Help me choose my sub sim!

[Camaero]

With so many to choose from, I am really not sure which one to get. I do have Enigma and I love it. I love the story line to it and I like that you can hop in a surface vessel too. So let’s take Enigma off the list of course.

Out of all the others, which one would you guys recommend? I am looking for high realism, good single player campaign, nice graphics, good emersion, and good community support.

I have limited experience with just about all naval games. I am usually a fly boy and play IL2 and Lock on and such!

Think this was the right place to ask such questions. If not, sorry!

Oh and by the way, if you make a recommendation, and have played Enigma, could you give me a run down of the differences and what I should expect to be different?

Thanks fellas.