SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   General Topics (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=175)
-   -   I think this cop is in trouble........ (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=125493)

mapuc 11-21-07 07:19 PM

In sweden you just don't become a cop like that, apart from school, you have to meet a psychologist and if she/he see that you have to much "Rambo" inside, you can forget all about being a cop.

Markus

AVGWarhawk 11-21-07 07:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mapuc
In sweden you just don't become a cop like that, apart from school, you have to meet a psychologist and if she/he see that you have to much "Rambo" inside, you can forget all about being a cop.

Markus

They do the same in the states. I went to University of Maryland and received my degree in Criminal Justice.(really just 4 years of heavy drinking and parties:p ) I applied to the Montgomery County Police Department. I had to take a lie detector test, oral exam, written exam and psychological exam. When I hit the physical eye exam, I got nixed. The rule is 20/70 vision if my glasses are off. I did not make that grade and was summarily dismissed. Just as well, watching a few episodes of COPS made me glad I did not pass the eye exam. Even so, clever Rambos can get by and some that are not Rambos become Rambos later on when they are behind the badge.

In all reality, the cop in this instance lost control of the traffic stop. It seemed to me he became agitated with the driver and in turn acted out the agitation. He should have stayed calm and explained in calming voice why the driver was stopped. He took the other route and took on the challenge knowing full well he held the all cards. He decided to call his hand and used undo force. The is nothing in that video that would indicate the officer was in control of the traffic stop and what was learned before hitting the streets to enforce the law was not adhered to. He can hear the officer telling the second officer that the driver thought he was in control of the traffic stop. Your first contact with the driver is the time to set the tone of the traffic stop. In LESS than a minute, the officer lost control of the stop which escalated into what we have witnessed.

Ducimus 11-21-07 11:00 PM

The force was a tad excessive, but overall, id have to side with the cop.

-, the guy was a smart ass.

- you don't argue with the cops. They're already edgy from dealing with alot of scumbags. They give you an instruction, you do it promptly, and precisely unless it places you in iniment danger, you can argue about it later in court.


- The trooper told him FOUR TIMES to turn around and put his hands behind his back. FOUR, and he still continued to not comply. Probably in self arrogance that no matter what, he was right and the cop was wrong. The fact that the trooper held a taser AT him, should be warning enough, combine that with 4 verbal warnings.

- he put his hands in his pockets and walked towards the car. BIG NO NO. Cops have a hand fetish. They want to see what your hands are doing at all times. Hands are dangerous because they can hold things like guns and knives. cops have the same allergy to cold steel and hot lead that we do.

Here is where i have my disagreement. In retrospect, he should have just put him in an arm lock that disables you and forces you to the ground (they're trained to do that, and it hurts like hell, but its definatly no taser),

Only thing the cop didn't say, was how fast the guy was going. he did say why he pulled him over, but didnt say how much over the speed limit. He did tell him why he was arresting him. He was right in the arrest, but wrong in the method used.

Now all that said, this cop was strung out and needs to go on vacation. One thing ive learned during my stint in the service is, the badge and the uniform give him the authority, you have to respect that. But the man inside the uniform is another story. Some of them are strung out, some of them are not. Its not a case of, legality, its a case of judging human character. You can see it in the mans eyes, and that tells you what you can, or cannot do, or what he will, or will not tolerate. Thats a here and now judgement call, you can argue the rest in court later.

swifty 11-22-07 01:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ducimus
The force was a tad excessive, but overall, id have to side with the cop.

-, the guy was a smart ass.

That is not an excuse to teaser some on or even escalate the situation to an unnecessary arrest.

Quote:

- you don't argue with the cops. They're already edgy from dealing with a lot of scumbags. They give you an instruction, you do it promptly, and precisely unless it places you in eminent danger, you can argue about it later in court.
Cops should know better they don't need to argue back. The drive stated he did not know the limit was 40 (The max limit in Utah is 75 one of the highest in the US) and was driving at 68. It seemed like a genuine case of knot knowing the speed limit dropped. At the start of the video you can clearly see a 40 mph construction sign. The office actually pulls over in front of it and quite possible obstructs the view. When driver exited the vehicle he wanted to see the sign and thought the officer was going to show it to him.

