I just found the first review
http://www.gamersglobal.de/test/sile...ter-5?page=0,1
its in german language, the score is 3/10. They say that the game is virtually not playable because of all these bugs. They also complain that you cant jump anymore between stations with hotkeys
Well it has bugs but for me its fully playable and im having fun with it. Sometimes the AI is realy realy dumb, like ignoring me all together while attacking a convoy and blowing ships up left and right and than in the next encounter i go like wtf because i get sunk in the first 10 minutes lol.
My personal score would be 7/10 without mods. I am 100% sure that Sh 5 will be the best sub sim ever once the first big mods are released