Dungeons & Dragons Daggerdale, released

[kiwi_2005]

This reviewer practically dogged it. Well it looks damn nice. Though its a bug feast.

Available off steam.

Dungeons & Dragons: 4th Edition represents one of the most drastic facelifts the long-running tabletop RPG franchise has ever undergone. The game's once ethereal elements have been turned tangible, its mechanics made far less punishing for new players, and its every component finely tuned to a state of balance that few other tabletop developers can match. It is as accessible as the game has ever been -- and, as a result, as adaptable as the game has ever been.

full review here:
http://www.joystiq.com/2011/05/25/du...erdale-review/

[Thomen]

I did not even know that they were working on a new DnD game until I got the email that it was released..

From what I read you correct that it seems to have 'some' bugs, but the opinions about how playable and how good it is seem to vary widely. I will buy, tho, even if it is 'just to have it'.

EDIT: It is not on Steam just yet. However, if you buy the box, it will be activated via steam.

[Egan]

4th Edition? Don't get me started on 4th Edition.....

[seaniam81]

Originally Posted by Egan

4th Edition? Don't get me started on 4th Edition.....

Haven't kept up but isn't 4th Edition dumbed down for video games.
I'll always have a soft spot for 3rd and 3.5 Editions.

[Egan]

Originally Posted by seaniam81

Haven't kept up but isn't 4th Edition dumbed down for video games.
I'll always have a soft spot for 3rd and 3.5 Editions.

They say it isn't but is does very much feel like it. I started playing with AD&D but stopped not long after 2e appeared due to other interests. I don't play at all any more but maintain an extensive library of D&D (and other RPGs,) because I still get a buzz out of reading them. I was a big Forgotten Realms fan, and Planescape and Dark Sun as well (although I never got to play either of the last too...Maybe if I luck into a new circle of aging dorks...).

I like 3e as well, and the Pathfinder rules (the natural successor) but 4e just seems....I dunno. Maybe if I was 11 or 12 again it would seem like the greatest thing ever. They claim they streamlined it to make it easier for noobs to follow but here's the kicker: the 12 year old me, and my friends, never seemed to have any problems following the rules of AD&D. Maybe we were smarter but I doubt it. Maybe we just had more willingness to learn something that we didn't immediately understand - I don't know. I do know that the current edition wars have been going on for two years now and make the fundamentalist fighting you get on sim sites looks like old ladies arguing about who gets to pay the bill. Hell hath no fury like a dork scorned.

Another reason I dislike 4e, aside from a lot of the rule changes, stupid assumptions the designers make about players, the fact it's now virtually a game centered around minis and combat, and it's crappy new magic system: the books themselves look cheap and badly designed. They actually look like manuals from a third rate CRPG.

Ah well, I'll always have AD&D and 2e and unless Wizbro instigate a policy of demanding all old books are returned to them for pulping (something I wouldn't put past them,) I always will.

[elephantium]

Originally Posted by Egan

Another reason I dislike 4e, aside from a lot of the rule changes, stupid assumptions the designers make about players, the fact it's now virtually a game centered around minis and combat,

That's a rather ironic criticism any D&D edition, considering the game's roots. Ever heard of Chainmail?

[kiwi_2005]

Originally Posted by Thomen

I did not even know that they were working on a new DnD game until I got the email that it was released..

From what I read you correct that it seems to have 'some' bugs, but the opinions about how playable and how good it is seem to vary widely. I will buy, tho, even if it is 'just to have it'.

EDIT: It is not on Steam just yet. However, if you buy the box, it will be activated via steam.

If your wanting a nice box sitting on your shelve can't bypass owning a D&D game go ahead. But if you wanting the game to play it. Don't even bother, what a mess. Can't really moan though as the game is playable (just) and its cheap. Daggerdale probably killed the 4th edition completely. The game took me little over 5 hrs to complete just doing the main quests. Why they didn't put the time into it make this game what it should of been instead of just a rushed job & a low price to say yeah its buggy. Maybe there will be patches & plenty of upcoming DLC with new dungeons? Wishful thinking.

I wont even bother to attempt multi player yet from what ive read plenty of bugs spoil the online play, lan though seems to be working okay.