Quote:

- The trooper told him FOUR TIMES to turn around and put his hands behind his back. FOUR, and he still continued to not comply. Probably in self arrogance that no matter what, he was right and the cop was wrong. The fact that the trooper held a taser AT him, should be warning enough, combine that with 4 verbal warnings.
It appears he was in shock. First he tells him to put his hands behind his back before saying hes was arrested. In fact he never says he ins under arrest. When an officer pulls a gun on you when you have no weapons and are not physically being aggressive it throw you off guard. It appears he turns his body and walks away instinctively.

Quote:

- he put his hands in his pockets and walked towards the car. BIG NO NO. Cops have a hand fetish. They want to see what your hands are doing at all times. Hands are dangerous because they can hold things like guns and knives. cops have the same allergy to cold steel and hot lead that we do.
The officer had already pulled the teaser before his hands went into his pocket. and fires before hands hands leave has pocket.

The officer takes an aggressive attitude throughout the ordeal up until the other office arrives on scene. He then has the nerve to joke about teasering him.:nope:
After that he than performs an illegal search hoping to find drugs or a weapon to cover his ass.

It all started with the officer refusing to answer questions and trying to force the driver to sign. I don't know the law in Utah but in Florida the driver has the right to ask any questions before signing and officer must make sure the driver understands everything thing before allowing him to sign.

Know he may have done it after the video cut off but the at now time did he tell him what he was arrested for. He even asked to be mirandized and the officer refused that starts to fall under the lines of illegal detainment.

There is no excuse for the officers actions :down:.

If it was me i would have demanded an ambulance, his supervisor and a lawyer before letting the officer take me to jail. I hope the driver sues the officer and the department for every thing he can think of.

Dowly 11-22-07 01:40 AM

Now here's an officer who knows how to keep his cool. ;)
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=GHZMoPV1rog

CCIP 11-22-07 01:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dowly
Now here's an officer who knows how to keep his cool. ;)
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=GHZMoPV1rog

"bye"

:rotfl:

:up::up::up:

There's a true role model. Really puts the guy in that first video to shame.

Ducimus 11-22-07 04:11 AM

The bottom line in any altercation where force is used, is that the public is almost always sided against the cop. Its just a given. I have to wonder if Taser's are a bit overhyped in what level of force they are considered. Their basically a ranged stun gun. yeah i imagine it hurts like hell, but the real question to me is, how much acutal bodily harm does it do? Aparently not much, the guy was up and walking about a minute later.

Now i still say the cop was a dick long overdue for a vaction. But i also think that civy was an arrogant punk. If he had been less of a punk, he woudlnt have been jacked up.

Kapitan_Phillips 11-22-07 05:08 AM

I dont like how people are now starting to generalise all cops. In any public service profession you'll get *******s with playing cards in their hats and an itchy finger. However, the vast majority of cops do quite a good job, and you Americans should be proud of that. Look what we have here - a couple guys who'll slap your wrist for a murder and make you pick litter up for a few months.

VipertheSniper 11-22-07 06:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dowly
Now here's an officer who knows how to keep his cool. ;)
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=GHZMoPV1rog

Man for the three or more "*sshole" you can be assured you pay atleast 21€ more.

AVGWarhawk 11-22-07 06:39 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dowly
Now here's an officer who knows how to keep his cool. ;)
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=GHZMoPV1rog


The Trooper is in control the entire time. He looked like a darn big dude who could bend you into a pretzel:o. I think I would have signed and moved on myself. He let the man vent for his 4 minutes and never took a defensive posture possible letting this escalate into an arrest.

AVGWarhawk 11-22-07 06:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by VipertheSniper
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dowly
Now here's an officer who knows how to keep his cool. ;)
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=GHZMoPV1rog

Man for the three or more "*sshole" you can be assured you pay atleast 21€ more.

