may as well rename this SH4 Mods

read the catagory guys, this is SH3 Mods forum not SH4, 3 out of 5 posts are about SH4

if it is about a mod working for both or can be converted then it would make sense, but why fill this forum with SH4 mod questions when SH4 has it's own forum?

[Jimbuna]

No thank you
We'll keep it as SH3 mods workshop....ta very much

[poor sailor]

I think that he mean to say that post about SH4 should be posted on SH4 mods forum not to SH3. If I good understand. If I'm not, then I also like SH3 mods workshop separate then SH4. My vote in this poll was to have a separate sections http://www.subsim.com/radioroom/show...highlight=poll

[mountainmanUK]

So far as I see it, there ARE already 2 independent forums for SH3 Mods and SH4 Mods.
These work pretty well AFAIK, and I see no reason for any renaming or changing.

I think what he may be referring to, are the threads which cover 'porting' certain aspects of SH3 into SH4, or vice versa. This does sometimes make it look as if Mods for both SH versions are sharing one Forum!

All is well in both the Atlantic and Pacific Theatres of Battle.....for me anyway!

Cheers
Dave

[Boris]

Originally Posted by mountainmanUK

So far as I see it, there ARE already 2 independent forums for SH3 Mods and SH4 Mods.
These work pretty well AFAIK, and I see no reason for any renaming or changing.

I think what he may be referring to, are the threads which cover 'porting' certain aspects of SH3 into SH4, or vice versa. This does sometimes make it look as if Mods for both SH versions are sharing one Forum!

All is well in both the Atlantic and Pacific Theatres of Battle.....for me anyway!

Cheers
Dave

Only as far as you see it? Of course theres two separate mod sections, clear as night and day. And of course webster is right, SH4 modding issues should be discussed in the SH4 section. Not refuting your argument, just strengthening it...

[Hitman]

read the catagory guys, this is SH3 Mods forum not SH4, 3 out of 5 posts are about SH4

if it is about a mod working for both or can be converted then it would make sense, but why fill this forum with SH4 mod questions when SH4 has it's own forum?

Webster,

can you point me those topics? Or you mean only replies to SH3 topics? If I find stuff here that belongs the SH4 forums, I will move it there

[Reece]

I think it is in reference to the following:
http://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=112460
http://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=111664

That would be a start, yes.
They wander over asking questions on how to do
stuff.
We tell them.
Next thing you know
these GREAT Mods are released for SH4 with no thanks to the people
here that showed them how to do it.
Best part is, they ain't right!!!
:rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl:
Arse Hats all!!!

[joea]

Originally Posted by privateer

That would be a start, yes.
They wander over asking questions on how to do
stuff.
We tell them.
Next thing you know
these GREAT Mods are released for SH4 with no thanks to the people
here that showed them how to do it.
Best part is, they ain't right!!!
:rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl:
Arse Hats all!!!

Feeling alright??

[Hitman]

I think it is in reference to the following:
http://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=112460
http://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=111664

Ah I see...

Yes the first thread started as a generic call for recruiting modders (Acceptably posted here) but evolved to a discussion of the project, which is a SH4 one:hmm: OK I will let the thread be for now, but if it keeps getting replies I will consider closing it and linking to the SH4 forum.

The second one should be moved, will do in a moment.

Thanks for the headup

@privateer and Joea:

Originally Posted by Hitman

Webster,

can you point me those topics? Or you mean only replies to SH3 topics? If I find stuff here that belongs the SH4 forums, I will move it there

well i havent taken notes about it but i clicked on some posts that interested me and found nothing related to sh3 only refering to sh4 mods. i was having a bad day so i posted in frustration, normally it wouldn't have bothered me.

i was refering to actual posts not replies and now that i know who to notify i will keep track when i find them.

i realize they must have been here looking for hints and ideas for sh4 mods and posted in the wrong place so i was reminding them to notice where they were.

actually the two that reece pointed out were ok by me because they did have a connection to sh3 and were not asking for sh4 advice, the one i ran into that caused the post was this one:

http://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=112894


it's about bow waves for ships in sh4 and i had thought i had nothing to do with sh3 but later in the post he indicated it was a sh4 ship morfed to sh3 so as it turned out it was a perfectly valid post even if it wasn't clearly stated to indicate that.


it seams like every few days when i check in at subsim (about twice a week) i was finding another sh4 post in this forum. gladley this is not as big a problem as it once was.

i guess i went a little overboard with the 3 out of 5 comment.....ok maybe way overboard,

[Jimbuna]

A little overboard!!....you nigh on caused a mutiny
:rotfl: :rotfl:

[bigboywooly]

Arse hats

:rotfl:

Me like that one