How would you rate this game at the moment

Reece · 03-10-10, 08:04 PM

I think it would be interesting for those who have the game to rate Silent Hunter 5 on a scale of 1 (Epic fail) to 10 (Fantastic)!

Before voting please think seriously about the rating you give.

Ducimus · 03-10-10, 08:26 PM

>>Before voting please think seriously about the rating you give.

Been thinking about that for the last two or three days. The best thing i can say, is I prefer the PTO and fleet boats. I spent the last few years modding just that in SH4. I have alot of time, and effort invested in it all; and yet, find myself wanting to play Sh5. It has its good points, it's bad points, the usual bugs, a few inexcuseable bugs, a hell of a lot of potential, and a lead anchor stuck fast that prevents it from leaving harbor. (at least for me)

Decoman · 03-10-10, 08:34 PM

Can't we just call it Beta?

Mondaiji · 03-10-10, 08:38 PM

I gave it a 7 for what seems posible with it. Maybe i should have given more thought on the "How would you rate this game at the moment"

.

Just rateing it for what it is right now 4.

LeonTheNorse · 03-10-10, 08:43 PM

I gave it a 5.

Drm takes away 2 points for me.

Exakt · 03-10-10, 09:36 PM

I gave it a 3, SH5 feels like a public beta that we actually paid for...
Has great potential, but sadly, they shoved half of the features out the window and Bork them. It is the same with the DRM... We are the paying beta testers...

Ziggy · 03-10-10, 09:45 PM

When it is good, it is pretty good, when its bad its very bad. Between 8 and a 4 depending on the day lol. I guess a 6 but with a very high chance of a 8 in the future.

karamazovnew · 03-10-10, 10:27 PM

At the moment v1.15 (without mods) I give the game a 3:
+1 graphics
+1 TDC (I actually like the new one because we can enter data manually)
+0.5 for the interior (although you can't do much so I now wish they just made that free camera for the SH3+SH4 interiors)
+0.5 for the recognition manual (too bad the pics are too small and there's no data shown)

The score should increase with each patch as more problems are solved.

Arclight · 03-11-10, 01:37 AM

You know what the weird thing is? This is one of the most stable games I own, hasn't crashed once. Despite some missing commands and features, I'm progressing through the campaign without any game-breaking bugs. I'm getting enough tonnage to fill my objectives, so even the smaller issues aren't holding me back.

7 out of 10. 8 if they can resolve the more pressing issues (add the missing commands, tweak morale system), 9 if they can get all the planned features implemented and most bugs worked out, and a solid 10 once the modders had their go at it.

Keep in mind that a 10 in this case doesn't mean 'perfect', but 'fantastic', i.e. the best SH to date.

Vorkapitan · 03-11-10, 01:50 AM

I gave it a 7 even though I would have liked to give it more!

I'm sure after 1 or 2 patches it good go to 9 or 9+.

03-11-10, 02:05 AM

I gave it an 8, it's a great game with even greater potential.

I suspect that a few mods is all that I need to enjoy this unpolished gem for a long while.

gutted · 03-11-10, 04:58 AM

When i first got it, i felt it was like a 5 or a 6.

After considerable amounts of playing i give it high 7.

HanSolo78 · 03-11-10, 05:36 AM

Voted a 5!

And that because there are sooo much bugs, missing things... half baked things and reliquies from Sh3/4...

To finish Sh5 for a release the devs at least would need about 6 months.. probably a year!!

Letum · 03-11-10, 05:52 AM

The results might be more intresting if there is an identical poll in the SH3 forum about SH3.

Iliaz · 03-11-10, 05:56 AM

I voted for 7. Fix up the bugs and end those CTD's and it'll be a straight 8. I enjoy the Game more than I enjoyed SH3 Vanilla. The moment when the first supermods surface, this will be my new queen.

View Poll Results: How would you rate SH5
10 Points - Fantastic	5	3.97%
9 Points	2	1.59%
8 Points	16	12.70%
7 Points	26	20.63%
6 Points	18	14.29%
5 Points	12	9.52%
4 Points	13	10.32%
3 Points	11	8.73%
2 points	3	2.38%
1 Point - Epic Failure	20	15.87%
Voters: 126. You may not vote on this poll

03-10-10, 08:04 PM	#1
Reece CINC Pacific Fleet Join Date: Sep 2003 Location: Down Under Posts: 34,709 Downloads: 171 Uploads: 0	How would you rate this game at the moment I think it would be interesting for those who have the game to rate Silent Hunter 5 on a scale of 1 (Epic fail) to 10 (Fantastic)! Before voting please think seriously about the rating you give. __________________ *Sub captains go down with their ship!* Last edited by Reece; 03-10-10 at 08:17 PM.