This is were you 'feelings getting hurt' should not muddle your judgment. Street level justice should be based on what you know and what the law states.

AVGWarhawk 11-22-07 06:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kapitan_Phillips
I dont like how people are now starting to generalise all cops. In any public service profession you'll get *******s with playing cards in their hats and an itchy finger. However, the vast majority of cops do quite a good job, and you Americans should be proud of that. Look what we have here - a couple guys who'll slap your wrist for a murder and make you pick litter up for a few months.

There are good cop/bad cop forces out there. All in all they do a great job and quite frankly their job sucks. Verbal abuse, physical abuse and mental toll after witnessing bad things. They do see some crazy crap. Even so, they must tackle everyday with their head on straight.

LukeFF 11-22-07 07:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dowly
Now here's an officer who knows how to keep his cool. ;)
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=GHZMoPV1rog

:rotfl::rotfl::rotfl::rotfl::rotfl:

Makes me glad I just work in police dispatch and not actually out on the streets.

LukeFF 11-22-07 07:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swifty
After that he than performs an illegal search hoping to find drugs or a weapon to cover his ass.

Officers have the right to search your vehicle when they pull you over. It doesn't matter if it's for speeding, an illegal U-turn, or having a headlight out.

Other than that, I'm going to have to side with Ducimus here. He was told he passed notl only that 40mph sign seen in the vidoe but also another one farther back. The kid was warned multiple times to comply, yet he didn't comply and started walking back towards the vehicle. How does the officer know he's not going to jump in the vehicle and drive off? Or reach under the seat and pull out a gun?

Happy Times 11-22-07 11:12 AM

He explains the situation a bit different to the other cop. Like the situation was prolonged and he repeatly gave instructions and warned about the taser.
He doesnt belong to his job.:nope:

Dowly 11-22-07 02:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Happy Times
He explains the situation a bit different to the other cop. Like the situation was prolonged and he repeatly gave instructions and warned about the taser.
He doesnt belong to his job.:nope:

Yeh, noticed that too. Phew, drama-queen. :p

AVGWarhawk 11-22-07 02:24 PM

Quote:

Officers have the right to search your vehicle when they pull you over. It doesn't matter if it's for speeding, an illegal U-turn, or having a headlight out.
Only if the officer has 'probable cause'. Illegal search and seizure is not allowed. Permission can be asked before the arrest. After the arrest, searching the vehicle is fair game.

AVGWarhawk 11-22-07 02:28 PM

Something else is very funny here. The cop pulls over in front of the 40 mph sign. As the truck passes him then the pursuit starts. Now if the truck is driving the same speed as the officer (we can assume as he was behind the cop before he pulled over infront of the sign and then proceeded to pursue after he passed), the cop was baiting the driver. The cops are to do the speed limit. If he is blowing down the road then others well blow down the road at the same speed he is doing. It does not make speeding right at this point but if the cop is above the speed limit he is then baiting others to do the same.

Dowly 11-22-07 02:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AVGWarhawk
Something else is very funny here. The cop pulls over in front of the 40 mph sign. As the truck passes him then the pursuit starts. Now if the truck is driving the same speed as the officer (we can assume as he was behind the cop before he pulled over infront of the sign and then proceeded to pursue after he passed), the cop was baiting the driver. The cops are to do the speed limit. If he is blowing down the road then others well blow down the road at the same speed he is doing. It does not make speeding right at this point but if the cop is above the speed limit he is then baiting others to do the same.

I agree. If the cop isnt 'on-call' then he should drive by the limits. If I was somewhere I havent been to before and not familiar with the roads & limits and saw a police car drive at certain speed without flashes on, I'd assume that he is driving within the limit.

AVGWarhawk 11-22-07 03:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dowly
Quote:

Originally Posted by Happy Times
He explains the situation a bit different to the other cop. Like the situation was prolonged and he repeatly gave instructions and warned about the taser.
He doesnt belong to his job.:nope:

Yeh, noticed that too. Phew, drama-queen. :p

It almost seems as if he is trying to convince himself (other officer) that he handled this in the correct way.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:17 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.