will then throw off your AOB and speed calculations too. Since I switched to "map contacts off" i've had a much higher rate of misses. Is this normal with the stadimeter?

It measures angle A so can only be as good as your mastheight and waterline settings.
So at long range it can be hard to get it right.

As you track the target - keep undating you solution.

So yes you must wait untill the ship is closer for inputting you final solution.

stoianm · 04-30-11, 04:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dignan

How accurate is the stadimeter? I know it's more accurate the closer you are but I still seem to get an error of about 200 - 300 meters from ranges above 5,000m and about 50 - 100 meter sized errors when I'm closer than 5,000m to the target. I'm assuming this is normal right?

I'm using TDWs NewUI and the manos scopes mod 8x5 version. The only problem is that these slightly incorrect range readings will then throw off your AOB and speed calculations too. Since I switched to "map contacts off" i've had a much higher rate of misses. Is this normal with the stadimeter?

the horizontal crosair of the manos scope is a bit to thick i think... from there you have a small stady error reading... but is realistic in my opinion... whe you will have the exacte readings with stady you will be in the space age... i have a personal scope that tweaked gap... gap reworked the horizontal crosair for me and i have very acurate readings with stady... i think is a bit unrealistic now

Dignan · 04-30-11, 05:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stoianm

i have a personal scope that tweaked by trevally, ddrgn and gap...

Hmmm. Anyone able to direct me to what file I can edit to get this crosair tweaked? I'm intrigued.

stoianm · 04-30-11, 05:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dignan

Hmmm. Any able to direct me to what file I can edit to get this crosair tweaked? I'm intrigued.

i do not have photoshops skills... you must to rework a dds file from the scope mod... but if you not know to use better do not touch

the path: data\menu\skins\german\gui\layout
you need to rework Periscope_Mask_1024_SH5.dds and Periscope_Mask_1024_SH5_OBS.dds

Dignan · 04-30-11, 05:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stoianm

i do not have photoshops skills... you must to rework a dds file from the scope mod... but if you not know to use better do not touch

the path: data\menu\skins\german\gui\layout
you need to rework Periscope_Mask_1024_SH5.dds and Periscope_Mask_1024_SH5_OBS.dds

Thanks stoianm. I'll take a look at it but if I think I'm in over my head I'll abort mission.

finchOU · 04-30-11, 06:04 PM

Range is important...but for a firing solution target speed and AOB are the most important factors....to test this out (at least SHIII)...you can input Range, AOB, Distance and Torp speed into the targeting computer and see how that effects the torps course. All things being equal and adjusting the distance does little to affect the torps course....errors in distance...especially that small (relatively) does not really matter. Hope this helps..

Dignan · 04-30-11, 06:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by finchOU

Range is important...but for a firing solution target speed and AOB are the most important factors....to test this out (at least SHIII)...you can input Range, AOB, Distance and Torp speed into the targeting computer and see how that effects the torps course. All things being equal and adjusting the distance does little to affect the torps course....errors in distance...especially that small (relatively) does not really matter. Hope this helps..

Thanks. I think you are right. My problem is that I'm not getting a good target course plot because at a long distance my range readings are so inaccurate. That results in a poor speed estimation and poor AOB value. I think I just have to practice more.

makman94 · 04-30-11, 06:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stoianm

... i have a personal scope that tweaked by trevally, ddrgn and gap... gap reworked the horizontal crosair for me and i have very acurate readings with stady... i think is a bit unrealistic now

i ,ensure you,...there is nothing wrong at scope that needs ....'tweaking'.be sure of that !

stoianm · 04-30-11, 07:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by makman94

i ,ensure you,...there is nothing wrong at scope that needs ....'tweaking'.be sure of that !

I mean to make the lines a bit tines from horizontal... but sory... those dds were not from your mod... your lines for your scope mod are tines enough

... i used the masck for another scope lol... for sure that your scope is acurate... just i wanted to have another mask like this and to use your others acurate files from mod:

sorry for missunderstunding makman94

makman94 · 04-30-11, 07:05 PM

all 'cleared' then ,Stoianm! glad we sort this out....continue enjoying your game

Pisces · 05-02-11, 08:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dignan

Thanks. I think you are right. My problem is that I'm not getting a good target course plot because at a long distance my range readings are so inaccurate. That results in a poor speed estimation and poor AOB value. I think I just have to practice more.

Use more time between the plots. Or take the average path between a multiple of them. Time averages all errors out. ... Until it makes a course change ofcourse. Just 3 minutes is to short to make a reliable plot from.

04-30-11, 04:46 PM	#1
Dignan Seasoned Skipper Join Date: Mar 2008 Posts: 698 Downloads: 262 Uploads: 0	Stadimeter accuracy How accurate is the stadimeter? I know it's more accurate the closer you are but I still seem to get an error of about 200 - 300 meters from ranges above 5,000m and about 50 - 100 meter sized errors when I'm closer than 5,000m to the target. I'm assuming this is normal right? I'm using TDWs NewUI and the manos scopes mod 8x5 version. The only problem is that these slightly incorrect range readings will then throw off your AOB and speed calculations too. Since I switched to "map contacts off" i've had a much higher rate of misses. Is this normal with the stadimeter? __________________

04-30-11, 07:05 PM	#11
makman94 Hellas Join Date: Jul 2008 Posts: 2,325 Downloads: 182 Uploads: 7	all 'cleared' then ,Stoianm! glad we sort this out....continue enjoying your game __________________ Knowledge is the only thing that nobody can ever take from you... Mediafire page:http://www.mediafire.com/folder/da50.../Makman94_Mods

04-30-11, 06:04 PM	#7
finchOU Samurai Navy Join Date: Jan 2004 Posts: 571 Downloads: 77 Uploads: 0	Range is important...but for a firing solution target speed and AOB are the most important factors....to test this out (at least SHIII)...you can input Range, AOB, Distance and Torp speed into the targeting computer and see how that effects the torps course. All things being equal and adjusting the distance does little to affect the torps course....errors in distance...especially that small (relatively) does not really matter. Hope this helps..