03-10-10, 08:43 PM	#5
LeonTheNorse Swabbie Join Date: Jan 2010 Posts: 8 Downloads: 0 Uploads: 0	I gave it a 5. Drm takes away 2 points for me. __________________

03-10-10, 09:36 PM	#6
Exakt Helmsman Join Date: Dec 2009 Location: Ville de Quebec (not the HMCS) Posts: 106 Downloads: 105 Uploads: 0	I gave it a 3, SH5 feels like a public beta that we actually paid for... Has great potential, but sadly, they shoved half of the features out the window and Bork them. It is the same with the DRM... We are the paying beta testers... __________________ U-46 Leutnant z. S. Jakob Bock U-47 ObLt z. S. Jaana Galland ObLt z. S. Ernst Wagner (BdU)

03-11-10, 01:37 AM	#9
Arclight Navy Seal Join Date: Jun 2008 Location: Land of windmills, tulips, wooden shoes and cheese. Lots of cheese. Posts: 8,467 Downloads: 53 Uploads: 10	You know what the weird thing is? This is one of the most stable games I own, hasn't crashed once. Despite some missing commands and features, I'm progressing through the campaign without any game-breaking bugs. I'm getting enough tonnage to fill my objectives, so even the smaller issues aren't holding me back. 7 out of 10. 8 if they can resolve the more pressing issues (add the missing commands, tweak morale system), 9 if they can get all the planned features implemented and most bugs worked out, and a solid 10 once the modders had their go at it. Keep in mind that a 10 in this case doesn't mean 'perfect', but 'fantastic', i.e. the best SH to date. __________________ Contritium praecedit superbia.

03-10-10, 08:26 PM	#2
Ducimus Rear Admiral Join Date: May 2005 Posts: 12,987 Downloads: 67 Uploads: 2	>>Before voting please think seriously about the rating you give. Been thinking about that for the last two or three days. The best thing i can say, is I prefer the PTO and fleet boats. I spent the last few years modding just that in SH4. I have alot of time, and effort invested in it all; and yet, find myself wanting to play Sh5. It has its good points, it's bad points, the usual bugs, a few inexcuseable bugs, a hell of a lot of potential, and a lead anchor stuck fast that prevents it from leaving harbor. (at least for me)

03-10-10, 08:34 PM	#3
Decoman Frogman Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: Oslo, Norway Posts: 306 Downloads: 24 Uploads: 0	Can't we just call it Beta?

03-10-10, 08:38 PM	#4
Mondaiji Watch Join Date: Mar 2010 Posts: 18 Downloads: 9 Uploads: 0	I gave it a 7 for what seems posible with it. Maybe i should have given more thought on the "How would you rate this game at the moment" . Just rateing it for what it is right now 4.

03-10-10, 09:45 PM	#7
Ziggy Torpedoman Join Date: Mar 2010 Location: Wisconsin Posts: 111 Downloads: 14 Uploads: 0	When it is good, it is pretty good, when its bad its very bad. Between 8 and a 4 depending on the day lol. I guess a 6 but with a very high chance of a 8 in the future.

03-10-10, 10:27 PM	#8
karamazovnew The Old Man Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: Bucharest, Romania Posts: 1,403 Downloads: 151 Uploads: 0	At the moment v1.15 (without mods) I give the game a 3: +1 graphics +1 TDC (I actually like the new one because we can enter data manually) +0.5 for the interior (although you can't do much so I now wish they just made that free camera for the SH3+SH4 interiors) +0.5 for the recognition manual (too bad the pics are too small and there's no data shown) The score should increase with each patch as more problems are solved.

03-11-10, 01:50 AM	#10
Vorkapitan Samurai Navy Join Date: May 2006 Posts: 594 Downloads: 1367 Uploads: 0	I gave it a 7 even though I would have liked to give it more! I'm sure after 1 or 2 patches it good go to 9 or 9+. __________________ __________________________________________________ ________ __________________________________________________ ________ Joe

03-11-10, 02:05 AM	#11
Brewtality Stowaway Posts: n/a Downloads: Uploads:	I gave it an 8, it's a great game with even greater potential. I suspect that a few mods is all that I need to enjoy this unpolished gem for a long while.

03-11-10, 04:58 AM	#12
gutted The Old Man Join Date: Apr 2005 Location: New Orleans, LA. Posts: 1,379 Downloads: 487 Uploads: 11	When i first got it, i felt it was like a 5 or a 6. After considerable amounts of playing i give it high 7. __________________ Solution Solver 2.3.2 - Visual Targeting Tools & Aids

03-11-10, 05:36 AM	#13
HanSolo78 Sea Lord Join Date: Apr 2005 Location: Austria Posts: 1,842 Downloads: 100 Uploads: 3	Voted a 5! And that because there are sooo much bugs, missing things... half baked things and reliquies from Sh3/4... To finish Sh5 for a release the devs at least would need about 6 months.. probably a year!! __________________

03-11-10, 05:52 AM	#14
Letum Navy Seal Join Date: Feb 2005 Location: York - UK Posts: 6,079 Downloads: 43 Uploads: 0	The results might be more intresting if there is an identical poll in the SH3 forum about SH3. __________________

03-11-10, 05:56 AM	#15
Iliaz Seaman Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: Outer Heaven Posts: 37 Downloads: 2 Uploads: 0	I voted for 7. Fix up the bugs and end those CTD's and it'll be a straight 8. I enjoy the Game more than I enjoyed SH3 Vanilla. The moment when the first supermods surface, this will be my new queen. __________________ Welch' Künstler gingen an mir zu Grunde!

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode