Is SH5 a better game than SH3 GWX?

SNAKE1937 · 12-01-11, 01:06 PM

I have been playing SH3 GWX for years and love it. SH4 if fun and a the WW2 action is in my interest area, but a lot of small issues on handeling the crew detract from it.

Is SH5 like a better SH3 ( graphics ), or way different in other ways.

Have "ALL" of the BUGS been worked out?

Mine you it is not the cost of the game, it's how good it is to play.

Very glad to see that the controlling need to be on line has been fixed.
Though I must say that having Steam controlling Civ 5 is great. All of the updates and patches are downloaded automaticaly while playing the game.

So should I give invest some time in SH5? At age 74 My time is limited.

Thanks for your input. SNAKE1937

Hinrich Schwab · 12-01-11, 01:45 PM

While I have only had 5 for a short time, I can say with all confidence that III is still better. Vanilla SH 5 is nothing short of an Alpha release. Darkwraith's UI mod is a must. Likewise, the TDC appears to be broken, thanks to all of the silliness of including an "interactive" crew. As it stands, SH5 has way too many issues and bugs that demand further patching (i.e. "Rudder Right 180 Degrees"

) to come anywhere close to the quality of even stock SH III.

SH III works, SH 5 halfway works...even with mods. Stick with what works.

Sailor Steve · 12-01-11, 05:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SNAKE1937

I have been playing SH3 GWX for years and love it.

Considering your situation as you described it, you might want to stick with what you know. SH5 lacks several of the gameplay functions of SH3, and it may be some time before those are added in.

Quote:

Is SH5 like a better SH3 ( graphics ), or way different in other ways.

Different in many ways, some of them better and some worse, depending on what you like in the game.

Quote:

Have "ALL" of the BUGS been worked out?

"ALL" of the BUGS haven't been worked out of SH3 yet. There's just been enough work done on it that we tend to forget.

Quote:

Mine you it is not the cost of the game, it's how good it is to play.

I hope not, considering I got my copy for less than five bucks. SH5 is great to play, but it is quite different.

Quote:

So should I give invest some time in SH5? At age 74 My time is limited.

If you want a major change, give it a go. If you want a better-looking SH3, give it a pass.

Ducimus · 12-01-11, 05:29 PM

It occurs to me, SH5 really isn't a Submarine sim as any of us would think. More of a hybrid between Sim and an RPG in a Das Boat setting; doing neither particularly well.

GT182 · 12-02-11, 01:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ducimus

It occurs to me, SH5 really isn't a Submarine sim as any of us would think. More of a hybrid between Sim and an RPG in a Das Boat setting; doing neither particularly well.

But you have to admit the graphics are supurb.

Ducimus · 12-02-11, 05:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GT182

But you have to admit the graphics are supurb.

First person immersion without equal.

Personally, the RPG aspects as well as the sim aspects should be embraced and improved upon. Mainly because I think SH5 is fundamentally different from the previous two games. It's less of a submarine simulation, and more of a Uboat captain simulation. That and i've been playing entirely too many RPG's as of late, so i'm probably on some ill concieved RPG kick at the moment.

Hinrich Schwab · 12-03-11, 01:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GT182

But you have to admit the graphics are supurb.

Agreed. The graphics are very impressive. Too bad we had to trade in most of our functions and our entire control scheme to get that.

I would rather have Ok graphics with all of the old, efficient functions. Eye candy doesn't sink ships efficiently.

shagy29 · 12-05-11, 06:22 AM

both have good things and bad things
i prefer sh3,but sh5 with the help of the comunity
its cool now,imo
hasta

Sailor Steve · 12-05-11, 10:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Schwartzritter

Agreed. The graphics are very impressive. Too bad we had to trade in most of our functions and our entire control scheme to get that.

I would rather have Ok graphics with all of the old, efficient functions. Eye candy doesn't sink ships efficiently.

That's a perfect description of SH3. Nothing stops you from continuing to play it, and I still do. They felt it was time to experiment with SH5. It didn't work out quite the way they planned, but it's still a fantastic experience. Or it will be once I get a computer that runs it properly.

12-01-11, 01:06 PM	#1
SNAKE1937 Loader Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: Colorado, summer/ Arizona, winter Posts: 90 Downloads: 6 Uploads: 0	Is SH5 a better game than SH3 GWX? I have been playing SH3 GWX for years and love it. SH4 if fun and a the WW2 action is in my interest area, but a lot of small issues on handeling the crew detract from it. Is SH5 like a better SH3 ( graphics ), or way different in other ways. Have "ALL" of the BUGS been worked out? Mine you it is not the cost of the game, it's how good it is to play. Very glad to see that the controlling need to be on line has been fixed. Though I must say that having Steam controlling Civ 5 is great. All of the updates and patches are downloaded automaticaly while playing the game. So should I give invest some time in SH5? At age 74 My time is limited. Thanks for your input. SNAKE1937

12-05-11, 06:22 AM	#8
shagy29 Swabbie Join Date: Dec 2011 Location: algarve-portugal Posts: 12 Downloads: 44 Uploads: 0	hi both have good things and bad things i prefer sh3,but sh5 with the help of the comunity its cool now,imo hasta

12-01-11, 01:45 PM	#2
Hinrich Schwab Grey Wolf Join Date: Nov 2010 Posts: 908 Downloads: 89 Uploads: 0	While I have only had 5 for a short time, I can say with all confidence that III is still better. Vanilla SH 5 is nothing short of an Alpha release. Darkwraith's UI mod is a must. Likewise, the TDC appears to be broken, thanks to all of the silliness of including an "interactive" crew. As it stands, SH5 has way too many issues and bugs that demand further patching (i.e. "Rudder Right 180 Degrees" ) to come anywhere close to the quality of even stock SH III. SH III works, SH 5 halfway works...even with mods. Stick with what works.

12-01-11, 05:29 PM	#4
Ducimus Rear Admiral Join Date: May 2005 Posts: 12,987 Downloads: 67 Uploads: 2	It occurs to me, SH5 really isn't a Submarine sim as any of us would think. More of a hybrid between Sim and an RPG in a Das Boat setting; doing neither particularly well.