Estimates of submarine detection ranges

[satyen]

Has anyone over here seen these articles

Estimates of submarine detection ranges
(https://fas.org/spp/eprint/snf03222.htm)https://fas.org/spp/eprint/snf03222.htm

The Future of Russia's Strategic Nuclear Forces
Discussions and Arguments (https://fas.org/spp/eprint/snf0322.htm)
https://fas.org/spp/eprint/snf0322.htm

They are very interesting and I was wondering if anyone can verify if the info is accurate

Cheers!

[Kapitan]

Some what dated now and alot of tech has rapidly moved on ! back in 95 most subs used push buttons now touch screen and fibre optic!

The Russian links are what was published by Janes is loosely accurate the SS-N-20 RSM-39 missile is know to have a range of just over 10,000km (not 8300km as posted) so there are inaccuracies due to age of articles.

Whats more there wouldn't be a person on here that would confirm to you modern today specs its just not done, what we often talk about is hypothosis based on available public information educated guesses and informed judgements.

[ikalugin]

I mean I do have official specs for the 2015 vintage Improved Kilo export sonar from the Okeanpribor catalog, so you sort of can verify some of the models.

[satyen]

I thought the article was interesting even if it was dated, I felt most of the hardware numbers they calculated could still be of some use to our community.
fascinating read if nothing else :)

[Kapitan]

I mean I do have official specs for the 2015 vintage Improved Kilo export sonar from the Okeanpribor catalog, so you sort of can verify some of the models.


very interesting care to share ?

[ikalugin]

Not without an equivalent quality source material being shared.

[Kapitan]

I am open to discussion :up: